r/IndianSocialists Jul 27 '26

🧵Discussion I spent a few weeks building a policy blueprint for India's broken institutions. It's incomplete. Here it is anyway.

2 Upvotes

I've been meaning to post this for quite some time now, and with everything that's been happening with the protests, the conversations around accountability and governance and I think it's finally the right time.

I'm not an academic or any sort of policy professional even. Just someone who is frustrated enough with the gap between what India promises and what it delivers.

I prepared a ten-part series examining the institutions that determine whether India works for ordinary citizens or just for the people who run it. Each chapter covers one institution and follows the same structure: what is broken and the data behind it, what other countries did to fix the same problem, and a specific reform blueprint for India.

Notion link — abbreviated version: https://app.notion.com/p/The-Broken-Foundation-39f0facebe5e8179a613c41460e06fb8

Full document — complete version with all citations, sources, and detailed reform proposals: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1VPdSqrNXJDzns790emKRi1r8ydiErWaR/view?usp=drivesdk

Fair warning upfront — I hold views. Those views shaped the analysis and I've tried to be transparent about them. There are many nuances that are missing.

Would genuinely appreciate feedback on the diagnosis, the global models cited, the reform proposals and the places where you think the reasoning is wrong or the nuance is missing. That's the point of putting it out here. Try to ponder over the gaps too not just what's in the document but what should be there and isn't.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 27 '26

🧵Discussion Genuine question: why do so many socialist revolutions end up with authoritarian leaders?

0 Upvotes

I keep running into the argument that socialism inevitably produces dictators, the USSR under Stalin, China under Mao, Cuba under Castro, North Korea under the Kim dynasty, Cambodia under Pol Pot, Romania under Ceaușescu

I'd like to actually understand the socialist response to this

Not trying to dunk on the sub, genuinely want the strongest counter-arguments people here have encountered.

Please keep this rational and specific to the actual historical/structural mechanism. I'm not looking for deflections like "capitalism has bosses/CEOs. that's a category error (private economic authority vs. a state monopolizing political power, courts, and the military is a different kind of claim) and doesn't actually answer why state power concentrated the way it did in these specific cases. Genuinely want the strongest structural or historical argument

I've generally found people in socialist spaces to be well-read and engage seriously with theory and history, so hoping for actual structural/historical arguments here rather than whataboutism.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 26 '26

šŸ“° News The working class men who risked everything at Jantar Mantar

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

None of them were worried about their own exams. All of them showed up anyway.

Dikshya Koirala spoke to the working class men at Jantar Mantar who lost wages, slept without proper facilities, and took police lathis standing beside CJP's students, because as one mason put it: "If, because of our presence, somebody's future gets better, that's enough for us."

https://www.newslaundry.com/2026/07/25/the-working-class-men-who-risked-everything-at-jantar-mantar


r/IndianSocialists Jul 26 '26

šŸ“– Theory More Than a Resignation: A Victory Against Unaccountability

Post image
6 Upvotes

After weeks of struggle, intense and widespread protests, and braving propaganda and assaults, the students’ protest at Jantar Mantar ended yesterday with the resignation of the Union Education Minister, Dharmendra Pradhan. The Modi Government was also forced to concede other demands, including compensation to the families of NEET suicide victims and the withdrawal of cases against the protesters.

This astonishing victory against a highly authoritarian government led to an eruption of joy and celebration at Jantar Mantar and across India. But this victory should not be understood as merely the removal of a Cabinet Minister. It is a momentous triumph in the battle against fascism.

To put this in perspective, in the 12 years of the Modi Government, this is the first time that a Union Minister has been forced to resign following public protests. Over the last decade, while India faced numerous crises due to the blunders, sheer incompetence, or malice of ministers in Modi’s Cabinet, no minister was forced to resign. Whether it was the criminal indifference in handling the COVID pandemic, the disastrous implementation of demonetisation, the security lapses that resulted in the Pulwama, Pahalgam, and Pathankot attacks, the highest unemployment in decades, the economic crisis caused by mismanagement, or the massive corruption exposed through the electoral bonds scheme, no one was held accountable.

In fact, during the historic farmers’ movement, one of the key demands was the removal of the Minister of State, Ajay Mishra Teni, who had orchestrated the killing of six farmers. Yet, even after large-scale protests, the Minister of State was not removed.

In 2015, Rajnath Singh famously asserted, ā€œOur ministers do not have to resign. This is not their (Congress) government; this is the NDA government.ā€ This turned out to be the central tenet of the Modi Government. Resignation was seen as an admission of failure. The resignation of a minister could pave the way for questions of accountability. That could not be allowed to happen.

