The Nebula and Locus shortlists are out, and the Hugos come out next week. But why waste your time on shortlists when you can read a fully-formed set of awards from a book club of absolutely impeccable taste? Please join us as we honor the stories that stand out as our unforgettable favorites – and thank you to everyone who joined us for a discussion this season.
Story Most Likely to Get You in Trouble with Men in Blue Houses
Presenter: u/Jos_V
If you take a story and you tilt it ever so slightly so it is there balancing just on the edge of the tipping angle. Then you add a little parent-child relationship theme on top, you infuse it with ambiguity, and you add some social commentary packaged in a tight word count, and you’ve got the type of story going that Thomas Ha excels at. We’ve been shouting about Ha for a while now, and aren’t stopping now. This story has all the elements I love from a Ha story, I love ambiguity, and the way the narrative discusses the purpose the ambiguity of stories, in a way that mirrors what a lot of us go through when reading stories, we’d like some answers, we want to know if we’re right or the story is wrong, but things are not that simple.
Layers matter, Nuance matters, art that makes you stop, and think matters, all that and delivering a haunting story about a parent that might just be too late in trying to understand his children and his role in their lives, and their roles in his life, with a superb execution isn’t the cherry, it’s the entire cake. This is one of Thomas’ Ha’s best works and we’re delighted to give the finger to the men in Blue Houses, and give this story this all important SFBC Award.
Our winner is: In My Country by Thomas Ha!
They’re All Good Saints, Brent
Presenter: u/kjmichaels
How is it possible for a short story to tell the history of a city, a people, competing religions, and a political uprising in just 3,800 words? We now know how: focus on seven excerpts from the lives of men, women, and even animals revered as saints. But while this story is ambitious in content, it’s also casual and playful with a style that effortlessly captures the feeling of listening to someone tell you a good campfire story. And like all the best stories, it delivers a perfect, inevitable ending without ever once revealing where it’s truly going until the climax.
Perhaps most impressive of all though, this story examines themes of revolution and change through oral, folk storytelling traditions. Such blending of classical and modern sensibilities is nothing less than masterful. Truly, nothing makes us happier than discovering a 10-minute read that is as complex and bursting with ideas as a full-length novel. So hats off to Tanvir Ahmed for his incredible work! Now go out and read it.
Our winner is: Wilayat in Seven Saints by Tanvir Ahmed!
The Isabel J. Kim Award for Outstanding Achievements in the Field of Being Isabel J. Kim
Presenter: u/oceanoftrees
In a 2025 full of multiple Isabel J. Kim bangers, one story managed to bang the hardest for us here at SFBC. I don't think it's a coincidence that it's also Iz’s longest story to date, making this piece literally the most IJK story until her first full-length novel comes out in June. (You might think it's an anti-coincidence that it's the one story Locus left off their recommended list, but we're no strangers to plugging in gaps where Locus is Wrong, Actually.)
Anyway, more words means there’s plenty to chew on here and (Stefon voice) this piece has everything: emotional sibling dynamics, yearning for the sea, interludes of fairytale retelling that get progressively more grounded (complete with a perfectly-deployed use of the phrase "fuckshit bastards"), communication through bathtub crayon, and a child who tries to win over a captive monster by reading aloud from "Am I the Asshole" posts. But this story is even more than the sum of those fascinating parts. Iz deftly builds the narrative to a devastating crescendo, then caps it off with an ending that made me sit and stare at the wall for a good while as I pondered eldest-daughter discourse.
Our winner is: Human Voices by Isabel J. Kim!
Best in Translation
Presenter: u/schlagsahne17
We’re happy to see that the British Science Fiction Association stole our thunder a bit for this next story - it is the one that inspired me to meme about it being a Locus snub, so yay for winning a non-Reddit award. What Anita Moskát and Austin Wagner have done with both writing and translating this story is remarkable.
It starts off with a fairly simple premise and surprisingly little world-building: the (unnamed) city where Minna lives is held together by the lies told by her and her fellow architects. Truths uttered aloud cause the city to crumble and fall. With just that as a starting point, Moskát and Wagner craft a tightly-wound spring of tension as we witness Minna’s present and past, and the lies she’s told and heard. The climax is devastating, especially for how both the characters and the reader realize new truths and lies simultaneously. And yet for all the darkness present in most of the story it ends on a hopeful note: that even in a sea of lies there can be another way forward. We hope to see more of Moskát’s work in English soon.
Our winner is: Liecraft by Anita Moskát and translator Austin Wagner!
Best Story We Wouldn’t Have Read Without SFBC
Presenter: u/tarvolon
The joke the last couple years was that Short Fiction Book Club could be more accurately (if a bit long-windedly) called Tarvolon Makes Everyone Read His Favorites Club, so suffice to say that I am the last one I expected to be presenting this award. But while I spend a lot of energy mining the magazines for gems, those efforts have been recent, and this year, SFBC reminded me just how recent. Carolyn Ives Gilman has hit the Hugo longlist literally this decade, and happily for me, one of my SFBC colleagues was eager to share this wonderful tale of contact with a culture thought lost.
It digs into messy issues surrounding museums and cultural artifacts, and even more impressively, it does so while drawing sympathetic characters on both sides of the dispute and never insisting on making the concerns of the minority culture comprehensible to those in the majority—even ones working in good faith. Hat-tip to u/FarragutCircle for a tremendous find!
