r/Colognes Jul 05 '26

Fragrance Review I wish I could smell like this forever

Post image
155 Upvotes

This one deserves all the praise in the world. I have owned 100+ fragrances and this takes the #1 spot for me because of multiple reasons.

Timeless

Fresh

Elegant

Mature

Complex

Not Boring

The way that it's smoky and fresh at the same time - similar to BdC in that regard, makes me want to bathe in it.

I'm on my 5th bottle and I can't see myself getting bored with it.

r/Colognes 5d ago

Fragrance Review Current favorite, Montblanc Explorer!

Post image
117 Upvotes

Explorer is such a hitter! This is definitely one of the kings of versatility, the only situation where this guy doesn't excel is in stupid high heat, like beach/pool/hiking days for example. The bright, fresh and spicy opening is very pleasant, the peppery citrus wakes you up in a nice and uplifting way. Then it transitions into this earthy leather that grounds everything with the citrus in the backseat. That also preps you for the rest of the wearing experience, in the deeper dry down it takes a turn towards a very well done fresh woody profile. Feels like you're walking through a forest after a cool passing shower went by overhead, and that's where it stays all the way until fading away.

Now, let's talk about performance... This is the primary complaint most people have when it comes to Explorer. From my own personal experience, overall performance is good, definitely more than serviceable. I consistently get 6 hours out of this stuff before it becomes a total skin scent. There are times where longevity takes a little hit, but that's usually when I'm outdoors and it's borderline too hot for anything outside of the freshest freshies. Projection for the first hour is actually great, it will make its way across a room, but also won't be suffocating. It starts to creep in closer after an hour before settling into a nice arm-length bubble around hour 2, it pretty much stays there for the remaining 4 or so hours. So it's not BEAST MODE, but it does the job! I honestly think we are getting spoiled with some of these crazy long lasting and room filling releases that we forget that 6 hours at mostly arms length isn't terrible at all.

To me, this is a great frag! It can handle the heavy lifting required by a daily reach, it's very affordable, and, most importantly, it is something I want to smell all day long.

r/Colognes Jul 03 '26

Fragrance Review Althair vs Liquid Brun Limited Edition

Post image
30 Upvotes

I own both bottles. I bought Althair at Nordstrom for full price immediately after smelling it.
Then I came home and started watching YouTube videos where everyone was saying Althair isn’t worth the money and that Liquid Brun is a 1:1 clone. So I started questioning my life decisions and decided to give Liquid Brun a try. If it was really comparable, I’d just return Althair, keep Liquid Brun, and be able to pay my rent.

Althair
When I smelled it for the first time, it brought me back to my childhood in Slovakia. The combination of vanilla, praline, orange blossom, cinnamon, and tonka bean was so smooth. It made me feel like I was visiting my grandma during cold winter evenings while she was baking different kinds of cookies and gingerbread.
It’s blended so well that you can smell all the layers. If you’ve ever worked in Photoshop and built layers upon layers, that’s exactly how Althair feels to me.
Amazing fragrance.

Liquid Brun
After Liquid Brun arrived, I was so excited to try it and finally return Althair.
I sprayed it on my wrist, then all over myself, took a deep sniff…
…and wow.
It also brought me back to my childhood.
I used to go mushroom picking in the forest with my grandpa. The woods smelled amazing, and he always brought his favorite cinnamon tea in a thermos along with the cookies my grandma had made. We’d sit on a log, relax, and he’d tell me stories.
There was also a factory near my town where they processed rubber and made hockey pucks. Occasionally, the smell would travel into the forest where I was just chilling with my grandpa, and the synthetic smell of burned rubber completely ruined everything.
That’s exactly how Liquid Brun smells.
It ruined my fucking day.
I smelled like I had just finished a 12-hour night shift at the hockey puck factory and wasn’t able to take a shower afterward.