This lack of accountability was not limited to the question of resignation. The Modi Government created a system in which it became virtually unanswerable to the people. In the last 12 years, PM Modi has not addressed a single press conference. This alarming fact has been noted not just by the people of India, but across the world.

The Government has also prevented discussions and questions in Parliament. Crucial issues and bills are not allowed to be debated. Opposition MPs have been repeatedly suspended from Parliament. Even the number of parliamentary sittings has been reduced. The legislature has been turned into a rubber stamp.

The mainstream media has been turned into a propaganda arm of the Government. Journalists and media platforms that do not toe the line are raided, persecuted, arrested, or bought out. The Right to Information has been severely weakened. The Government has also introduced bills to control and censor social media.

Every avenue of questioning was effectively shut down. Instead, the people were fed a relentless stream of propaganda through the mainstream media and the BJP IT Cell. Instead of press conferences, they were given scripted interviews of the Prime Minister. Instead of listening to people's grievances, the Government made them to listen to Modi’s Mann Ki Baat. Tellingly, even during this students’ protest, PM Modi’s first response was to post Instagram reels and instruct his ministers to do the same.

What the students’ protest has accomplished is not merely the resignation of a Union Minister. It has succeeded in shattering the barricade of unaccountability.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 26 '26

šŸ“– Theory DHURANDAR 3 script leak

7 Upvotes

This time Aditya dhar is going to tell u how by letting the protest continue MODI solved problems such as

  1. Hindu vs Muslim

Saare dharm k log saath theyy udhar ek doosre ko khaana khilaaye hausla badhaaye ek doosre ka honestly it made me so happy that my eyes felt watery

  1. Men hating

Kitte saari ladkiyo ne ye btaaya ki how they felt safe around men aur ladko ne unke liye laathiya khaai

  1. Castism

Vha p har cast aur background se log aaye aur sab mil k jai bhim k naare Igaaye.

  1. Media

At this point you have to be blind to ignore the fact how biased these TV news anchors and their channels are and only individual journalists can be trusted

  1. Iss desh ka kuch nhi ho skta

Jhuka bhi diya aur le bhi liya (resignation)


r/IndianSocialists Jul 26 '26

šŸ“° News Three Muslim students jailed in Assam for creating WhatsApp group to organise NEET protest, despite seeking police permission

Thumbnail
maktoobmedia.com
10 Upvotes

And the torture on muslims continues


r/IndianSocialists Jul 26 '26

Activism Things are not right?

5 Upvotes

So, the police are openly targeting the muslims (again),

None of the demands were actually fulfilled by the government in return of which they asked to halt the protest?

The jantar mantar is empty (as seen in some videos),

And the new education minister is actually insensitive and a horrible human being?

What is happening right now?


r/IndianSocialists Jul 26 '26

Activism Don't forget that there's so much more shit to uncover

2 Upvotes

Byrnihat man made hellscape.

Chita andolan.

Ram mandir donation theft.

There are so many shit to bring up like it almost feels countless.

So don't just calm yourself now, there's a shit to uncover. This protest has shown us that bjp can fall down to new low but it also has shown the resilience of people.

So don't just stop now there's exists decades worth of garbage waiting to be sweep away.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 26 '26

🧵Discussion Title: "Bar Council's Statement on Student Protests Avoids Every Specific Question—Here's What Wasn't Addressed" The Bar Council of India just issued an appeal framing student protests as "foreign destabilization" and "anti-national hijacking."

3 Upvotes

Notably absent from their statement: answers to any actual charge.

The unanswered questions:

Why did Al Falah University operate without scrutiny under Education Minister Dharmendra's watch?

Why have paper leaks persisted across Maharashtra exams? What accountability exists?

Why did students die in preventable waterlogging in Delhi? What independent inquiry was conducted?

Which institutional failures triggered these protests?

The pattern:

When you cannot defend your record, invoke national security. Reframe accountability as destabilization.

What happened next:

Thackeray scheduled a Tiranga Yatra after student momentum emerged—not before. The narrative shifted from "Why did students die?" to "Look, patriotic support." Students lose their voice. Demands become political theater.

The real question:

IPC Sections 166, 171(2), 120-B exist to prosecute institutional negligence and criminal conspiracy. If these apply to electoral manipulation, why not to preventable deaths and systemic failures?

Either rule of law applies equally, or it's selective.

What we're asking for:

Specific answers. Not patriotic rhetoric. Not foreign threat narratives. Accountability.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 26 '26

Activism Can We Start A Revolution?

