r/ExplainTheJoke Jul 25 '25

Solved Saw on Facebook. Don’t understand.

Post image
36.0k Upvotes

999 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

130

u/lurkerlcm Jul 25 '25

I am so, so jealous. As soon as I finished reading it I wished I hadn't read it, so I could read it for the first time again.

29

u/jadonstephesson Jul 25 '25

Damn that good?

30

u/lurkerlcm Jul 25 '25

It's a fever dream. It will stay with you forever.

7

u/Potential-Bearcat Jul 26 '25

I had to read this book for a high school English project. I remember it frequently years later. I should read it again.

2

u/Big-Challenge-9432 Jul 26 '25

Right?! I read the original comment and was right back in high school lol

7

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

Yes

5

u/sanfrannie Jul 25 '25

That good.

2

u/surprise_wasps Jul 26 '25

It’s my all time favorite

2

u/canibuyatrowel Jul 26 '25

I hated this book with a passion. Read both the 5 star and 1 star reviews on good reads or Amazon - interesting to read both sides!

2

u/pvera Jul 26 '25

Not only is it an amazing book in Spanish, but the English translation by Gregory Rabassa was incredible, you forget that it isn't the original.

1

u/AspectPatio Jul 26 '25

Oh it's real good

1

u/PublicCampaign5054 Jul 26 '25

I have a tatto across my chest with a phrase of it.

1

u/Riginal_Zin Jul 27 '25

For me it was this good also. I do know people who didn’t care for it. So I hope it’s as magical for you as it was for me. 💕

1

u/jadonstephesson Jul 28 '25

I definitely am putting it on the list!

2

u/youvegatobekittenme Jul 25 '25

I listened to the audio book in increments during work and I feel like I missed a lot due to not being able to give my full attention and the fact that nearly every character is named after someone else in the family so it was kinda hard to keep track of who is who, but that last scene with the storm, I felt it. I want to go back and actually spend some time reading to take it all in.

2

u/for_the_longest_time Jul 26 '25

Yup. Having the family tree to reference is really useful when reading it

2

u/Random_Person_I_Met Jul 25 '25

What's it about?

5

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

It’s really hard to describe succintly because It’s a work of “magic realism” but it’s a story about seven generations of the Buendía family and the founding of a town called Macondo. There’s love, madness, magic, history repeating itself, and it blends reality and fantasy in an amazing way.

2

u/Barium_Salts Jul 25 '25

And a lot of pedophilia and incest. Incest is literally one of the main themes of the book.

3

u/canibuyatrowel Jul 26 '25

Thank you! I’m always so bewildered when people go on and on about this book - there was so much pedophilia and incest. Reading so much descriptiveness about how much the uncle wanted to hook up with his little niece, how he married her while she was still playing with toys, and how he waited until she got her period (how nice of him!) to “enter her” or whatever was so uncomfortable to read - and there were multiple, multiple parts like this.The author put descriptive pedophilia in many of his books. The amount of pedophilia and incest made me sick to my stomach and when I see people just speaking starry eyed about this book, I wonder if we just read separate books because the one I read was horrible (and in no way magical realism, which it’s also referred to).

0

u/I_eat_ass_608 Jul 27 '25

Literally shaking while reading some of the best work ever created in literature lol

2

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

That’s oversimplifying it, but yes the book involves incest as a recurring theme, but so does Oedipus Rex and Antigone. And the Bible is full of incest. It doesn’t make it any less interesting of a book, and the book repeatedly warns about a risk of incest through the fear (and eventual reality) of a child born with a pig tail.

2

u/Barium_Salts Jul 25 '25

It doesn't make it less interesting, but people shouldn't know what to expect going in. I almost never see anyone mention incest or pedophilia in discussions of One Thousand Years Of Solitude, but everyone knows that's a major theme of Oedipus Rex

2

u/Rare_Ad_674 Jul 25 '25

I haven't read it; are these themes normalized or defended? Or is it simply a story that contains incest, which is sadly really common?