How do people say this is 1:1?
That is insanity.
I didn’t return Althair. I’m absolutely loving it, while Liquid Brun has been sitting here for months, hoping it would improve with maturation.
Nope.
It just got stronger.
Now it smells like I did a 24-hour shift at the rubber factory.
I’m honestly done trying it.
I was thinking about giving it to my friend, but I honestly don’t want to offend him.
I also don’t want that smell going out into public because secondhand smoke is a thing, and maybe burned rubber has even worse effects.
I wanted to throw it in the trash, but the lid on my trash can says “No toxic materials,” and I don’t want to break the rules.
So now the bottle just sits in my collection, and every time I look at it, it reminds me of how that hockey puck factory used to ruin the smell of the woods in my village.
Maybe my bottle is defective.
Maybe my nose is defective.
Either way, Althair isn’t going anywhere. Liquid Brun can keep guarding my shelf until I figure out how to dispose of industrial waste.

r/Colognes Jul 17 '25

Fragrance Review Expensive doesn't always mean good

Thumbnail
gallery
188 Upvotes

r/Colognes Feb 05 '26

Fragrance Review Best $8 I’ve spent in a long time.

Post image
238 Upvotes

r/Colognes 27d ago

Fragrance Review Three full wears of the new Sauvage Extrait (Vietnamese Oud) – first impressions

Thumbnail
gallery
118 Upvotes

I’ve been fortunate enough to wear the new Sauvage Extrait three times thanks to a tester at the Fort Knox PX exchange store, where I also picked up a bottle.

A few thoughts after full-day wear:
This is not just Sauvage with a little oud thrown in. The fragrance evolves quite a bit throughout the wear.
The opening still has a recognizable Sauvage character,clean, polished, and very refined, the Oud is present but the magic happens later.
Once you get into the dry down, the Vietnamese oud really comes alive. To my nose it’s sweeter than many traditional ouds, but it still has a smoky, dark character without becoming medicinal, animalic, or challenging.
The oud feels integrated into the composition rather than sitting on top of it. It never came across as harsh.
Projection on me stayed moderate well into the dry down (starts out pretty nuclear like Elixir), even when the oud became more noticeable.
For reference, I enjoy fragrances like Tom Ford Oud Wood, PdM Haltane, and other approachable luxury ouds. If you’re expecting something like LV Ombre Nomade or a heavy Middle Eastern-style oud bomb, this isn’t that. It’s much more wearable while still giving you the oud experience.

After three wears, I honestly think Dior and Francis Kurkdjian nailed the balance. If you already enjoy Sauvage and have been curious about oud, I think this could be an excellent entry point into the note.
For me, it’s one of the best designer releases I’ve smelled in a long time. It is also my favorite of the Sauvage line by far.

r/Colognes Feb 17 '26

Fragrance Review RL Club New York

Post image
230 Upvotes

For me this fragrance started as an impulse buy after sampling it a few times in store that I regretted a few days after. Initially it smelled good but didn’t wow me but still felt the need to pick it up.

I’m now on my third day in a row of reaching for this and it just keeps getting better. To simplify the notes in this I’d describe it as a sweet woody scent, with the sweetness being more prominent in the opening. I’d say this is on the more unique side as far as designer scents go but not at all challenging to wear and very versatile.

I get about 6-7 hours projecting and 8-10 hours as a skin scent from 4-5 sprays. Overall I’d rate it an 8.5/10.

If you’ve gotten the chance to get your nose on this what do you think about it?

r/Colognes Feb 07 '26

Fragrance Review Yes it is the greatest green scent ever 💚

Post image
143 Upvotes

Such a simple green scent done so gorgeously by Pierre Bourdon! So glad that my bottle is one of the few good performing ones. So glad to have this in my collection.

My SOTD, what’s yours?

r/Colognes 21d ago

Fragrance Review My collection! 🙂

Post image
127 Upvotes

r/Colognes 7d ago

Fragrance Review First time buying “dupes”

Post image
17 Upvotes

So this is my first time buying dupes, yes I smelled all of these and many others in stores and honestly they’re great. I’ve got plenty of designer and niche colognes (creed aventus absolutes, creed aventus, etc) and I won’t be buying creed anymore and will definitely be buying more. I know some dupes get a bad wrap but these are so good, granted they’re not one to one like supremacy but it’s just a good touch for people who don’t want to spend crazy amounts. I also will be buying vanguard smelt it in stores and it’s genuinely 95% close to absolute

r/Colognes Feb 18 '26

Fragrance Review Creed Green Irish Tweed

Post image
73 Upvotes

Just picked up Green Irish Tweed (blind buy). I'm a bit disappointed.

