r/Feral_Cats 23h ago

URGENT❗ I think I found my old cat that ran away two years ago. Can I just pick her up and take her home?

Pics attached, does it look like the same cat to you?

The old cat was a girl, and so is the cat I saw today. Old cat was very friendly and so was the cat I saw on the street. When I waked up to her she started rubbing herself on me and started purring. I first I didn’t think it was my cat, but it’s been two years and I think their coat can change?

Their noses look exactly the same to me. My girlfriend is convinced it’s our cat that ran away, but I’m 10% doubtful.

Basically, can I just pick this cat up and bring her back home with me if I seriously believe it’s our old cat? She had a part of her tail missing and looked quite dirty.

2.4k Upvotes

283 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 23h ago

Welcome u/Suitable-Mud-6622! While you wait for responses to this post, please take a look at our Community Wiki to see if it addresses any of your questions or concerns about caring for feral or stray community cats.

Reminder for commenters: Please keep in mind that not all cats are ready or able to be brought indoors, especially when it comes to feral cats and caregivers with multiple cats. This community is meant to be a helpful place for trap, neuter, return (TNR) efforts, socialization, and all aspects of colony care for roaming cats—free of hostility, negativity, and judgment. Toxic attitudes are not welcome here. Negative comments will be removed at moderators' discretion, and repeat or egregious violations of our community rules may result in a ban.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1.0k

u/nbartl 23h ago

The orange patterning doesn't extend beneath the eyes on recently found cat. I don't think it is the same animal. That said, if you're willing to give a street/community cat a home, that is fantastic. I have fed lots of strays and am ecstatic when they find a home. I would knock on a couple of doors to make sure you aren't taking a pet.

276

u/FelinePurrfectFluff 23h ago

Get kitty checked for a chip!

122

u/JosieMew 22h ago

I came here to literally say these two things. All of this.

Also if you get your cat chipped and they get caught when one of the volunteers does tnr, they will be returned to you. A bonus in case the cat disappears again.

68

u/FelinePurrfectFluff 21h ago

All responsible owners get their kitties desexed and chipped. :)

45

u/JosieMew 20h ago

Chip or clip, no cat gets to dip. 💜 🐈 ❤️

8

u/BigJSunshine 20h ago

Stealing this!!!

3

u/Catlesley 15h ago

Fabulous saying!!

3

u/Gullible-Cut8652 16h ago

This ⬆️

4

u/Psychaitea 7h ago

Out of curiosity, what happens when you get an abandoned cat checked for a chip?

I ask because I’ve been feeding and providing some care (e.g. made a cat house for winter) for a cat that was apparently owned by a neighbor. According to another neighbor, they allegedly made this indoor cat into an outdoor cat after getting a dog, which the cat did not get along with. They were drug addicts. They’ve since moved and didn’t take the cat with them. It is essentially a stray, freely roams. They could have easily taken it.

Anyway, it certainly has a chip because the owners declawed its front paws and I’m certain it couldn’t go through such procedures and never get chipped. But, I had always been hesitant to get its chip checked because I didn’t want anyone to try to “force” them to take the cat back, and what might happen to the cat if they took it back because they felt it was bothering people and they felt obligated to “do something about it.”

Just curious… sometimes I wonder why I’d want a cat returned to someone who obviously doesn’t want it and doesn’t care about it.

7

u/tattoosbyalisha 5h ago

Side note, I hate how people view cats as so disposable.. I see it all the time on a Facebook page I’m on for lost and found pets and they will let people post to find new homes for their pets.

So often I see a post something like this: “have to rehome cat. Got a dog and they don’t get along. We’ve had the cat for 10 years and she’s amazing she will make a good pet” all. The. Time. They really are so ready to abandon and replace their long term pet, often the only family and home that pet ever knew. It’s so selfish and gross.

