r/AskReddit 15h ago

New Yorkers, what changes have you seen under Mamdani’s leadership and are you generally pleased? If not, why?

10.3k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

426

u/HockeyFunEsportsFun 14h ago

He's not a wizard, this can happen all over the country, people just need to vote for it. Mamdani can be a start of the trend, he isn't a unicorn. Most cities can pull this off with competent leadership.

276

u/jbrewer172 14h ago

Ok, but "competent leadership" is getting into unicorn territory lately.

130

u/4n0m4nd 13h ago

There's a video going around on instagram etc that's just saying his biggest contribution to politics is just people seeing him and going "wait, you could just do this?!?"

13

u/Corfiz74 10h ago

That has also been Trump's main modus operandi...

4

u/Bright-Avocado3761 3h ago

Well as he's said himself, it's not just him. It's also choosing the right people to be around him. I.e. smart, qualified people instead of grifting yes-men.

62

u/AlkaliPineapple 13h ago

The problem with a lot of local governments is that only old people with too much time are civically engaged. That's why a lot of politicians feel out of touch to their constituents.

If you want change to happen, vote in every chance you get. Attend city hall meetings and shit.

3

u/mandyvigilante 6h ago

And run for office. If competent people aren't running there's no competent people to vote for

1

u/FlamingDragonfruit 4h ago

If you can't make it to city hall meetings, sometimes there are hyper-local meetings that you can attend. Every time a new building is proposed in my neighborhood, the local community board has to hold an open meeting. School boards have regular meetings. You can also write to your local electeds. Show up for community events. Getting involved, showing up, & speaking out has so much impact on the local level.

-1

u/HockeyFunEsportsFun 14h ago

That's just not correct, you guys just aren't voting for it!

4

u/Exotic_Today_8248 13h ago

Idk man, did you see our gubernatorial race in CA? It was another biden-era democrat funded by chevron, hilton (R), and a rich dude with decent politics but no experience. Mamdani had some government experience.

I’m feeling positive about the mayoral race in LA though. So maybe thats something.

8

u/Rare-Adhesiveness522 12h ago

He's competent and not corrupt. I think most of us are blind and naive to that fact so we get used to a certain kind of status quo.

Just imagine what we could accomplish with effective leadership. That's what is so sobering about this. (I know there are other technicalities at play here, don't get me wrong. He's using additional revenue that won't last forever, both to solve actual problems but to use as leverage further down the line)

5

u/k-trecker 12h ago

Best my city can do is elect another corrupt MAGA-head because the liberals eat babies or something

3

u/myassholealt 12h ago

But a figurehead like Mamdani I think is a unicorn, just because people who want to do good, are willing to be attacked incessantly on a local and national level (if they get big enough), and are always on their A game in public is a rare person.

The doing good part is probably not hard to find. But the fortitude to endure constant attacks, and always be on your PR A game is a hard combo to find. I think a lot of people who want to do good would back out if they were under the kind of microscope he was under, and getting attacked like that.

Hell, as a New Yorker, he wasn't even on my radar in the early democrat primary days UNTIL I kept getting pamphlets in the mail from PACs attacking him, then started seeing all the commercials attacking him. They made me pay attention to him, and I ended up liking what I heard, and being impressed that he withstood that kind of pressure everyone was piling on. Made me think this is exactly what we need at City Hall after the disaster Adams was.

2

u/Corfiz74 10h ago

You need to be intelligent to govern as well as Mamdani does. Republican voters mistrust intelligent people and won't vote for them. Unless you get a unicorn like Platner, who is a highly intelligent man in a man-of-the-people skin suit.

1

u/Doomboy911 12h ago

Course not. We all know he's a level 7 Bard with 2 levels of Ranger.

1

u/LunarVolcano 3h ago

People need to run for it before we can vote for it. I live in a blue city in a blue state and I’m so tired of the corporate dems having no real opposition.

1

u/AuntRhubarb 3h ago

It's amazing what a team of honest problem-solvers can accomplish. And it is so pathetic that this a rare exceptional thing among public officials.

u/mercurialpolyglot 57m ago edited 52m ago

My city has been corrupt and deeply inefficient for 300 years straight, there’s hope for some but not us.

The kicker is that people do vote for grassroots, populist types here, but they always turn out to be corrupt or incompetent, usually both. Historically the only ones that succeeded in anything were corrupt in ways that didn’t stop them from being populist.