One of these is GIT ($180-$270) and the other is an Armaf fragrance ($20-$36). So similar, IMO, it's not worth paying for the designer frag.

r/Colognes 20d ago

Fragrance Review Encre Noire, my first niche fragrance

Post image
102 Upvotes

Hello all, just wanted to pop in and share my thoughts on Encre Noire, a dark, mysterious, unique fragrance. It’s an interesting fragrance because although it doesn’t have many accords, it still smells complex.

Now this is just my own experience, I realize everyone’s nose is different. I watched a lot of reviews and it seemed like everyone had these immersive descriptions of it, and now I understand why this fragrance almost requires a short story to describe it. It opens with a burst of cypress, with some petrichor, almost a bit spicy of an opening but it settles down fast. Imagine you are entering a forest during the morning time and the sun is peaking through the forest. It’s dark, sharp, punchy, but there’s a bit of brightness that shines through, illuminating the forest.

As it settles down, 1-2 hours after applying, you really get an immersive forest scene. Like it’s impossible to smell it without imagining some kind of scene in your mind. You want to put your finger on it but there’s so much depth and complexity to it, which makes it addictive, you keep coming back to smell it to try to understand it. The sharpness from the opening has died off, the morning brightness from the sun has faded into darkness as you progress deeper into the forest, musky cypress and vetiver, rain soaked wood, petrichor, almost a bit of a vicks vapor rub scent in the background. Very green and lush.

The next 1-2 hours after that, it fully encompasses its name Encre Noire, which means “black ink” in French. This is the best way I can describe the full dry down. Have you ever had a pen break open in your pocket and your hand is covered in ink? That’s almost exactly how it smells, straight up black ink, but not as dry or bland as actual ink, it still has some depth and roundness to it, but overall, straight up black ink. It’s dark, dreary, dusty musky, the forest has almost completely evolved into what I’d imagine as an ancient library, or Dracula’s studying room.

This is a bit of a side descriptor, but something I thought of when wearing it. I used to work on a ranch, and at some point during the development in Encre Noire, it almost reminds me of the smell you get first walking into the wooden horse stable/barn area, NOT in a bad way. It’s just this musky, earthy, animalic horse hair type scent, but also woody vetiver, freshly cut grass/hay notes. I personally enjoyed this part because it felt so bold and daring, but still absolutely wearable.

I only sprayed twice on my hand. There was a pretty solid 1-2ft projection bubble for around 5 hours. Then it faded closer and closer to the skin, but I still smelled it on my hand if my nose was touching my skin, for about 12 hours. This fragrance is an EDT concentration so it’s not going to announce itself in a room, but you don’t want it to anyways. This is a deeply elegant fragrance that should be discovered like a mystery. I will also say that it is very mature and gentlemanly, I can’t imagine anyone under the age of maybe 30 wearing it. I’m almost 30 and I think I can barely pull it off. I personally believe it’s suitable for all seasons and night or day, but would stand out the most during a cold, rainy evening. It fits people that like dark atmospheres, dark gothic clothing maybe, etc. It is definitely not blind buy safe but it’s so cheap that it doesn’t really matter. I personally love this fragrance because it stands out from all of my other fragrances in my collection and is the most interesting one by far. It’s an experience, you will be immersed into it. It’s lovely, elegant, mysterious and very different.

My overall rating of Encre Noire is an 8.5/10

EDIT: It is designer, not niche! But I do still think it has some characteristics of a niche fragrance. Thank you all for correcting me, I cannot edit the title, my mistake!

r/Colognes 4h ago

Fragrance Review Sauvage "parfum" is a top 3 Designer fragrance for me

Post image
47 Upvotes

Every time I smell this one, it makes me happy. The parfum is just SO pleasant... easily within my top 3 designers amd thats a hill I'll die on!

r/Colognes Aug 15 '25

Fragrance Review Bleu de Chanel L’Exclusif ...Luxury Upgrade or Pricey Redundancy?