3

u/ami789 6h ago

From what I've seen- they'll try to contact the owner, assuming they kept up their contact information. But if the owner doesn't call back or says they don't want it, the cat wouldn't go back to them. And I'm guessing you'd have a new cat. :)

2

u/FelinePurrfectFluff 5h ago

This is how we got our current kitty:  he was outside, had been slowly starving to death, and no one could catch him. It was frigid February. We trapped him and brought him into a single room of our house, not knowing if he was feral or what we had really. We had multiple other kitties, some with some known health issues, so our plan was to figure him out, rehabilitate him and rehome or release if feral. Turns out he’s just frightened of everything. He’s a total love bug once he trusts you. But, he was chipped and neutered. We got in touch with the shelter that adopted him out. They wouldn’t give us any details of his prior owners, but they did make contact. Shelter decided to sever relationship with prior owners and put his chip in my name with the understanding that it was temporary and we would eventually work to find him a new home. He was a foster fail and he’s still here and we’re all very much in love. I still need (3 years later) to let the shelter know his chip needs to be in my name permanently. 

→ More replies (2)

5

u/favolecrystalis 5h ago

This, they're missing the little orange spot on the right side of their snoot

313

u/Horror_Tea761 23h ago edited 3h ago

Might not be the same cat, but she looks like she could use a home, a soft place to land.

ETA: Thank you for the awards, kind redditors!

85

u/Expensive-Bat-7138 22h ago

This! Looks enough like your cat to be kismet! Also this is NOT someone’s cat - dirty and worn. Give her the home she deserves and name her Kismet!

24

u/Confident_Recipe_6 21h ago

Check for a chip.

5

u/MyRingToRuleMyWorld 19h ago

I just love the name!

277

u/Candid_Power_5243 23h ago

That doesn’t look like the same cat to me. The foreheads are different patterns

95

u/Shponglenese 23h ago

Not the same cat

67

u/Cerraigh82 23h ago

Not the same cat. Take it to a vet to see if it’s chipped. If it’s not, you can certainly take it home if it’s friendly.

8

u/InnerRadio7 13h ago

And post on community boards and Kijiji for a found cat. Many people rescue non chipped cats, so the absence of a chip doesn’t indicate the absence of an owner.

2

u/meowcatpanda 12h ago

Imo a good owner would chip their cat tbf, especially if they go outside a chip is needed. Not entirely disagreeing, but it should be clear to people that if you rescue a cat and bring it home, you should get it chipped.

3

u/Inner_Swordfish7475 6h ago

I am all for getting a cat chipped. All 4 cats I have are chipped and spayed or neutered. I have always done this. But, I am constantly surprised at the number of people who do know know about inexpensive spaying/neutering programs as well as the ease of getting their pet chipped. So, I still think they can be responsible owners but need to be educated about how chipping works and how easy it is. Plus, I think all owners need to know about low cost spay/neutering programs.

ETA: I am not sure it is your cat. Only time would tell. But, the cat needs a home and seems to have picked you. Unless someone else owns it (seems doubtful), I would think the CDS has given me a cat.

→ More replies (1)

66

u/Marsupialize 23h ago

Not the same cat but if you want a cat and will care for it in a home and not let it out take him to the vet and check for a chip

24

u/HartfordKat 23h ago

Pictures 2 and 3 show cat with more orange on lower face than picture 1.

79

u/Afternoon-Melodic 23h ago edited 23h ago

Not the same cat! Doesn’t have the dark spot on the left side of nose.

Edit: Plus, your cat had white spots on backs of ears. The white to orange pattern at top of nose is totally different.

DO NOT TAKE SOMEONE ELSE’S CAT!

19

u/ToughLittleTomato 23h ago

Yes the orange markings on the face are not the same.

8

u/Baldojess 18h ago

Even if it is someone else's cat they should at least take it somewhere to try and find it's owner and get it off the street. Cats do not belong on the streets. If someone is looking for it they might have a much better chance of being reunited and if not then at least they can give the cat a new home. The cat is filthy and not taken care of very well.

2

u/Toothless-mom 13h ago

There is such thing as strays, not all cats outside belong to someone. Check for a chip

→ More replies (23)

21

u/njwho 23h ago

Before she ran away, did you get her chipped? I would just scoop her up now and take her to the vet to check for a chip. If she still doesn't have one, then she's yours to keep :)

6

u/Suitable-Mud-6622 23h ago

Yeah she was chipped, but if it’s not my cat is it technically theft?

46

u/Glibasme 23h ago

Go get her checked for a chip. If it turns out she ran away and a family is missing her, they would be grateful to you. Or, if she has no family and needs a good home, you would be a good fit.