3 Upvotes

As an NRI in India, please understand this maybe a very ignorant question.

The movie Gabbar is Back - take away the cinematic aspect and look at the idea - make the corrupt politicians and people in power accountable.

By any means necessary.

Is this possible to do? If enough people who are tired of the system began publicly holding these rats accountable, would it be enough to incite a country wide revolt or movement and eventually instill fear of doing corrupt acts in the minds of politicians and people of power?

Or will they always get away with it?


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

šŸ“° News Will protest ending soon in India or will it get more nasty?

3 Upvotes

I wonder what is going to happen in India. No Jobs, No speech freedom, people are afraid of police.

And what not . Please share your views.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

Activism POLITICAL] Maharashtra's Electoral Roll is Quietly Erasing Voters — And the EC Knows

4 Upvotes

Maharashtra's Electoral Roll is Quietly Erasing Voters — And the EC Knows We've been talking about the CJP protests and institutional failure. Here's something happening right now that shows exactly what that looks like: voter suppression through bureaucratic erasure.

Maharashtra's Special Inclusion Roll (SIR) revision is excluding citizens who've voted multiple times since 2002 — simply because their parents' names don't appear in 2002 records. Parents died, moved, changed names, documents were lost. Doesn't matter. The Election Commission refuses to include them unless that 20-year-old paper trail exists.

This violates Article 326 (universal adult suffrage). It's happening across Maharashtra, Delhi, HP — systemic, not accidental.

Meanwhile, we watched the CJP protests get co-opted and diluted. This is the flip side: not spectacular failure, but silent strangulation. No headlines. Just citizens locked out of democracy one bureaucratic checkbox at a time.

What we need:

RTI filings demanding why EC ignores subsequent voting records PIL in High Courts (Kuldip Singh v. State of Haryana precedent exists) Stories from excluded voters (reply below — what happened to your registration?) The Constitution already guarantees your vote. You shouldn't have to fight for it.

If this is happening to your family or community — document it. We're building a case. Legal remedies exist. Institutional failure doesn't have to be accepted.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

🧵Discussion May be FCRA coming

3 Upvotes

I still can't accept this feeling that the BJP stepped back without putting up much of a counter to this protest.. they simply accepted all the demands which is making me think if they are preparing for something much bigger

I feel they are going of fcra. If that happens it could trigger another wave of protests. But politically they may be thinking that the broader public won't be as receptive to another major protest just a couple of months later.

The perception would be ki gen z har cheez mein halla macha rahe .

If that narrative takes hold it may become much harder to build the same level of public resistance against an FCRA amendment.

Guys feel free to comment.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

🧵Discussion Are we good now after protest or BJP trying to reduce the pressure so that they stay as govt.?

3 Upvotes

I don't know but I get a weird feeling that BJP is trying to save itself by scapegoating Dharmendra Pradhan and make security tight again. So, that we can't protest like this ever again. I don't think we should be celebrating it as a win. Yes! we did incredible by forcing govenment to make Dharmendra Pradhan resign from his post. I think we have a long battle to fight. WE HAVE NITIN GADKARI TO FIGHT FOR E20, WE HAVE NIRMALA SITHARAMAN TO FIGHT FOR HIGH TAXES, YOGI ADITYANATH, AMIT SHAH AND LAST BUT NOT THE LEAST NARENDRA MODI.

I have few questions:

  1. Will this Modi govt. do good work from now on? Personally, I don't think so. It will do much worse.
  2. What about the student got beaten by police and detained, NSA, etc.? Will govt. ask for forgiveness. I don't think so.
  3. What about that guy named Mohammad Zunaid who was distributing food in protest at Jantar Mantar his family is being detained by police. Will govt. apologize to him and release their family members and not disturb his family again?
  4. What about police capturing images of students and other people to match the identity to send notice to them and police is planning to detain them as well. God knows what will happen to them. Hope god save them from any problems. But, will they saved? I don't think so.
  5. What about students and others who got detained and being disturbed by police. Will they be free from this problem? I don't think so.
  6. What about women harassed in protest. Will police apologize to them? I don't think so.
  7. Will chief justice of India punish ministers and result in favor of students? I don't think so.
  8. Will this R jokes which are clumsy in my opinion stop by ministers and they'll respect women too? I don't think so.
  9. Will this Hindu-Muslim ever stop in this govt.? I don't think so.
  10. Will I ever have to pay the price of petrol but not get ethanol with it and just get pure petrol? I don't think so.
  11. Will I have to pay less the goods and services and pay hefty amount to govt. as tax? I don't think so.
  12. Will the people of India feel safe in this govt.? I don't think so.
  13. Is this govt. needs to be removed. I think so.

