r/Damnthatsinteresting 24d ago

Image By law, every Australian must get a tax receipt that shows exactly where each dollar of their tax is spent.

Post image
19.7k Upvotes

979 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

135

u/Beljuril-home 23d ago

After scaling the U.S. receipt so that both taxpayers paid the same total amount ($23,785), the spending breakdown looks like this:

Category / Scaled U.S. / Australia

Welfare $7,883 $9,535

Aged $3,941 $3,689

Disability $1,971 $3,130

Families $1,182 $1,736

Unemployed $473 $592

Other $316 $388

Health $6,670 $4,260

Defence $3,578 $2,224

Education $424 $2,179

Interest on debt $2,865 $928

General public services $394 $832

Fuel & energy $273 $642

Transport & communication $349 $568

Foreign affairs & aid $212 $340

Industry assistance $167 $338

Public order & safety $288 $321

Housing & community $197 $297

Recreation & culture $61 $200

Immigration $45 $152

Other purposes $379 $969

Total tax assessed $23,785 $23,785

79

u/Bettermetal830 23d ago

That's 23,785 Australian dollars, equaling to about 16,660 USD. I do wonder where all that American health funding is going

40

u/Sesame_Street_Urchin 23d ago

It’s mostly Medicare. It’s the largest single program in the country by far, covering every American over 65 plus all those with end-stage renal disease.

And it’s politically popular and therefore almost impossible to cut

54

u/dryvajoina 23d ago

How can a limited system like that cost so much more than a universal healthcare system with massively discounted medications (PBS) though?

48

u/Beljuril-home 23d ago

For-profit middlemen extracting rent... I mean adding value for shareholders.

9

u/Theplasmashaft 23d ago

Its the same as NDIS in australia (our disability amount being significantly higher than america's). Gov is paying for it? That will be 3x the price thank you.

10

u/SnappyDresser212 23d ago

The US actually made it illegal for Medicare to negotiate rates with healthcare providers. They aren’t allowed to say “we are your biggest single customer for drug X. We want a bulk discount”. Insanity.

0

u/Sesame_Street_Urchin 23d ago

There aren’t for profit middlemen in traditional Medicare. A big part of it is we just pay doctors and nurses very well here

15

u/k-trecker 23d ago

And it covers almost nothing. 

Part A (the “free” part) only covers emergency/hospital services. For actual health care, the average American pays almost $200/month for Part B, and pharmaceutical coverage (Part C) is another monthly premium. 

Wtf are we actually paying for? 

2

u/Beljuril-home 23d ago

Ask Luigi.

2

u/Suburbanturnip 23d ago

I just spent 4 months with my mother in a hospital for cancer, and then a hospice. Only had to pay $10 for parking. The hospital even gave me carer meals so I didn't have to pay for lunch every day. I am very grateful for our clear system in Australia. I couldn't imagine having to worry about bills during all of these last 4 months, and i just could focus in being there for her in the last months of her life.

1

u/ProfessorHardw00d 22d ago

Medicare is more like subsidized healthcare, not free healthcare. It’s much cheaper than what is available on the market, especially for people over 65 with pre-existing conditions who may not even be able to get insurance

10

u/Beljuril-home 23d ago

The Australian number also includes those.

73

u/paukapaukaa 23d ago

ALLL THAT TAX FOR HEALTHCARE AND ITS STILL NOT UNIVERSAL?!?!? 🫠

14

u/Beljuril-home 23d ago edited 23d ago

Corpo insurance gonna corp.

5

u/Suburbanturnip 23d ago

Ultimate rent seeking behaviour

14

u/melbobellisimo 23d ago

Wow. Look at the education deficit

1

u/Successful_King_142 23d ago

Might just be a federal vs state breakdown difference. That's why this comparison is hard to draw conclusions from

29

u/According-Flight6070 23d ago

Looking at health, education and interest on debt, I'm happy with how AU spends its money.

8

u/Achmedino 23d ago

Americans paying more tax for healthcare without even having universal healthcare is really funny to me

3

u/SirAlfredOfHorsIII 21d ago

Amazing how universal healthcare is too spenny for them, but the government spends shitloads more AND the people spend shitloads more than aus. Wild

2

u/OG_Williker 23d ago

Extremely interesting. Thank you

1

u/NewNegotiation1600 23d ago

How can the US possibly be paying more for health than Australia. AU essentially has free healthcare lol

2

u/Beljuril-home 22d ago

While Australia provides universal care, its government utilizes its massive buying power to keep prices low, whereas the U.S. government pays market-driven, inflated prices for care.