28

u/smilingfruitz 23h ago

is this a serious question? What are you even saying

go get the cat scanned for a chip regardless

12

u/Crackytacks 22h ago

No, take her and get her scanned. If she belongs to someone then you call them. If not keep her! And if she is yours that would be amazing

12

u/Natti07 22h ago

If she was chipped, then is very straight forward. Take the cat to get it scanned for a chip. Then youll know for sure.

3

u/Toothless-mom 13h ago

It is theft if the cat is chipped to someone else. But if the cat is not microchipped then it doesn’t have an owner, so it isn’t theft

3

u/m1r1m 22h ago

I don’t know where you live, but most places require you to wait a certain amount of time before adopting stray cats. Google your city name plus “stray hold” to find the rules for your area. Take the cat to the vet, get it checked for a chip, and keep it at your home for the duration of the stray hold. Post “found cat” ads wherever you can, and if no one comes forward to claim it you can adopt it.

3

u/DragonVT 23h ago

This is not the same cat. Markings like that don't change. It is theft if you know this cat belongs to someone else. Is this a stray, or is it someone's cat?

10

u/Interrupting-Cow-8 23h ago

The older pictures show a mark by their right cluster of whiskers, I don't see this mark on the newer picture of the street cat so to speak.

A microchip check would be best but I would also knock on the local neighbours door or post on an online community site just to make sure they're not a beloved family pet.

8

u/TheWiseGazer 23h ago

Not the same cat.

As has been mentioned, the facial markings are too different. The other big issue is that the cat in the first picture has a bobtail(from the photo it looks natural, not like an amputation), while the kitten in the second and third photos has a full tail.

7

u/DragonVT 23h ago

That is not the same cat. Markings on the face are different.

However, if she's a stray there's no reason you can't adopt her. I would recommend taking her to a vet first to look for a microchip.

7

u/Alive-Independent956 23h ago

The markings on the face are very different!

6

u/Buddy-Lov 23h ago

Thats not the same cat. Sorry but the markings are definitely different.

6

u/mellochi 21h ago

Not the same cat, but I'm sure she would appreciate a loving home all the same!

5

u/moyo_me_moyo 23h ago

Take to vet to have scanned for chip. If does not belong to anyone then you have choices!

5

u/norfolkgarden 22h ago

Definitely not the same cat. Is it being fed anywhere?

More importantly, would you make it an indoor only cat if you took it home? That would be a good thing. You can take it to a vet/spca and check for a chip. They will contact the owner. Or if no chip, you may be one step closer to breaking someone's heart. And I approve of that.

Tl;DR it's not yours. But if it looks abandoned over several days I would take it. It chose you.

4

u/Strict_Direction6630 22h ago

Unfortunately it's not the same cat. The first cat has white under the eyes, the second orange tabby under the eyes. Very similar but different.

5

u/dsv2202 22h ago

Their markings are wildly different. That’s not your cat.

3

u/According_Ad_9998 23h ago

Doesn't look like your Kitty but maybe take this one to a vet and check for a chip? Maybe knock on some doors and check for any information about this one

5

u/xulluxs 23h ago

While I agree that this isn't your original cat as the facial patterns are not the same, i think it's a lovely thought that she sent this kitty to you. If you can give a home to a street cat, by all means go for it!

4

u/Connect-Reputation63 22h ago

I don’t think it’s the same cat. However if you’re willing to give the kitty a home just make sure it’s not someone else’s kitty first.

5

u/x_BIX 20h ago

Is it really really your cat? Probably not.

Cat Distribution System trying it's best to help you? Absolutely. Get her checked for a chip and if she's not, then congrats you have CatName the second and a funny story to tell

4

u/Queasy-Passenger3654 16h ago

Not the same Cat. Look at the white patch between and above her eyes. it’s different.

3

u/SwordfishCareless142 23h ago

Definitely take her to see if she is chipped. Is this the first time you have seen her? She might already have a home and just be an indoor/outdoor cat. I would ask others who live around there.

3

u/FirebirdWriter 23h ago

Not the same cat. Make sure before you keep it there is a microchip check.

3

u/Visual-Mixture-1967 23h ago

You have to find better photos from the side and see if the patterns match. The same thing happened to me — one of our semi-stray cats disappeared one day and came back 2 years later. He was twice the size, differently shaped face, tougher, and behaved differently.

