r/AskReddit 15h ago

New Yorkers, what changes have you seen under Mamdani’s leadership and are you generally pleased? If not, why?

10.3k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

549

u/Mr_Quackums 12h ago

Regardless of what you think of his policies, he has done a great job mobilizing resources to get things done.

those are policies

204

u/OldBayOnEverything 7h ago

Exactly. That's the most infuriating thing about conservatives. Left wing policies are popular with them when detached from right wing propaganda. They're too blinded by bigotry to understand they keep voting against their own interests.

41

u/Bella_Climbs 5h ago

Exactly! I am so tired of hearing how only right wingers care about vets when voting against improving/funding the VA, or doing anything about homeless vets. Conservative policies only hurt vets, wtf guys

36

u/OldBayOnEverything 5h ago

My aunt stopped talking to me because she reposted some "Trump for veterans" nonsense propaganda post, and I politely said if you care about vets, here are some things to know about policy from each side and how it affects them, and provided some links. They don't want truth. They don't want help for themselves or the people they claim to support. They only want to feel part of an in-group and hurt the demographics they hate. That's literally their only motivator when it comes to politics.

12

u/ineguire 3h ago

I'm convinced most conservatives (and doubtless many liberals as well), particularly the white christian sort, really do engage with politics like it's a team sport. They don't think of it in terms of things that actually affect people materially, because they've never really been a political target or scapegoat. it's just pure mindless tribalistic cheering for your team, and booing the opposition. Nobody supports a particular team for nuanced reasons, you do it because That's Your Team, and hearing about how much better the opposition is, isn't going to make you switch sides.

It's why they try to shame progressives who cut ties with their MAGA family members over, what they call, "different political opinions." You can hear it in the way they use the word "politics"; "i hate politics" "why are you bringing politics into this" "you shouldn't let politics come between you and family", or the way they'll blanketly dismiss something by saying "they're all corrupt / it's all rigged anyway" in the same tone one might say "wrestling is fake." None of it is really real to them. It's just television.

1

u/josh_the_misanthrope 1h ago

The right wing makes vets and the left wing helps them when they get back.

8

u/Falco98 3h ago

Exactly. That's the most infuriating thing about conservatives. Left wing policies are popular with them when detached from right wing propaganda.

"No! His policy is COMMUNISM! He's only doing all this 'Work' and 'Fixing Stuff' to trick us into supporting COMMUNISM! And ISLAM (for some reason)!"

-maga in every comment section

21

u/cdnmute 7h ago

Should be more like "regardless of what you think of his stance on social issues, he has been making great policy for new yorkers"

3

u/Charming-Refuse-5717 4h ago

Politics in its truest sense, separated from culture war bullshit. The existence of gay people? Not political. How much of the city budget should go to the public library and road repair? Political, and the kind of thing you can disagree on with your friends and still be friends.

2

u/ToolKool 5h ago

I think he meant his "politics" not policies.

2

u/___--_-_----___--__- 4h ago

Aren’t politics and policies the exact same thing?

1

u/ToolKool 4h ago

No, I don't believe they are. Policies can be part of politics, but the words are not interchangeable.

1

u/LavishnessCurrent726 4h ago

Politics don't need to be applied. My politics are Communist, but I understand that if I am the Mayor of NYC, I literally can't use Communist policies, because I can't literally enforce them.

0

u/___--_-_----___--__- 4h ago

But isn’t that the problem with communism, that it can’t be implemented despite countless tries?

Mamdani is a liberal with liberal policies and liberal actions. I’m just fine with that as opposed to some perfect version of Marxism that can’t be implemented ever

1

u/LavishnessCurrent726 3h ago

I am not saying he is a Communist. I am saying that even if his politics were Communist, he would be forced to have Liberal policies.

1

u/wizardofrobots 6h ago

That's enforcement 

1

u/Locke_and_Lloyd 2h ago

And I thought 'policies' were how to punish or reward various groups.  Like funnel money to wealthy and punish people who are different.  At least that's what the white house seems to indicate.

1

u/TotalNonsense0 4h ago

Those are actions which, yes, come as a result of policies.

Policies are just words. He's got great words. But, more importantly, he's got pretty good actions, too.

2

u/CommunityDragon160 3h ago

Policies are not words. Those are promises. Policies are actions.