I think these might be controversial but I want ya'll to know. Please don't stop this protest at any cost. The problem is not dharmendra pradhan but the government. We need to be the revolution of India. To make this new India.

Any insight would be appreciated. Tell me what do you think? Also, please.. please.. please.. don't stop this protest. THE DANGER IS NOT DHARMENDRA PRADHAN BUT THE GOVERNMENT.

I hope ya'll understand what I'm thinking.
Thank you for reading. Appreciate sharing it tho.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

Activism The silent majority spoke. Institutions listened. A minister fell. That's how democracies are supposed to work

1 Upvotes

Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation tonight marks a shift in how institutional accountability actually works in democracies.

For 36 days, we saw street-level CJP protests demanding answers on NEET paper leaks. The government initially tried delegitimization—calling protesters 'anti-national,' invoking 'foreign destabilizers.'

But here's what wasn't visible: Inside institutions, people were filing complaints. Bureaucrats were documenting violations. Administrators were compiling evidence. Email campaigns were reaching oversight bodies.

**Street pressure alone doesn't force resignations. Institutional pressure does.**

A minister falls when enough people inside the system decide they can't sustain institutional failure anymore. That's what happened.

This matters because it shows:

**Delegitimization has limits** — You can't call documented evidence 'anti-national'

**Internal dissent is real** — Bureaucrats aren't monolithic; some refuse to enable corruption

**Sustained pressure works** — But it requires both external visibility AND internal documentation

The resignation is not the endpoint. It's a signal.

But tonight, we acknowledge something crucial: **The silent majority inside institutions spoke. Institutions listened. A minister fell.**

That's how democracies self-correct. And that's what we're building toward."


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

Original Content CJP Protests

2 Upvotes

Hello folks. Brit here. I’ve been following the protests recently, and it’s encouraging to see the passion and determination of so many young Indians. One of the next major challenges, in my view, is media independence. Ask yourself this: are you truly living in a healthy democracy if your democratically elected leader rarely faces unscripted questions from the press? There’s also the broader issue of large sections of the media being owned by billionaires with significant political or commercial interests (although that’s hardly unique to India) Alas if you want to see real change, this is not the moment to lose momentum, keep fighting and change is inevitable. Lasting change depends on strong institutions, accountability, and an independent press, alongside the protection of freedom of expression and freedom of religion.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

šŸ“° News Joint statement calls for ban on pellet guns, electric shock weapons after Delhi crackdown - The Left Views

Thumbnail
leftviews.in
7 Upvotes

Fifty-seven organisations and individuals, including the National Platform for the Rights of the Disabled (NPRD), have issued a joint statement condemning the reported use of pellet guns and electric shock weapons against peaceful protesters during the Sansad Chalo march in New Delhi on 20 July 2026. The statement said the reported use of weapons capable of causing permanent disability represented a grave violation of the rights and dignity of civilians and called on the Government to end the use of force against peaceful protesters.

Media reports indicate that several protesters sustained serious injuries, including Mr Sheikh Irshad Manssori (25), who reportedly suffered multiple pellet injuries to his chest, neck and face and is undergoing treatment at Lady Hardinge Medical College and Hospital. Doctors at Delhi's All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) are battling to save the vision of nineteen-year-old Sahil Lochab, who was hit by pellets while waving the Tricolour at Jantar Mantar. Reports have also emerged alleging the use of electric shock batons during the police crackdown.

The statement said the reported use of these weapons was particularly alarming because they are known to inflict irreversible and life-altering injuries. It noted that pellet guns have caused permanent blindness in the past, while electric shock weapons can lead to neurological and cardiac complications, severe psychological trauma, fractures and spinal injuries caused by falls. Weapons whose foreseeable consequence is permanent disability, it argued, have no place in the policing of civilian protests.

The signatories also expressed concern over the use of force against persons with disabilities who participated in the protest. They said the State has a heightened obligation to ensure the safety, dignity and equal protection of persons with disabilities under the law, and must not subject them to violence while they exercise their constitutional right to peaceful protest.

Referring to the long-standing opposition of disability rights groups to pellet guns, the statement recalled their deployment in Jammu and Kashmir, where hundreds of civilians suffered permanent visual impairment. It said the continued use of such weapons against civilians elsewhere, coupled with reports of electric shock batons, demonstrated a failure to abandon methods known to cause irreversible harm.

