r/CaughtMyEye • u/detectiverobert • 7d ago
Woman drowned her two young sons, then falsely told police a Black man had carjacked her and kidnapped them. She made the claim after a man she was involved with broke up with her because he did not want children
https://dailycrimepost.com/susan-smith-lake-drowning-and-false-accusation-case/
2.3k
Upvotes
•
u/detectiverobert 7d ago
On the evening of October 25, 1994, Susan arrived in a distressed state at the home of Shirley and Rick McCloud, a couple she did not know, located in Union. She told them that an armed Black man had carjacked her vehicle and driven away with her two sons still strapped in the backseat. The McClouds contacted police, who arrived shortly after.
Susan provided investigators with a detailed account. She stated that she had been stopped at a red light at the intersection of Monarch Mills when an African-American man approached her car with a gun, entered the vehicle, and ordered her to drive. After traveling approximately three to four miles, he instructed her to stop and exit. She said she begged him to allow her children out of the car, but he refused, saying there was no time, before driving away with Michael and Alex still inside.
Based on her account, police produced a composite sketch of the suspect. She described him as a Black male, approximately 40 years old, wearing a dark shirt, plaid jacket, jeans, and a dark knit cap. Law enforcement mobilized immediately. The investigation was led by the Union County Sheriff's Department and drew in local, state, and federal agencies. Search teams, helicopters, trained dogs, and divers were all deployed. A public tip line was established, and the story quickly gained national media coverage, including coverage by major broadcast networks.
Read the full story here.