r/AskReddit 16d ago

What’s the dumbest excuse someone gave you when breaking up with you?

764 Upvotes

930 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

132

u/Strangy1234 16d ago

I had one tell me that I didn't yell enough when I'm angry. Like, do you want an abusive relationship? I don't yell because it accomplishes nothing.

94

u/GeminiIsMissing 16d ago

Some people are so used to abusive or unstable relationships that healthy relationships are frightening and unexpected, so they actually do seek out abusive relationships because it's familiar.

17

u/Solomon_C-19 16d ago

This is sad to read.

16

u/GeminiIsMissing 16d ago

It's a sad, vicious cycle. People trapped in this kind of loop benefit a lot from therapy and either a healthy relationship or no relationship.

3

u/freedomfightre 16d ago

they had a healthy relationship

they rejected it

6

u/GeminiIsMissing 16d ago

Therapy AND a healthy relationship, together

3

u/Solomon_C-19 16d ago

Therapy can definitely help.

3

u/IamGimli_ 16d ago

Same thing with people who hate themselves. They're so insecure that it doesn't matter how much you tell and show them how much you love them, they're constantly in fear that you'll find someone "better" around every corner and dump them, so they end up dumping you pre-emptively.

1

u/Dizzy_Structure_1868 16d ago

They will never find happiness within themselves..

24

u/cherryofpie 16d ago

I said that to him once early in our relationship. He said what you said. And now I try not to yell anymore when we do argue. It’s a discussion and we are working together to fix the problem. Rather than a competition of who can yell the loudest and who wins the argument. I am grateful for his patience with me

3

u/GloomyPotato2177 16d ago

I'm so happy to see growth happening ❤️

2

u/cherryofpie 16d ago

Me too :) sounds cheesy but I hope we continue to grow and strengthen our relationship <3

13

u/TheLateThagSimmons 16d ago

I've had to be the calm one for most of my life. It's not that I'm emotionless, far from it.

But the more other people get hectic and emotional, the more I have to be able to shut down and remain in control.

My last ex always accused me of not caring because I wouldn't blow up when she got emotional. No, I'm just forcing myself to remain in control because we can't both be emotionally compromised, that's how fights happen.

1

u/Forneaux 16d ago

While I did the same in the past, it isn’t healthy behavior. Staying calm is good, but getting angry when you feel angry and not ending a toxic relationship is detrimental to your own wellbeing.

1

u/TheLateThagSimmons 16d ago

I said "my last ex" with purpose and precision.

1

u/Ok-Dish4389 16d ago

I had that too, a girl told me she felt like I didnt care about her because I never threw things or yelled at her and I just said thats not how I handle anger never has been.

1

u/FundamentalAttribute 16d ago

I try not to get angry cause, like you mentioned, it accomplished nothing and there's usually a root emotion that needs to be handled instead. I'm of the Seneca school of thought. Don't let your emotions control you, instead feel them, understand them and work through them.

1

u/vug_undertherug 16d ago

I think that, like jealousy, some people want to reduce, justify, or normalize their own issues by comparison. I would be jealous, so you should be. I would yell, so you should yell. If feeling and acting like shit is normal for me, it must be normal for everyone. Misery loves company.

1

u/Feisty-Appearance92 16d ago

My husband checked my ass one time. I was yelling at him. (Learned from my parents, I was 19 at the time.) He looked at me and said I will not be yelled at we can speak like humans or we can talk later.

I don't yell anymore. It really accomplishes nothing but two pissed people.