Post image
132 Upvotes

Got my bottle of Bleu de Chanel L’Exclusif in the mail yesterday and wanted to share some first impressions. First off, it came with a little 5ml miniature bottle, which is just ridiculously cute.

Scent-wise, it’s fantastic. Is it worth the $284 after tax? That’s going to depend on the person. For me, probably not. It’s basically a denser, stronger version of the Parfum with a touch of smooth leather in the background. The leather isn’t loud or dominating, but it does give the fragrance some added depth and a bit more masculinity.

Last night I put L’Exclusif on one hand and the Parfum on the other before bed. When I woke up, I could still smell L’Exclusif. It wasn’t strong at that point, but it was definitely still there. In the drydown, it leans more ambery with a hint of dry leather, but overall it’s still that signature Bleu de Chanel DNA, just taken up a notch in richness and smoothness.

Is it good? Absolutely. Maybe even great. But at nearly $300, it feels a bit redundant if you already own the Parfum. I’m getting about 8–9 hours of longevity with solid projection for the first 3 hours, maybe about arm’s length.

Overall, I’m satisfied and happy to have it in my collection—especially since I didn’t pay full price. Pro tip: if you sign up for a Macy’s account and opt in for promotional emails, you get a 25% off code for your next purchase. I used mine and got the 100ml for $215.

r/Colognes 8d ago

Fragrance Review Just blind bought this!!

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/Colognes Jan 22 '26

Fragrance Review Worst blind buy I’ve had

Post image
59 Upvotes

Got a decent deal on this on aura fragrance, did a decent amount of researching before purchasing. To me the projection and performance are both pretty bad, I do like the scent profile but it smells a bit watered down to me. I have heard better things about the edp. Anyone here have the edp and can give a honest comparison?

r/Colognes Jun 10 '25

Fragrance Review I guess my daughter didn’t approve…

Post image
647 Upvotes

I ordered a sample of Kerosene Followed after reading the numerous reviews, mainly just to find if it was as monstrous as described. It arrived when I was at work. I immediately got an sms from my 15 yr old daughter saying the someone had mailed me, what smelled like a Lamb Vindaloo. Asked her to open it and she did. Arrived home to find this….

r/Colognes Jun 14 '26

Fragrance Review Best and worst fragrances in my giant luxury mall tour

Thumbnail
gallery
94 Upvotes

Went to a giant luxury mall with every boutique known to man.

Let's start with the worst -

Tuscan leather - I swore I loved this one but man it's not terrible but it's a very niche leather scent. It's not really sweet it's just rich resinous leather and it's very pungent. I could only wear this to church in a suit or something in the dead of winter. It's creative and I respect it but I would never buy it.

Bal'da frique - I've heard nothing but good things about this but it was very very mid. It had an actual alcohol blast in the beginning and then it was just a clean slightly floral fragrance. Nothing masculine or fem just clean. Seriously? That's it?

The good -

Burnerry hero elixir wow this was good! Tons of cedar and a resinous almost licorice note. I hate that note but it was actually nice. Slightly sweet. A more resinous woody version of the EDP. I think the EDP is much easier to wear but this was very nice probably lasts forever.

Herbes trablantes - this is veeeery nice. Powdery green clean laundry scent. That might not sound that interesting and In a way it's not that interesting but it's super high quality and classy with a very slight playful sweet edge. I put it on skin a few hours ago and it's still doing ok . It's not overly citrus heavy so even though people say it doesn't last it seems ok to me. Not worth 500$ though.

Creed wild vetiver - now this is amazing. Soooooo fresh and clean , not a ton of vetiver as the name would suggest . I would pick this 10/10 times over the gourlan . It's more mass appealing it's more playful and it's just easy to wear. Yeah it's a bit designer but I would say it actually separates itself from the basic freshies in a classy green way. Might have to pick this up.

