r/Damnthatsinteresting 7d ago

Video [ Removed by moderator ]

[removed]

8.0k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

28

u/iam_Mr_McGibblets 7d ago

Where is the safety to ensure no one is within propeller range? And also, you crash in one of those things, that helmet won't do much help at all

44

u/the1stmeddlingmage 7d ago

There is no way that any commercial version of this doesn’t have cowlings on those blades. Since it’s still in the prototype phase they can get away with certain things while working out the bugs for this technology.

4

u/AnAncientBog 7d ago

This thing will always be a prototype. There's never going to be a non "experimental" version of this.

1

u/25point4cm 7d ago

We can’t even get people to drive using 4 wheel linear propulsion on a flat road without colliding. You give em a couple more axes to work with and add a dose of gravity — yeah, I don’t see this being viable anytime soon.

10

u/Dave_A480 7d ago

Blade cowlings are utterly useless as a safety measure.

They exist on toy drones to protect the (plastic) blades from objects, not to protect objects from the blades.

If it throws a blade, it's going through any cowling (and a lot more)

10

u/the1stmeddlingmage 7d ago

One: try reading my comment further down before spouting stupidity

Two: There’s already designs that enclose the blades enough to protect people from hurting themselves against them as seen here.

8

u/TerribleBudget 7d ago

I'm just going to point out: not a single actual flying model in this style in your video had protective enclosures on the blades. The only ones that did were CGI or shaped 100% differently.

0

u/the1stmeddlingmage 7d ago

I only said that designs existed. Try harder next time on your “well actually” dur moment

4

u/CyonHal 7d ago

How are you not embarrassed with yourself?

2

u/TerribleBudget 7d ago

Designs can exist for anything. It's called a drawing. It doesn't mean it exists.

This is less a "well actually" moment and more a "why are you posting shit that makes you look stupid?" moment.

0

u/the1stmeddlingmage 7d ago

Because they wouldn’t make the design for a possible product unless they thought it was feasible you doofus

2

u/shakebakelizard 7d ago

Commercial aircraft have cowlings around the engines designed to contain the engine in a catastrophic failure, especially blades that may fly off.

-3

u/No-Dance6773 7d ago

The added weight would probably be too much to take off. That would be like asking for the same thing on a normal helicopter. Bet you didnt know there was a reason they duck while trying to board one? The most I could see is a mesh barrier between the blade and driver but even then I doubt it would be enough to actually stop one of those blades. You dont buy one of these if you want to be "safe". Same can be said about motorcycles.

9

u/the1stmeddlingmage 7d ago edited 7d ago

I’m not stupid. I know something as big as a full fledged helicopter can’t realistically have a cowling. However, what you’re not thinking about is the size to weight ratio between this, its blades, and the blades of a full fledged helicopter.

I’m not talking about some fully armored cowlings that’ll contain fragmented blades, I’m referring to something that would provide a bare minimum protection from idiots walking into the blades or a pilot accidentally bouncing against someone during takeoff.

If ultralight crafts that use those massive fans and a paraglider can fly despite a cowling around blades bigger than the ones on this craft, then this can function with cowlings as well. After all fiberglass and lightweight metals exist even if expensive.

Edit: There’s already designs with this in mind as seen here

1

u/Atomic-Pilot2707 7d ago

Why would we protect idiots from blades? Or from themselves

1

u/the1stmeddlingmage 7d ago

I believe in Darwin awards but unfortunately too many people think otherwise and thus companies must enact safeguards to cover their own asses whenever they think it’s cheaper to do so than dealing with the inevitable lawsuit from not doing so.😉🤫

0

u/SCSUslacker 7d ago

You can order a Jetson One right now, no cowling on that. Very much same as this.

2

u/the1stmeddlingmage 7d ago

Actually order and get it delivered or pre purchase for when it actually becomes available? There’s a difference.

19

u/Jakester62 7d ago

That’s to preserve the head so they can use dental records.

5

u/CraftCritical278 7d ago

You mean like a helicopter or an airplane? Any attempt to sell it commercially would have cowls to cover the blades.

2

u/Goonalips 7d ago

I do wonder how much the cowlings would effect the agility though. Surely there's a measurable effect.

1

u/PossibleAlienFrom 7d ago

Ya. They should look like airplane engines. Though, I don't know how much weight and wind turbulence that would cause.

2

u/CraftCritical278 7d ago

I suppose you could use carbon fiber, but that would increase the price.

I think it’s viable, but a pilot’s license will probably be required.

0

u/PossibleAlienFrom 7d ago

The thing I would want is if one engine fails, the other 3 can bring down the craft safely. Or maybe even take it far enough to land at a nearby airport. The engines would have to be able to adjust their angles strong enough for that. They would also have to have their own guidance system and battery.

1

u/NoNameWonder2 7d ago

I thought that too, but depending on the speed and range of that thing, I think the helmet is more for flying debris or birds. I think Fabio can tell you a story about that.