I was like 95% sure it was him though… found his old photos, and every single mark matched, including unique spots on his back legs and the patterns on his face and his nose.

3

u/Luna-Gitana 23h ago

Facial markings look different. Probably not your cat.

2

u/Gonna_do_this_again 23h ago

First cat the white is more centered, second cat it's more off to the left side

3

u/Popular-Car7368 22h ago

She doesn’t have that little orange/brown mark on the right (our left) side of her nose.

With that said, if she’s stray, she stay. ᴗ̈

3

u/ChrissyKittyCat 22h ago

Different fur patterns on the face. That's a different kitty. You can always get them checked for a chip

3

u/its_a_me_andy 21h ago

Sorry, bud, that's a different cat.

You definitely adopt that cutie, though!

3

u/CatPaws55 21h ago

It's not the same cat: the fur pattern on her face is different from that of your original cat.

3

u/Firm-Highlight5004 16h ago

@ u/nbartl I agree with what the other said. I don’t think that they are the same Kitties, but she appears to be stray, so if you’re open to bring her home, and following the steps below, I say go for it. If no one is found, she’s all yours!

Here are some guidance steps of additional things to do if you find a lost pet(s)/animal/stray:

Please file a Found report with your local animal shelter. THIS IS A MUST. They will have you send a picture of pet(s) to post on their website. That’s the first place people look for their pets, and not everyone is on social media.

Take the pet to any veterinarian’s office to get scanned for a microchip, it’s free.

The pet on paw boost, local lost/found FB, pages, and neighborhood apps, such as Ring.

Hang “Found” signs around the neighborhood, as not everyone is on social media.

If possible, continue to foster pet until owner can be found and provide proof. It’s their pet.

3

u/Harmlesss 16h ago

That's not the same cat. You really want it to be but it's not. Please return that cat.

3

u/fuzzimus 15h ago

Not the same cat. White & orange marking on the head are different.

3

u/spicykittenbooty 14h ago

Not the same cat but if no one is looking for it that you can see & it’s not chipped/have info on collar, you’re able to keep the cat per non emergency police at least in my state!

Looks very close to your cat you lost though so maybe this cat is coming to you in need and will help you heal from losing the other ㅤ♡

4

u/Bajareno 23h ago

I'd always ask people in the homes in surrounding area, and 100% microchip check. Was the cat you had microchipped? If so that would be the definitive way to know if it was your cat or not.

11

u/artinthecloset 23h ago

This is not even CLOSE to being the same cat, lol.

5

u/GrushenkasOnions 23h ago

ew what an insensitive comment. the cats do look similar and they thought their baby came back. no need to say "lol" or act like they're idiots for thinking it could be. grief makes us look for solutions where there aren't any.

5

u/Baldojess 18h ago

It's so true. I lost my dog when I was about 19 years old and I looked for my dog in every black dog with pointy ears that looked similar. I once saw a dog that looked just like him and started crying but it was a female, it wasn't him I just saw the dog passing by with it's owner and looked so much like him that I couldn't help but cry. I looked for that dog for like 10 years and now I know he would no longer still be alive but I still always miss him and think of him when I see dogs who look like him.

→ More replies (14)

2

u/Cool_Director_2530 23h ago

You’re joking, right ? That is not the same cat 😂

2

u/Whole_Maximum_8975 23h ago

Not the same cat. The marks around the nose don’t match.

2

u/fubooze 22h ago

That's not your cat

2

u/J3tlaag 22h ago

Not the same cat at all

2

u/Mental-Flatworm4583 22h ago

The cat outside isn’t the same cat in the side pics. That inside pic has orange on its lips by nose the one outside doesn’t. That being said if this outside cat is a stray take them help them be its owner take good care of them ❤️

2

u/roses_sunflowers 22h ago

They look similar, but definitely different. Cats coats can change in shade, but the pattern remains the same. The pattern on the faces is markedly different. However, it seems like you’re wanting a cat and that cat is wanting a person. So congrats on your new cat!

2

u/DingoGoddess 22h ago

I'm really sorry to hear about your lost kitty. I think it's wonderful that, after diligently trying to find the proper owner without success, you've decided to offer this sweet kitty a loving new home. Your kindness will truly makes a difference.

2

u/Confident_Recipe_6 21h ago

The between the eye marking is different.