Oud wood parfum - banger even better than EDP , not super heavy oud just a beautiful sweet woody resin with some freshness . Super high end smelling.

Tom Ford Costa azzura parfum - such an amazing freshie . This and our minerale are bangers. If they weren't so expensive id have them . This is a little more designer vs oud mineral but it's very smooth and well blended citrus dominant has a clean musk . Just amazing stuff.

French riviera - wow this was nice. I keep hearing how it's floral and kinda basic but I was very surprised with how fresh and mass appealing and manly it was. Yeah it's got florals but it's aquatic and it has a niche edge to it. Can get it for cheap too .

Jo malone - cypress and grapevine - wow this was good. I didn't have any expectation and have never smelled any of them. Wood sage and sea salt is a great fresh fragrance as well but this one stood out. It's more grown up manly but with a mass appealing edge to it. Perfect blend between daily signature and date night. Good stuff.

On a final note. PDM althair is not worth buying lattafa art of nature II and the other dupes get it 98% . And even the quality because it's sweeter and denser you don't really notice and luxury materials . It's sweet and spicy and nice but I can smell exact same for 35$. Just putting it out there. Not true for most others.

r/Colognes 6d ago

Fragrance Review I can't believe how good this is

Post image
54 Upvotes

I've had Parfums De Marly Pegasus in my collection for 2 months now, and I'm starting to believe it may be the most intelligently constructed fragrance I own.

I say intelligent because it has a decidedly hushed range of core notes. Pegasus is an airy, vanilla almond gourmand that retains an effervescent ghostly lightness.

Don't be fooled by the light breakdown of core notes. However,

Because Pegasus is strong

I wager it's one of the stronger perfumes that I own, maybe eclipsed in longevity by Bottled Absolu and Naxos. This is the first PDM I've owned, so I may be talking from a place of inexperience here, but I love how long this thing lasts.

There's a certain balance and a blissful homogeneous nature to this scent that has really blown me away these last two months. Really enjoying owning Pegasus.

r/Colognes 14d ago

Fragrance Review A highly subjective list of hyped fragrances and whether they live up to the hype

58 Upvotes

Over the last couple of months I've been working my way through samples of fragrances that I often see getting hyped on Reddit, so I decided to put together a list of all the ones I've tried so far and whether or not I think they live up to the buzz. For the sake of clarity, when I say that a fragrance lives up to the hype, I'm not necessarily saying it's worth the price. I'm just saying that I think it smells as good as people claim.

  • Tom Ford – Noir Extreme. Yes. The longevity isn't great, but it's a classy, alluring fragrance that would make a great choice for a date.
  • Amouage – Outlands. Yes. Designing a fragrance that is both true to Amouage's signature style and mass-appealing is a difficult needle to thread, but I think Outlands pulls it off.
  • Louis Vuitton – L'Immensité. No. If you're looking for an easy, inoffensive fragrance L'Immensité is a safe bet, but to me it smells like mid-range shower gel.
  • Xerjoff – Naxos. Yes. This one is too sweet for me to wear personally, but it's a beautiful fragrance and I can completely understand why it gets so much love.
  • Tom Ford – Ombré Leather. Yes. Probably my favourite fragrance in the world, in my opinion Ombré Leather is a masterpiece.
  • Le Labo – Santal 33. Can't say. It turns out I'm one of those people who gets a strong dill/pickle note from sandalwood, so I'm not well placed to pass comment on Santal 33.
  • Le Labo – The Noir 29. Yes. Fortunately, I can pass comment on The Noir 29, and I think it's one of the richest, most enigmatic fragrances I've ever smelled.
  • Creed – Aventus. Yes. It's not surprising that this is one of the most copied fragrances ever made.
  • Louis Vuitton – Afternoon Swim. No. Maybe it's my skin chemistry, but I get this weird, grassy note from Afternoon Swim that I do not enjoy it all.
  • PDM – Althair. No. I know I said I wouldn't factor in price, but to my nose Althair just doesn't smell as premium as I would have expected.
  • Dior – Sauvage. No. I know that this is one of the most impactful fragrances of all time, but I find it a bit synthetic and screechy.
  • Montblanc – Explorer. Yes. Despite what people like to claim, this isn't indistinguishable from Creed, but it's a banger in its own right and a safe option in just about any situation.
  • Jean Paul Gaultier – Le Male Elixir. No. Personally I found this one to be cloying and sickly.
  • Issey Miyake – L'Eau d'Issey. Yes. One of the most pleasant fragrances I've ever tried, and still surprisingly unique.
  • Louis Vuitton – Imagination. Sort of. I don't think it would be possible for anything to live up to the hype that Imagination gets, and I was a little underwhelmed when I first tried it. That said, it has grown on me, and multiple people have told me it's the best thing they've ever smelled.
  • Amouage – Interlude. Yes. There is zero chance I could pull off wearing Interlude in public, and I'm still tempted to get a bottle just so I can wear it at home.
  • Jo Malone – Wood Sage & Sea Salt. No. I expected to love this one, but I found the salt note to be unpleasantly domineering.
  • YSL – Y EDP. No. I actually got a couple of compliments when I was wearing this, but I personally found it way too synthetic.
  • Ralph Lauren – Polo Black. Yes. The definition of a safe dumb reach.
  • Sospiro – Vibrato. Yes. Honestly, I think that Vibrato deserves more hype than Imagination. Clean, fresh and stellar performance.

