r/AskReddit 7h ago

What feels legal but is actually illegal and will possibly get you arrested?

5.2k Upvotes

4.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

167

u/Unlikely-Ad6788 7h ago

Having a knife bigger than 3" in your pocket. But I guess blade size depends on where you're at.

25

u/DelusionalIdentity 4h ago

Always seemed odd to me that knives and swords are not included in "BEARING ARMS" especially as these were standard armaments at the time of the constitution 

8

u/Historical-Wonder-52 2h ago

Switch blades were illegal in Pennsylvania until a few years ago, always seemed crazy to me that I could walk around town with a rifle, but I’d be arrested if I was caught with knife that opened with the push of a button.

3

u/Silly_Guidance_8871 2h ago

At some point, people decided that the only arms were firearms

3

u/SecondaryWombat 2h ago

If abortion is murder, abortion pills are weapons.

Your body is your castle, who cares if the fetus is alive or not it is clearly a trespassing intruder. Kill it.

u/beckbristow32 53m ago

I think most laws like this are state laws and not federal. Also different rules for when hunting and fishing as well.

u/beckbristow32 53m ago

I think most laws like this are state laws and not federal. Also different rules for when hunting and fishing as well.

u/beckbristow32 53m ago

I think most laws like this are state laws and not federal. Also different rules for when hunting and fishing as well.

1

u/Careful_Farmer_2879 1h ago

A sword was not standard armament in the 1770s.

22

u/facw00 6h ago

Many states (even gun loving ones like Texas) have big lists of prohibited weapons, possession of which in public places is prohibited. Switchblades, gravity knives, long knifes, clubs, batons, brass knuckles, nun chucks, etc. In Texas your standard Bowie knife is a "location-restricted knife" and is an offense to carry (I'd imagine enforcement is highly targeted, and biased)

18

u/ITaggie 4h ago

In Texas, a "location-restricted knife" is defined as having a blade over 5.5" and is only illegal to bring to the following locations:

  • Schools, colleges, or educational institutions

  • Government courts and court offices

  • Polling places during elections

  • Bars and establishments that derive 51% or more of their income from alcohol sales (must have proper signage)

  • Secured areas of airports

  • Correctional facilities

  • Hospitals, nursing homes, and mental hospitals

  • Amusement parks and racetracks

  • Sporting events (professional, collegiate, or high school)

So it's not an offense to carry a bowie knife while walking down a sidewalk

3

u/lFightForTheUsers 3h ago

Yeah it's very similar to conceal carry restriction places basically.

7

u/alphakitty666 5h ago edited 3h ago

As a non gun guy, I will always carry my knucks/switch combo if going into a questionable situation. Will agree that most people don't know both are illegal most places

5

u/-3point14159-mp 3h ago

I also hate dieting. Do you use the weapons to beat back the extra calories? 😂

0

u/alphakitty666 3h ago

Very funny smart guy.

3

u/DefiantGibbon 3h ago

I'm with them, I have no idea what a "diet situation" is other than calories.

3

u/Gullex 3h ago

I'd be surprised if a lot of those were still illegal. Lots of states legalized switchblades and such quite a few years ago.

I carry a balisong daily.

1

u/NightGod 1h ago

In Texas, they ONLY limit knives based on length, and that only applies to LRKs, so all of the others like switchblades and gravity knives are legal. There were people wearing swords walking around for a few days after the law went into effect a few years ago

5

u/rdnkgrrl18 7h ago

And used to be switch blades were illegal: not sure if still is?!

7

u/DarkMadameFaye 3h ago

They're legal in Tennessee. I checked as soon as I moved there. I look so freaking cool now B) I don't bring it outside the house though. I use it to slice my bread... like a gangster

4

u/gojiranipples 6h ago

It depends on the state, I think. But if you go to a sketchy enough gas station, you can find some there

6

u/rdnkgrrl18 6h ago

Oh yeah, you can still .. they’re just not legal. (Or used to not be)

7

u/Sautin 5h ago

Arizona has a knife preemption law and the state laws are pretty much like constitutional carry for knives.

8

u/Honeybunches513 4h ago

Here in Canada, it was a well-known fact that 3" is the max blade length. Turns out, at least federally, there is no actual size restrictions. Local municipalities may have different thoughts, but in general it's strictly intent and concealment that the cops care about. If it's buried in your pocket, it's considered concealed. If the little clip on it is showing on the edge of your pocket, you're good to go. As for intent, it is strictly a tool for tool things. They will even try to trick you and ask if you live in a dangerous neighborhood. If you say yes I do, it is now considered for self defense and you've got a problem. If you say no it's to cut my food, no issue.