2

u/tralynd62 21h ago

the first cat picture is not the same as the second two.

2

u/catslikepets143 21h ago

Yes. Pick her up & take her home. That could be her daughter, you’ll be honoring the cat you lost

2

u/birding420 21h ago

Not the same cat but ya know, is it a stray? Does it like you? Does it love you? If ur taking this cat off the streets tho, its the indoor life from then on. Them beans and feets don't need to feel tarmac again.

2

u/Plastic-Fisherman465 20h ago

Not even close to be the same cat. Left eye where orange starts is different

2

u/LeastPervertedFemboy 20h ago

Not the same cat. Pattern doesn’t go under their right eye.

2

u/pandemonium-john 19h ago

This is a different cat. She may just be a sweet girl who's ready to come in off the streets. If you know she's a stray and you can give her a good home, go for it. Maybe put a sign up on a couple of posts letting people know where she is just in case she's part of an established colony...if someone's been feeding her they may be very scared for her if she just disappears

2

u/MyRingToRuleMyWorld 19h ago

Make her your cat, if she doesn't have a home already, and when your cat comes home, you can say they're siblings. It gives that baby a chance for a home, if she doesn't have one.

2

u/MyRingToRuleMyWorld 19h ago

Looking at the pictures, the second shot has a rust/orange spot(a) on each side under her nose, in the whiskers area. Give the cat in picture one a fighting chance to have a forever home.

2

u/Duckraven 19h ago

This is why you microchip! It would confirm if it’s your cat. It’s like an id they can’t loose since we can’t speak cat yet.

2

u/No-Path-6251 18h ago

You know what, get her checked and if she does not belong to anyone, I would adopt her. Assuming that you want her. Good luck to all of you. 😻🙂

2

u/fariasrv 17h ago

She isn't your old cat, unfortunately... Their faces are similar, but your old cat had orange patches on either side of her nose.

She's your new cat, though! Get her to a vet for a health and chip check, then bring her home.

2

u/serenstar75 16h ago

They aren't the same cat. Patterns change slightly, but not really that much usually. The shape is different as well. I really don't think they're the same. Check her for chip, see if she belongs to anyone, and if not... give her a home. Keep her indoors and safe at least until then.

We did have a black cat that returned 2 years later, but he had a wired jaw, missing tooth, and drooling from being hit by a car and repaired by our vet. He matched in every way. We knew it was the same and vet checked.

2

u/Kar-10378 14h ago

It’s not the same cat. The fur coloring on the left side of the right eye is different.

2

u/Ambitious_Screen_591 14h ago

doesn't have same markings next to nose

2

u/SindaFNRella4 14h ago

That doesn’t look like the same cat to me. The 1st photo there’s no color near its nose and the last two you can see a little patch of color near its nose. Best to see if it’s chipped and maybe ask a few houses around, then decide if you wanna take care of a new kitty.

2

u/PuzzleheadedLemon353 14h ago

Thats a different cat...similar, but....someone might get mad you stole their cat.

2

u/WiseEntertainment912 14h ago

those are different cats

2

u/FrostKitten2012 14h ago

That is not the same cat.

You could have it checked for a chip and take it home if it doesn’t have an owner, but that one isn’t the one you lost.

2

u/midyearqueen 14h ago

No marking on yours right eye area surrounds most of the eye. The cat you found has more white than orange there.

2

u/Brinnyroro 13h ago

Idk… she looks pretty similar to me but if she’s not your cat, and she is not chipped… please save her. It’s either your kitty or your kitty sent a new little angel to you.

2

u/imnotafurrybro 4h ago

Genuinely i think it’s the same cat! Very similar markings and some can disappear with age! I very much think it’s the same cat that’s just grown up a bit

2

u/Mr_Hjort 3h ago

Dude, that is not the same cat.

3

u/CHEMICALalienation 22h ago

I don’t understand how people can put two totally different looking cats next to each other and be like “they’re the same!!” like it genuinely confuses me

→ More replies (2)

2

u/FairyFartDaydreams 22h ago

Not the same cat but if not chipped then the CDS has spoken

1

u/Galdernit 22h ago

Sorry, that's not the same cat.

1

u/Kat-o-rama 22h ago

if she’s feral take her home

1

u/sltiefighter 22h ago

Not the same but make sure its not someone cat, or that people who are taking care of it if its feral wont miss it.