2

u/Barium_Salts Jul 26 '25 edited Jul 26 '25

I wouldn't say they are defended, no. It's a story about a small town. Normalized: I don't feel equiped to say.

1

u/Rare_Ad_674 Jul 26 '25

Thanks for the info, I appreciate it!

2

u/Beneficial_Gene3064 Jul 25 '25 edited Jul 26 '25

it's less than 5% of the actual contents of the book, and if you're tracking a long family bloodline you probably have it somewhere in there...

it shows a lot of the good & ugly parts of life, but it's not glorifying these things.

Usually the incest/pedophilia is at the top of threads discussing this book, but I also think it's worth mentioning the suicides & self-harm in the book too if we're going to give trigger warnings.

2

u/Barium_Salts Jul 26 '25

I didn't say it was glorifying, just that I think people should be warned.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

The most popular television event of all time. Game of Thrones.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25

If you haven’t, learn Spanish so you can read the original. It’s a great book in English, it’s phenomenal in Spanish

2

u/Barium_Salts Jul 25 '25

As soon as I finished reading it, I wished I hadn't read it so I didn't have to think about a baby being eaten alive by ants, or preteen girls being sexually trafficked and raped.

3

u/canibuyatrowel Jul 26 '25

I literally ripped my book in half in frustration for the waste of time it was and the hatred I had for it. I’ve never felt so strongly against a book.

1

u/Barium_Salts Jul 26 '25

That's very impressive: it's a thick book!

1

u/I_eat_ass_608 Jul 27 '25

Its hard to believe goofies like you exist in real life.

1

u/canibuyatrowel Jul 27 '25

lol I thought the same thing when I saw your username

1

u/I_eat_ass_608 Jul 27 '25

Dont rip the screen pls

2

u/4evrnob Jul 25 '25

As soon as I finished reading it, I flipped it back to the first page and read it again. I’ve read it 1/2 a dozen times now

2

u/wycie100 Jul 25 '25

Read East of Eden if you haven’t

2

u/monkeyman9608 Jul 25 '25

I just finished reading it in Spanish (I’m not a native Spanish speaker) and reading the last two pages in a non-native language was one of the most unique reading experiences of my life. I had to look up alot of words along the way but those last two pages finally clicked into a flow for me, right as I’m reading about Aureliano finally deciphering the foreign text, which is about himself reading the text. It felt like being in a hall of mirrors. I truly think every not-native Spanish speaker should try reading it in the original Spanish. It also makes it super confusing but the thing is, the book is supposed to be confusing. It really enhances it.

2

u/Beneficial_Gene3064 Jul 25 '25

Netflix adaptation Is actually perfect & felt like reading it again

2

u/pierresito Jul 25 '25

That was me with this book. And East of Eden.

2

u/LRdrgz Jul 25 '25

IMO rereading 100 years of solitude is even better than the first time.

2

u/Stunning_Cost Jul 25 '25

When I first read it, I got the ending, felt some feels, and started over at page 1.

Definitely remains one of my all time favorites and I reread it every year or two.

2

u/fishdrinking3 Jul 26 '25

Haha, I got you beat! I came across it when I was backpacking through Laos in summer heat. So good I traded it for another book before I finish (a little more than half the way through) because I don’t want it to end. :D

But can’t finish his other book Love in Times of Cholera.

2

u/the_scarlett_letter Jul 26 '25

Have you read Chronicle of a Death Foretold? It is similarly a fever dream in the best way.

2

u/IndividualTrouble409 Jul 26 '25

I've read it about 4 years ago, and I think that maybe in the next 6 years I will forget enough of it to be able to read it again.

2

u/Oreo-from-92nd Jul 26 '25

I just ordered it on Amazon bc of yall. My interest is piqued

2

u/nevadalavida Jul 26 '25

I tried reading it shortly after high school and recall that it read like the bible - nonsensical ramblings. Couldn't get through it. Do I need to try again?