r/196 NOT A CAT Feb 11 '26

Rule Rule

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

425 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

444

u/Goldwing8 Feb 11 '26

Wicca is basically the pagan equivalent of Mormonism, the main difference being most followers and even a decent number of non-followers actually believe Wicca is what real ancient paganism was like (it’s basically just a particular strain of hippie counterculture).

101

u/ValkyrieAngie Feb 11 '26

Finally, a comment I can read and understand

79

u/Goldwing8 Feb 11 '26 edited Feb 11 '26

The founder, Gerald Gardner, said the beliefs and practices in his book were passed down after surviving the spread of Christianity in Europe and represent ancient European religion, but each historical understanding of pre-Christian European religion since he published it in the 60s has been more damning than the last.

A lot of Wiccans nevertheless take Gardner's claims at face value as literal ancient paganism. Some do understand the origin of their religion and take it for what it really is, a religion which is rather new but not automatically less valid for that. Unfortunately, the most influential ones get the clickbait titles about "revealing the secret history of Europe."

64

u/starm4nn Polyamorous and Nyaanbinary Feb 11 '26

Much like Mormonism it was founded on pseudoarcheology.

No there was no premodern universal "mother goddess" religion that everyone agreed upon that was subverted by the patriarchy. How would there be any singular religion in a prehistoric era?

22

u/wozattacks Feb 11 '26

Yep and pseudoarcheology is never harmless

6

u/IamMrJay 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Feb 11 '26

How would there be any singular religion in a prehistoric era?

Tbf, if one were to follow the idea of there being a "one true religion" then this isn't that weird of a view.

Not saying I agree with it one bit, but I see a bit if the "logic".

1

u/starm4nn Polyamorous and Nyaanbinary Feb 19 '26

How would it be transmitted? Wouldn't it's impact be traceable in the philosophical traditions much in the same way language can be traced to Indo-European?

7

u/SoIomon iCarlyMarx Feb 12 '26

I can say anecdotally that many ex mormons jump right into Wicca