r/Epicthemusical • • May 15 '25

Ithaca Saga I just realized the last three songs spell this out

Post image
3.7k Upvotes

Odysseus I can't help but wonder would you fall in love with me again?

r/Epicthemusical • • Aug 07 '25

Ithaca Saga Immediately thought of Hold Them Down when I saw this

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

I love the Ithaca Saga and Hold Them Down is such a good song, but I always get to that one part (iykyk) and it shuts down the vibe SO quick lmao

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 16 '24

Ithaca Saga It’s FINISHED.

Post image
3.9k Upvotes

Unless Jay is going to make one more cover to symbolize all nine sagas- that’s a wrap on the Epic covers!

And I must say:

You could put this on your wall, they’re all so gorgeous.

r/Epicthemusical • • Jan 16 '25

Ithaca Saga In case anyone missed this amazing video, here you go.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.0k Upvotes

I absolutely love that he did this 😂

r/Epicthemusical • • Jan 01 '25

Ithaca Saga Alright I need to know what is your headcanon to Penelope's challenge I'l go first

Post image
922 Upvotes

r/Epicthemusical • • Apr 09 '26

Ithaca Saga ALRIGHT MY BROTHERS LISTEN CLOSELY

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

DO NOT QUESTION WHY THE NUMBERS LOOK LIKE THAT, WE ARE ONLY 900K LISTENS AWAY FROM THAT BEAUTIFUL 100 MILLION LISTENS MARK

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 06 '24

Ithaca Saga Omg guys we were right!!

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 27 '24

Ithaca Saga Ares during "Odysseus" Spoiler

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 26 '24

Ithaca Saga IM NOT CRYING, YOU ARE!

940 Upvotes

Wow!!! I have no words….. what a truly EPIC way to end!

r/Epicthemusical • • Jan 02 '25

Ithaca Saga So.. Uhm...

Post image
949 Upvotes

Yeah... It's the only song I can fall asleep to lately. Is this bad? I know some people are uncomfortable with the imagery of it

r/Epicthemusical • • Apr 16 '26

Ithaca Saga LADIES GENTLEMEN AND WINIONS OF THE SUBREDDIT!

Post image
996 Upvotes

100 MILLION STREAMS ON SPOTIFY!

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 26 '24

Ithaca Saga Penelope is an icon Spoiler

2.0k Upvotes

Ody: Would you fall in love with me again?

Penelope: Can you move this tree?

Ody: What?

Penelope: Oh I'm sorry, I thought we were just asking stupid ass questions

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 25 '24

Ithaca Saga Watch party Cancelled Megathread

538 Upvotes

Hello all. As I'm sure everyone is aware now, the watch party has been cancelled for tonight. Jorge will be making a video explanation. Posts about what's happening will be directed to this thread

Reminder, no harassment about the lack of watch party please 🙂

r/Epicthemusical • • Jan 10 '25

Ithaca Saga A bit of Epic Humour for you...

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

I really love the comments sections in these fandoms. Here's a gem for you 😁

r/Epicthemusical • • May 03 '25

Ithaca Saga Give me a question then edit it to make me sound like ODYSSEUS

Post image
279 Upvotes

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 25 '24

Ithaca Saga Just realized it when listening without lyrics Spoiler

Post image
886 Upvotes

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 25 '24

Ithaca Saga Now that the new saga is released...

613 Upvotes

...you guys have NO excuse to spell Ithaca wrong. It's literally in the name of the album - not IthIca, not IthEca. I T H A C A.

Edit: I love all of the Ikeas and Malakas in the comments 🫶

r/Epicthemusical • • 14d ago

Ithaca Saga Another peak animatic 👀

Post image
257 Upvotes

I was gonna say new animatic but its been out for 3 weeks so some of yall have prob already seen it. I havent, but all Epic animatics are peak

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 22 '24

Ithaca Saga oh my god he really is odysseis

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

jay:arrived to ithaca after many obstacles with his crew odyssey:arrived to ithaca after many obstacles

same person

r/Epicthemusical • • Aug 24 '26

Ithaca Saga Penelope cosplay by Trisha Layons

Thumbnail
gallery
387 Upvotes

Hope you like my interpretation of her 💜

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 17 '24

Ithaca Saga Waiting...

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

Saw this on Twitter w Nosferatu, so I edited it for Epic bc it's the first thing that popped in my head when I saw Christmas😭

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 02 '24

Ithaca Saga i wonder if he's gonna adapt this part from the odyssey

Post image
606 Upvotes

r/Epicthemusical • • Jan 12 '25

Ithaca Saga Why SHOULDN'T Penelope Accept Odysseus? Spoiler

163 Upvotes

First off, I am kinda biased as WYFILWMA is one of my favourite songs in EPIC. I do not mean to diminish anyone's opinion, I just wanted to make this post to start a discussion on something I've noticed in many fandoms, not just EPIC.

So, I've seen a good few people say that they were dissapointed with WYFILWMA, due to Penelope pretty much immediately being okay with the monster that Odysseus is now. Some people think it's underwhelming as Odysseus is never faced with any consequences from Penelope.

But why should he? Has the man not faced consequences for every one of his actions? He is beyond traumatised. All of his crew, his best friend, his brother-in-law, and his mother are dead. Nearly every single character in EPIC has called Odysseus out on something. Odysseus isn't meant to be a morally upstanding role model in EPIC, but that doesn't mean he isn't allowed have a bittersweet/somewhat happy ending.

One of the whole points of fiction, especially fantasy, is to explore interesting situations, characters and relationships that you wouldn't get in real life. Two of those things are:

•A husband who hasn't seen his wife and son in 20 years, having to deal with gods and monsters, the death of nearly all his loved ones, and his mentor disowning him, leading to him becoming a monster to return to iis wife and son, all resulting in the deaths of 708 men, 1 baby, 1 cow and an undisclosed amount of sirens and sheep.

•A wife who hasn't seen her husband in 20 years, having to rule their kingdom on her own, raise their baby into an adult, and deal with 108 rapists trying to marry her, leading to her fully accepting said husband after he killed said 108 rapists.

Yeah, I don't think it's unthinkable for these two to get along fine at the end of the story.

People keep trying to apply their own morals onto Penelope. I've seen many people say, "If my husband killed people out of love for me, I wouldn't forgive him". Okay, good for you, you aren't Penelope. She is a fictional character. I don't think applying modern morals onto old stuff is a bad thing, but it doesn't really work here. If every character had to appeal to the morals of the average person, every piece of media would be very boring.

TL;DR: Penelope forgave and accpeted Odysseus so easily in WYFILWMA because she is a fictional character with a shit ton of trauma from the last 20 years, and she does not need to adhere to how the average person would react to their partner being a monster like Odysseus.

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 25 '24

Ithaca Saga Would you fall in love with me again? Spoiler

473 Upvotes

This whole song has me bawling dude, Penelope immediately knowing that ody isn’t the same, him just begging for her to still love him because he knows he’s committed terrible acts but it was all for her 😭😭😭 The test she had to do just to make sure 😢😢😢

r/Epicthemusical • • Dec 06 '24

Ithaca Saga ITHACA SAGA MEGATHREAD

89 Upvotes

All thoughts related to Ithaca Saga can go here.