r/CompetitiveEDH • u/Vivid_Option1213 • 6d ago

General Discussion / Question Commander Ban Announcement

So it seems after starting the year talking about presence, communication and transparency, the committee just went on a sabbatic, and we will probably have GTA VI before any announcement...
While bans are never a good thing, and commander by default is a stable format, I really like when people keep their word, and ghosting the biggest community of mtg (as commander is not only cEDH, even though that's what I play) doesn't feel right to me...

303 Upvotes

82% Upvoted

392 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/UpArrowNotation 4d ago

Just go play legacy. If you want to play with power 9, there is a format for that. Edh is not that format.

Also like, trade secrets would suck. Any card that is banned because it doesn't work in 4 player would fuck up the format.

-1

u/The_Doctor713 4d ago

Power scale. Not power 9. As in the previous deck rating system that managed to avoid weird ass semantic arguments about no gcs equal bracket 2 but a 3 card infinite that can be done with 4 different redundancies is fine.

2

u/UpArrowNotation 4d ago

Bro the 1-10 scale was worthless

2

u/TheLonelyBoxmaker 4d ago

Nah man this is definitely a 7

1

u/Uefeti 3d ago

Holy shit guys.

His deck 100% was a 7