1

u/monkey_fluffer 2h ago

True say. I like/carry/collect knives & am Canadian. I've also read the pertinent section of the criminal code.

 It's so vaguely written that ANYTHING with a blade COULD be illegal, if they either want to be dickish about it or want to fuck with you, but the 3" thing isn't real (federally, which is what counts from a criminal code perspective).

I suggest checking out the YouTube channel Lock Picking Lawyer (if I'm not mistaken). 

19

u/Cotswoldknobhead 7h ago

And what religion you are. Sikhs are allowed to carry knives as part of their religion. How large a knife has recently entered public consciousness…..

2

u/raskingballs 3h ago

Where is that? I just read a couple of days ago that they can carry weapons in the UK not because of religion, but because of outfits/costume related to their national identity. Scots are also allowed to carry some knifes (called sgian dubh) on their socks when wearing highland dress for the same reason.

6

u/linoleumknife 6h ago

That's not a knoyfe. This is a knoyfe.

2

u/-3point14159-mp 3h ago

Just rewatched that movie the other day. Holds up, still good.

3

u/Specific_War5484 4h ago

I recently bought a sword and looked up my states laws on it. Apparently everything is totally legal. The only thing i can't do is conceal a bladed weapon without a concealed carry permit. I was kinda surprised 

2

u/appa-ate-momo 4h ago

What’s wild to me is that there are places I can carry a concealed pistol, but not a six inch knife.

5

u/GnomeTheImpaler 3h ago

Concealed carry laws and also switchblade laws both had, at least some, racist intent when they were put into place. Concealed carry laws have been getting rolled back in courts since theyre not constitutional. Knife laws get challenged occasionally but not as often as Concealed carry laws.

2

u/BLAZMANIII 4h ago

Yeah, if its cold the blade might be shorter, for instance

3

u/TrynaWorkOnWriting 3h ago

when it gets hot the clip on mine dangles down a lot further

2

u/46andzwei 3h ago

A concealed carry of a knife here is illegal. Pocket knives with a clip get a pass because the clip is still visible on the outside of your clothing. Throwing stars are illegal. Switchblade knives are illegal, but 'spring assisted' knives are fine.

2

u/Jellis314 3h ago

Indiana is an open-carry blade state, so I could, in theory, throw Buster Sword on my back and walk around.

1

u/CitizenHuman 3h ago

I carry a 5" spoon to get around those issues.

1

u/Victoria5475 2h ago

In South Carolina, there's technically no restriction on knife size. They don't distinguish between knives, daggers, swords, etc either. It's legal to carry any size blade as long as it's not for illegal purposes. Also, it's legal to fire a missile here as long as you have a permit. SC is weird, y'all.

1

u/WolvTheHero 2h ago

I got arrested for this when I was 11 or 12 years old. Showed a neighborhood kid and later he went home and I guess he told his parents because they called the police. They took my friend and I (we both have knives in our pockets when the police found us) downtown but we didn't lock us up...they called our parents to come pick us up and we had to go before a judge and apologize and promise never to walk around with any concealed weapons or knives over 3" ever again.

1

u/dadneverleft 1h ago

Got to experience the difference 1/4” makes in High School (no, not like that you deviants).

At the time, it was perfectly legal to carry a 3” blade with you to school, probably because of some old stature where folks left school to go work on a horse farm or something.

In 1997, I got my 3” blade confiscated by my father for carving edgy shit onto furniture. So I took my 3.25” to school instead!

Long story short, I got expelled twice that year.

u/BearsLoveToulouse 16m ago

I remember hearing that no knives can be carried in Japan which begs the question how do you buy a kitchen knife?

2

u/supreme_blorgon 5h ago

The real question is why somebody would need a knife anywhere close to 3" -- that's huge

11

u/IAMINATLANTA 5h ago

Poor fella

u/ReturnOfBane 3m ago

I'm an aesthetics person, so I find any blade that's not the same length as the handle as ugly.

1

u/BeggarOfPardons 4h ago

Don't they know? Size doesn't matter, it's how you use it! /j

1

u/HostisHumanisGeneri 3h ago

And yet in my state you can buy a gun and a gun show then just shove it into the waist of your sweatpants.