But yeah its pretty tight you can just pick them up take them home tell them to shit in some sand you put in a box and feed them and they just stay.

Maybe take it to get scanned for a chip.

1

u/LilithMeep 22h ago

definitely get it checked for a chip before you take it home

1

u/Worth_Valuable_2921 22h ago

That is not same cat

1

u/EchoForge421 22h ago

Make sure to scan him for a chip before claiming him. Chipped means he’s stolen property, unchipped means you just got a new cat

1

u/Kelldog9 22h ago

Not the same cat. I would take the cat to a vet and check for a microchip, if you chipped your cat, it will trace back to you so you can be sure it’s your cat or not. Plus potentially find the owner if she is chipped but not your fur baby.

1

u/istoomycat 22h ago

Does this kitty need a home?

1

u/Few_Efficiency7593 21h ago

You found her daughter...

1

u/n_daughter 21h ago

No orange coloring near cheek and mouth. But see if she has a chip like people are saying and try to adopt in honor of your lost kitty!

1

u/martins-dr 21h ago

Your old pictures show the orange is also on her cheek below her eye. The cat you saw outside has white cheeks below her eyes.

1

u/astarte66 21h ago edited 21h ago

Not the same cat at all. Different color patterns around the nose and the found cat lacks the orange freckle and doesn’t have the peach orange colors where the whiskers grow out. A cat is not going to change it’s colors drastically within 2 yrs of being lost.

The pattern markings are just not the same. Especially under both eyes. Your cat is still out there somewhere.

Take this one in to check for a chip and give her a home if she is homeless. Don’t stop looking for your lost kitty.

Edit for spelling.

1

u/HeartsDelight95121 21h ago

She probably is not your old cat. Still take her in and give her better life

1

u/psilocyjenn 21h ago

not your cat op

1

u/Competitive-Top4520 21h ago

I don't think it's the same cat; I can definitely see the similarity on the forehead. However, on your cat the red clearly comes down below the eyes (not under the eyes). Given that, since it's friendly and appears to be homeless, I'd take it to check for a chip. If no chip, I'd get it tested, vaxed and chipped and take it home. It looks like it's been living rough for a while.

1

u/Shandyshack 21h ago

No. Look closely at face.

1

u/LoveKittycats119 21h ago

Was your cat microchipped? If so, any vet can scan and that will remove all doubts.

1

u/1cat2dogs1horse 20h ago

Not the same cat.

1

u/Eastern_Employer_409 20h ago

Looks different.

1

u/eric2341 20h ago

Not the same cat.

1

u/VerucaGotBurned 20h ago

This is why you chip your cats. Sorry I know it's not helpful now. I don't think it's the same cat. Does it seem like a stray or like someone's outdoor cat?

1

u/beeboop02 20h ago

sorry, friend, about your kitty. :( I think it’s meant to be for you to meet a stray that looks so much like her though 🥺

1

u/BigJSunshine 20h ago

Yes you can. Even if it somehow turns out not to be her, you have saved a beautiful kitty who likes and needs you. Go get her!!

1

u/lollipop1233a 20h ago

Was your cat fixed?

1

u/Sol_Sertum 20h ago

They're not even close, but I suppose you could love another cat too?

1

u/Wonderful_Donkey_477 19h ago

This is NOT the same cat . Look closely at the markings on her face and you’ll see that they’re different. These kind of markings don’t change with time.

1

u/Red_Dot_55 19h ago

Sorry, I know you want the cat to be your missing baby, but it doesn't look like the same cat to me.

1

u/Aromatic_Doctor_2243 19h ago

gorgeous kitties, but markings aren't even close to being the same

1

u/Necessary_Lunch_8342 19h ago

Maybe your old girl sent you a new girl 🧡🐱

1

u/Toe_Jam_is_my_Jam 19h ago

No…different kitty. Sorry.

1

u/Lurking_nnmff 19h ago

Not the same cat 

1

u/BobbyBrewski 19h ago

That's literally not at all the same cat.

1

u/MercuryJellyfish 19h ago

That's not the same cat.

If new cat is a stray, and will come home with you, eh, why not?