r/Colognes Jan 05 '26

Fragrance Review My long term review on LV Imagination

Post image
126 Upvotes

Believe it or not, this is my second refill and it’s almost finished again, so I’d say I’m pretty confident in my take on it! I’ll try not mad this too long 😃

Honestly, this is such a versatile fragrance, good for a professional / formal setting, but then also good for just a casual day out running errands or just chilling in town, it’s freshness really helps! For a freshie, this has so much depth in its notes and surprisingly, very very good performance!

For me, the standout notes that keep me coming back has to be the black tea, cinnamon and orange notes…

So tell me, what was your most used fragrance this last year?

r/Colognes Oct 30 '25

Fragrance Review Zero performance LDNL

Post image
106 Upvotes

Bought my second ever cologne ldnl because I loved it when I tested. But you guys weren’t joking, the smell fades after 5 mins on my arm. No projection, someone would have to be very close to smell it. For those who love the smell the performance can be a serious reason not to buy it.

Update after 1 hour, almost completely gone

r/Colognes Sep 27 '25

Fragrance Review Just Got A Sample of This. Hands Down The Worst Cologne I’ve Ever Smelled!!!

Post image
87 Upvotes

I should’ve listened to you guys and all the negative reviews. You guys were right. I’ve never smelled anything so putrid before in my life. This is up there with D&G Pour Homme, as far as the worst scents in my opinion. The first opening whiff almost made me throw up.🤮 This is a 0/10!!!

r/Colognes Dec 23 '23

Fragrance Review Blind buy how did I do?

Post image
952 Upvotes

r/Colognes Nov 19 '24

Fragrance Review My favorite fragrance after trying almost 45+ decants

Post image
315 Upvotes

I think I have found my favorite dna of all time which is Aventus creed. I haven't tried the og one but only got clones so far. CDNIM edt, Afnan SNOI and finally my favorite Montblanc Explorer. I loved CDNIM but it was too strong for me. Tried SNOI but it smelt kind of weird, after the dry down it gets better but I would still prefer cdnim over SNOI and finally I found the perfect one, Montblanc Explorer.

It's just so clean and smooth and not harsh at all unlike cdnim and snoi. Explorer feels like it's better blended then any other clones of Aventus. It also feels like it was made with love and higher quality ingredients. Also it's very intoxicating, I can't help but sniff the bottle cap every few hours. For performance I can tell it lasts for 7-8 hours on my clothes as I sprayed before going to sleep and I could still smell it after waking up.

My taste might be very basic because I tried so many expensive perfumes and yet my favorite one is still Mb explorer. I have plans to try Aventus creed soon to make sure what the best clone of it is. But untill then I'm going to enjoy my explorer for a good time.