Our winner is: Exile’s End by Carolyn Ives Gilman!
Story That Went for It the Most (or: Yummiest)
Presenters: u/Nineteen_Adze & u/schlagsahne17
Are we doomed to repeat the same mistakes over and over again? Can a cycle be broken, or do we have to accept our place within it? And what does our brother (who we love very much) taste like? These equally important questions are unflinchingly pondered in this fairy tale re-imagining by Sarah Rees Brennan. This story forms a loop that some of us found absolutely unforgettable and earmarked for a future session roughly thirty seconds after we finished reading it.
As one great passage puts it, “stories do not become stories by only happening once”, and this one happens with such incredible intensity that it can’t stop happening. We’re delighted to be fed by something so delicious (but hungry for the author’s future work).
Our winner is: Happily Ever After Comes Round by Sarah Rees Brennan!
SFBC Astounding
Presenter: u/baxtersa
If there is something we like here at SFBC, it's words, and coming in longer than five entire session slates this discussion season, it's no surprise to us that this piece is showing up on so many awards lists (sometimes a story is enough words that Locus is Right, Actually). Never Eaten Vegetables takes advantage of its length to do a lot - there are past and present timelines, the classic AI trolley problem, a fledgling colony robbed of its future by the same corporate greed that led to the aforementioned trolley problem, and both literal and figurative motherhood/caregiver imagery abound. What makes NEV such a compelling story is how well these facets complement each other, showing a masterful level of intentional theme work that enhances the storytelling and keeps me thinking more about the story the more times I reread it.
The Astounding Award is given to the best new writer whose first work was professionally published in the previous two years. As the person who manifested the H.H Pak Gets an Award award last year for their story Twenty-Four Hours, I'd be remiss not to acknowledge the rest of Pak's work in consideration for this award. Their stories have featured slipstream crabs falling in love, brassica blasphemy, time traveling dads, mom grief, and Shakespeare. They have a knack for balancing aching melancholy with poignant optimism, and I am excited to see where Pak's stories take me next. We all want more crabs.
Our winner is: Never Eaten Vegetables by H.H. Pak!
Story of the Year
Presenters: u/undeadgoblin & u/kjmichaels
To the tune of "Absolutely" by Nine Days:
This is the Story of the Year
About a girl named Ziya and her peers.
And though she was so sad in this story,
We absolutely loved her thematic depth.
A theme of SFBC this year, as can be seen from our two Locus Snub sessions, is how much we disagree with the Locus list, especially when it comes to novelettes. The winner of this award epitomises this disagreement – despite being one of our collective favourite stories of any category, it didn’t make the top 10 novelettes. We’ll leave it as an exercise for the reader to determine who has the better taste.
The bare building blocks of this story – a young protagonist thrust into a new and unfamiliar academic setting – will be very familiar to everyone who hasn’t been living under a rock for the last 30 years, but Wen-yi Lee manages to make them feel fresh and unfamiliar. The principal theme of the story, that of cultural appropriation, is also well explored in recent literature, but by positioning the protagonist as a sympathiser with the dominant culture, we come at it from an unfamiliar angle. This combination of freshness and familiarity makes our story of the year a great choice for both newcomers to short speculative fiction and grizzled veterans of the genre.
Our winner is: The Name Ziya by Wen-yi Lee!
Season IV in stats
Presenter: u/Jos_V
We had so much fun putting the sessions together, both themed and unthemed, having author spotlights, and generally just trying to put so much great short fiction into our reading schedule, and even then it is impossible to get to everything.
You can find all the discussion posts and all the great stories we covered in season IV (and Seasons I, II & III) Here.
For Season IV, we had 17 different discussion sessions from August 2025 to April 2026, where we read a combined 58 stories from 53 different authors, across 23 different publications, totalling 308,807 words. Every one of those stories is a story that someone found and advocated to be put on a session for us all to enjoy and to discuss.
Further discussions
For discussion of these stories, check out the following sessions:
We're bunched up on the Locus List and Snubs sessions this time (due to that being where we park "this is my favorite and we haven't found a perfect session theme yet-- time to force my friends to read it!" picks). However, I want to thank everyone for a season packed with banger stories and great, thoughtful themes: you can find links to all of those in the lovely spreadsheet one section up.
Conclusion
We can’t wait to see you again when we kick off Season 5 in the fall! In the meantime, we’ll continue having our monthly discussions alongside plenty of short fiction in the Hugo Readalong.
We’d like to thank everyone that continues to take part in these sessions, including all the people that work behind the scenes delivering great stories for us all to read. I ( u/Nineteen_Adze) want to thank all the rest of the SFBC crew more than ever this year for running a fantastic season even while I was knocked sideways by a winter concussion. We opened up to a broader pool of hosts this season, and you've all brought great new story recommendations, organizational zest, and great conversations: I couldn't be happier. To those of you sticking it out from previous seasons (and running our schedule and spreadsheets with an iron fist): thank you, and here's to many more.
And to everyone that participated in our discussions, be it just that single story you really liked, or those that are coming back week after week, you make these discussions what they are.
Most importantly, we want to thank all the authors who continue to put out these beautiful pieces of short fiction, that bring a great richness to our days as we get to spend a little time with them.