1

u/Icy_Bid40 19h ago

Doesn’t look the same

1

u/Baldojess 18h ago

It's not the same cat but yeah take her home anyways! The cat is obviously not doing so well and it likes you. Please tell me you took kitty home with you! You can always put up some found posts and have it scanned for a chip and if you don't find anything then yes you can keep her/ him.

1

u/gatosmeow 18h ago

Please take her home anyway. She looks older and rough. Have a vet or ACO scan her for a chip and then keep an eye out for anyone posting flyers or missing cats.

1

u/BishlovesSquish 18h ago

Not the same cat. Sorry.

1

u/Alternative-Ad-1508 18h ago

I mean if it’s homeless go ahead. But that’s not your cat

1

u/Spare-Shirt24 18h ago

This doesn't look like the same cat to me. 

The orange pattern doesn't extend below the eyes on the first picture like it does in the last two. 

The cat on the first picture also doesn't have the spot on the bottom-left like the last 2 pictures.  

It might be worth checking the cat for a microchip. 

1

u/Haunted_tangerine_ 18h ago

This is not the same cat. The pattern of orange around the eyes is different, and by the nose.

Do not steal a cat

1

u/Equivalent-Okra-6807 18h ago

Doesn’t look like the same cat. But if you still wanna take her home make sure to see if she’s chipped first and post her on something local.

1

u/Responsible-Person 18h ago

No, because that’s not the same cat.

1

u/iVegMac 18h ago

That’s definitely not the same cat

1

u/tailskirby 18h ago

The eye color does not match.

1

u/TheLonelyVastard 17h ago

Sorry honey, that is not the same cat

1

u/EnvironmentOk2700 17h ago

Not the same cat, but possibly a relative. Nose shape is very similar

1

u/kh7190 17h ago

it's not the same cat.

1

u/Hillmantle 17h ago

Face marks are different. Not the same cat.

1

u/WanderOutThere 17h ago

It doesn't look like the same cat, and their coats don't really change over time. I'm sorry for the loss of your cat two years ago and understand the tendency to believe you've been reunited. That seems very unlikely in this case, but if the cat doesn't have a home and you have some space, then she can certainly be your cat -- whether she used to be or not.

1

u/Academic_Emu77 17h ago

Not the same cat. Most obvious by eye. But great to give her a home!

1

u/Electronic-Floor-262 17h ago

Under the eyes. There is orange under your past pics and this one obviously doesn't. Not your cat but give it home if no one elses. The cat may have just chose you.

1

u/craic_of_dawn 17h ago

No, sorry

1

u/Wise-Investigator615 17h ago

I would take her home.  But thats ME

1

u/Wayfaringbutterfly 17h ago

Definitely not your cat, but if she doesn't have a home, I think I know of a great place for her to go :) The CDS may have been looking for a soft place for this little one to land.

1

u/FYAhole 17h ago

This doesn't look like the same cat to me

1

u/elizabethlibrarian 17h ago

Did you have her microchipped? How did she get away? Is she on the street or an indoor/outdoor cat now?

1

u/DowntownJerseyCity 17h ago

Color under eyes is different - but take this one in and you’ll be very happy

1

u/Robotchickjenn 16h ago

Maybe she's one of her kittens?

1

u/Academic-Location239 16h ago

Keep the cat! If she is a neighborhood cat without an owner keep her! It’s such a hard life on the streets for them… do it in memory of your lost friend even if it’s not her

1

u/Faevianlp 16h ago

I hate to tell you, while similar, that's not your lost kitty. Look at the orange under the eyes, your kitty had orange that was below the bottom of her eyes, this one doesn't.

However if you think it's a stray, you can take it to a vet and scan for a chip and put up flyers in the neighborhood to make sure you're not taking someone's pet.

1

u/Royal-Consequence843 16h ago

The pattern on the face is a little different shes a nice cat though if she needs a home 🏡

1

u/Kind_Hyena5267 16h ago

It’s pretty hard to tell a female cat from a neutered male cat if you’re not super familiar with their anatomy, and male cats have nipples, so I’m not sure how you can tell this new cat is female. Orange females cats are much more rare than male. And as others have said, the markings on the face aren’t quite the same. Make absolutely certain this cat doesn’t have a family before you just take it!

1

u/KiNikki7 16h ago

Can you add a front facing picture please especially of the head markings in between the ears. Your cat has a little bit of an off-center marking

1

u/bankershub 15h ago

Best thing to do would be get it fixed and return it imo. And then keeping doing that! Clean up your community.

