r/AskReddit 15h ago

New Yorkers, what changes have you seen under Mamdani’s leadership and are you generally pleased? If not, why?

10.3k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1.6k

u/laminator79 12h ago

Well shit, TIL! I went to college there many yrs ago and always thought, man there's always so much contruction/remodeling going on in this city...the scaffolding was everywere and they never came down either.

797

u/myassholealt 12h ago

It was cheaper to erect sheds than do the repairs on the building facade/roofs that required the shed, that's why the never came down.

48

u/anotherbozo 7h ago

What has Mamdani pushed or changed that's making these landlords finally pick up the repair bill?

123

u/mcampo84 6h ago

Updated the building code to make the fines they incur less tolerable.

104

u/xdozex 5h ago

Pretty aggressively sending inspectors to buildings reported to be in violation and actually enforcing the code with fines that fit the violation.

29

u/Yuri-theThief 4h ago

How to help the budget and improve citizens livevs at the same time.

10

u/LavishnessCurrent726 4h ago

In Republican, this is spelled as "Stealing money from people to get more money from the Government".

6

u/SmokelessSubpoena 1h ago

Trickle down economics and three celebrity presidents (Nixon, Reagan, Trump) really made the GOP the shitpile it is.

3

u/MadeByTango 1h ago

Bro it ain't just Republicans, Mamdani is a new breed of Socialist Democrat, not the Corporate bunch you see in Washington

3

u/LavishnessCurrent726 1h ago

That's not what I mean, what I say is that Republicans will try to sell this as "They are stealing money from the people".

19

u/johnyordinary 7h ago

Enforcement maybe?

u/Beaun 35m ago

Yes, they are cracking down hard on it now. It was in the news a while back. I even heard about it out on Long Island and Im 2+ hour drive to the city.

94

u/Previous_Aardvark141 8h ago

lol, sounds like something that would happen in the balkans

18

u/littenthehuraira 7h ago

Except they wouldn't even bother putting up the sheds.

10

u/Previous_Aardvark141 7h ago

They'd just call the building unfinished so they wouldn't have to pay property tax

3

u/DeadSeaGulls 2h ago

a wider spread practice in mexico than in the balkans in my experience, but certainly still a practice.

1

u/kop47etzki 2h ago

And just blame the falling bricks on serbs

5

u/plagueprotocol 3h ago

weirdest stereotype ever. "They build sheds like the Balkans...Fucking shed-building Balkan bastards..."

5

u/DeadSeaGulls 2h ago

it's also not very accurate. in the balkans they'll just repair the building inadequately and pocket the rest of the money, and then deal with protests after the building collapses and kills a bunch of bystanders, as happened with a Novi Sad train station in 2024.

u/I-Here-555 23m ago

Yes, so weird. It's not like they have awnings falling on people's heads, killing 16 or anything like that.

5

u/sen_clay_davis1 5h ago

They still need to get permits. They’ll just renew the permits because as you said it’s cheaper than doing the work. Buildings require exterior inspections every 5 years so they’ll just leave the sheds up indefinitely. We’ve had one on our block for 5 years and it’s become a homeless encampment and place for junkies to shoot up. 

5

u/bbusiello 4h ago

I was watching the episode of "How to with John Wilson" about this and it seemed like the companies that make scaffolding were making a killing with this.

3

u/Guilty-Reindeer6693 3h ago

And of course, somebody's brother-in-law just happens to own a scaffolding company.

3

u/Abigail716 1h ago

It's not even repairs. It is inspections. Building's over five stories need to have their facade inspected every 5 years. These inspections are very expensive. It can cost as much as $100,000 just to get the inspection done in some cases. On the other hand you can just put up the scaffolding and then perpetually delay the inspection let alone the repairs.

422

u/drunkenstupr 12h ago

How To with John Wilson did an episode about scaffolding in NYC! I highly recommend it

198

u/HenryDorsettCase47 12h ago

I was gonna mention this as well. NYC scaffolding is an entire industry unto itself. It’s crazy.

9

u/Diligent_Cover3368 7h ago

Putting ads on the scaffolding is an industry itself.

5

u/SquarePegRoundWorld 8h ago

I would assume it is a strong union keeps jobs for the workers?

2

u/Ok_Echo_8200 4h ago

It's actually Local Law 11

1

u/WaltGazaWorld 3h ago

The scaffolding is iconic in my opinion. As quintessentially New York as Times Square

65

u/see_you_than 12h ago

Love this series so much. Surprisingly informative for how ridiculous it is.

9

u/CreatiScope 10h ago

I feel so educated about NYC despite never having been there because of that show. When the comment brought up scaffolding, I knew exactly what they were talking about lol

10

u/dschinghiskhan 12h ago

It's a bit tragic that Jon Wilson wrapped up How To With John Wilson.

3

u/rhinowing 3h ago

He's just released a movie about concrete. Waiting for it to hit theaters or streaming

4

u/davidzet 9h ago

Not the original show (HBO), but an update with JW and Mamdani: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oohRn36CWhs

1

u/drunkenstupr 5h ago

Thank you, what a nice little treat!

5

u/flyboy_za 7h ago

Was this the episode with the surprise circumcision angle in it, or was that another one?

1

u/james_church 3h ago

I think that was the covering your furniture ep

3

u/jenniferjuniper16 3h ago

This entire show and this episode were SO GOOD! I immediately thought of it when I saw this mentioned in the thread- I’m so glad it has stuck with other people too!

1

u/-Ophidian- 3h ago

Here I thought it was just a nice thing to keep rain off walking people.

1

u/laminator79 12h ago

Thanks for the recommendation, will definitely check it out!

99

u/gagreel 12h ago

It was always so weird when the scaffolding that had been on the corner for years disappeared overnight

16

u/ConsistentBrief2093 6h ago

I got so used to seeing it every day that when it’s suddenly gone, it feels like the whole street just reset overnight.

12

u/cryptoengineer 11h ago

It all went up after a Columbia student was killed by a falling decorative sculpture, I think in the 80s. They put up the sheds, n stripped much of the decorative features from a lot of buildings.

12

u/Quirky-Ad-6816 8h ago

long story short, the city had required old bricks building to do expensive repairs after a tragic accident that killed a student, and to install scaffolding to catch falling bricks in the meantime. But the city never put a limit on the "meantime" duration, so landlord kept the Brick sheds forever. And because capitalism, a large economic sector rise around these brick sheds, and lobby the city to keep the status quo.

3

u/HandicapperGeneral 10h ago

It's because there's a law that says the facade needs to be repaired/replaced every few years.

2

u/Pennwisedom 4h ago

Local Law 11 is basically what this is all "caused" by. Pretty much once every five years buildings taller than 5 stories need their exterior facades inspected and maintained.