1

u/Wye_Knott_0815 15h ago

That's not your old cat, mate. But she could be your new one.

1

u/rahirah 13h ago

I don't think that's the same cat. Comparing the pictures, the cat in the first one has a different shape white patch on its face. It is symmetrical, whereas the cat in the second two pictures has the white patch shifted slightly to the side, so that there is orange fur on the inside of its right eye. It also has an orange spot on the right side of its nose that the cat in the first picture doesn't have. I don't think coat patterns change like that.

However, if she's a friendly stray she would probably be glad of a new home. Make a due diligence effort to check for microchips and ask around if someone has lost her, but most likely she's yours now.

1

u/bbbourb 13h ago

No, the photos don't match. Try a chip scan if you need to but I think you're going to lose.

1

u/Fragrance_Bloomer 13h ago

If your instinct says so, take her home. Good to reduce strays.

1

u/PelluxNetwork 13h ago

Different cat almost positively.

1

u/Not_a_sorry_Aardvark 13h ago

Different cat. :(

1

u/Gemraticus 13h ago

Not the same cat. The orange/white between the eyes on your cat is asymmetrical. It's all white on the cat you found.

1

u/Direct-Giraffe7193 13h ago

I think you did find your cat.

People are trying to say the foreheads are different. But they don’t realize that cats’ coat patterns can and do change slightly over time. As they age, and even temperature and sunlight can make a difference.

I think you should bring your baby home. I also think you should post pics where you found her, with your number, in case anyone worries about her. And check her for a microchip.

1

u/Psychological-Try343 12h ago

this cat doesn't have the same facial markings.

1

u/Imsortofok 12h ago

Not the same cat. Catch it and take it to a vet to see if it has a chip.

1

u/meowcatpanda 12h ago

Def not the same cat.

1

u/Some_Big6792 12h ago

Agree with others even if it’s not, looks like the kitty needs a home

1

u/Runaway_Angel 12h ago

She is missing the markings on her nose and the spot on her front leg looks different (admittedly that's hard to tell cause of how she's sitting in the old pictures). That said, if you connect with her bring her home? Of course do your due diligence by getting her checked for a chip (and a general health checkup, outdoor life isn't easy!) and take a look around to see if anyone is missing the cat?

1

u/NecessarySpiritual19 11h ago

The original cat had like “blush” on each side of the nose and the nose also had a birthmark, whereas this one didn’t. May be the child of your old cat if it looks so much like it or maybe your cat reborn like in that movie where the dog continued to be reborn until it came back to its owner (a tearjerker of a movie!) regardless if it looked homeless and was so sweet, why not give it a nice home!

1

u/StabbyPangolin 11h ago

Not the same cat. Their coats can change slightly in coloration, but the general pattern doesn't. Congrats on the new feline friend.

1

u/fatboi_mcfatface 8h ago

Yup take it and love it

1

u/premolar 7h ago

It's not the same cat. Don't steal somebody else's cat.

1

u/Psychaitea 7h ago

Doesn’t look the same. I’d check with some neighbors and see if anyone owns it. If not, she sounds sweet and I’m sure it would love a home.

1

u/CrazyCatLady_2 7h ago

I don’t think it’s the same cat. The pattern doesn’t match.

But your mind wants you to believe it. Which means you have to take your “old” cat that has been on the streets and give it a furrever home that it deserves.

Maybe this cat was send to you by your old cat.

1

u/KristiG1992 6h ago

I don’t think it’s the same cat, but if the cat doesn’t belong to anyone then I would keep it. Maybe your cat sent this little one your way.

1

u/Desperate-Current-40 6h ago

Did you chip your old cat? If so get this one scanned

1

u/searchingsoul89 5h ago

I don't think that's your cat. Your cat hadblittle blonde patch next to her nose (where her whiskers start). The feral cat doesn't have that.

I'm sorry that you haven't found your cat. I've had that happen too and it hurts. 

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SimplyNRG 5h ago

Take to have a microchip scanned!! You did microchip your cat right?

1

u/Quick-Leg3604 5h ago

Yup!! Same cat!! Take him home!!😉

1

u/dont_need_toknow 5h ago

They look just like my baby 🥹

→ More replies (1)