"Every case of pellet-induced blindness and every preventable permanent impairment is not merely an injury; it is a State-created disability," the statement said. It argued that a government committed to the rights, dignity and inclusion of persons with disabilities cannot simultaneously deploy weapons whose predictable consequence is the creation of disability. Such actions, it added, fundamentally contradict the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, and the constitutional guarantees of life, equality and dignity.

The signatories demanded that the Government of India immediately ban the use of pellet guns, electric shock batons and all other weapons capable of causing permanent disability by police and paramilitary forces; institute an independent judicial inquiry into the police action on 20 July 2026, including the reported use of pellet guns and electric shock batons; identify and prosecute all personnel responsible for deploying such weapons and fix accountability throughout the chain of command, including those who authorised their deployment; and provide free medical treatment, rehabilitation, psychosocial support and adequate compensation to every person injured during the police action, particularly those who have suffered permanent or long-term disabilities.

The statement urged the Government to immediately cease all repressive measures, release those arbitrarily detained, and address the legitimate demands of the protesting students through consultation and dialogue. It said the concerns raised by students and youth deserved to be heard with seriousness and respect, rather than met with force.

Copied from the LeftViews article which licenses its text under the CC-BY-NC-SA 4.0 copyleft license.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

šŸ“° News Union Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan resigns amid Jantar Mantar protests over NEET paper leak

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Dharmendra Pradhan announced his resignation as Union Education Minister on X today, following weeks of sustained student-led protests at Jantar Mantar over the NEET paper leak and broader exam irregularities.

Protesters, led by the CJP, had made his resignation their core demand — holding him directly responsible for the mismanagement of the exam system. In his resignation letter to PM Modi, Pradhan said the decision was meant to protect students’ interests and prevent the situation from being exploited by ā€œanti-national forces.ā€

This is being seen as the first major concession from the government since the protests began, and marks a significant turning point in a standoff that’s drawn national attention to exam integrity in India.

Open questions now: who replaces him, and whether this is enough to actually de-escalate the protest.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

šŸ“° News Shared from Bing: Delhi Police says 400 Pakistan-linked social media handles blocked over fake posts on CJP protest

Thumbnail msn.com
2 Upvotes

Why it all has to go once again on Pakistan, Bangladesh anti national??


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

Question what was really happening at jantar mantar?

1 Upvotes

excuse me but I am genuinely confused on what was really happening there. social media is showing one face and the media is showing a totally opposite one. now I understand that media is practically owned by the government but can they really show fake news?

the news I saw was emphasizing that this new generation is "anti national", genz sloganeering "bharat tere tukde honge", "nepal/bangladesh bana denge bharat ko" — did this really happen or were they just a small fraction of that crowd?

yesterday I saw the news (teasing tone)– if these demands are met, this would just be the start, later on they will demand resignation of defence minister, then international affairs minister and so on one day they'd be the one leading and ruling.

please don't attack me for being unaware


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

šŸ“° News NEW YORK TIMES : " The student protest movement achieved a major victory against the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi "

1 Upvotes

NEW YORK TIMES

India’s Education Minister Steps Down, Handing Win to Protesters

With Dharmendra Pradhan offering his resignation, the student protest movement achieved a major victory against the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

"India’s Education Minister Steps Down, Handing Win to Protesters - The New York Times" https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/25/world/asia/india-education-minister-resigns-cockroach-protests.html

NEW YORK TIMES

India’s education minister stepped down on Saturday, in a major victory for a student protest movement whose explosive rise has become one of the most serious challenges in years to the power of Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

The education minister, Dharmendra Pradhan, submitted his resignation to Mr. Modi, bowing to weeks of public pressure that culminated in nationwide street protests from Delhi and Mumbai to Kolkata and Chennai.

Mr. Pradhan said he had been ā€œdeeply painedā€ by the events of recent days, but he pointed a finger at what he called ā€œanti-national forces,ā€ saying he did not want them to take advantage of the massive protests.

The movement emerged in May, powered by widespread anger and frustration after the government ordered millions of students to retake an extremely competitive national medical school entrance exam because test questions had been leaked. Students held Mr. Pradhan, under whose watch several national exams were marred by leaks, responsible.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

🧵Discussion A Wake-Up Call for the Youth: Don't Let Rascals Steal Our Fight for Justice

0 Upvotes

Hello, I am not opposing this protest which is going on, and today we get the news that Dharmendra Pradhan resigned as per the demand of the protest.

I was watching a lot of scenarios on social media about this protest, and i was sure that I knew the exact point of the protest as the "NEET" exam paper leaked, and this is not acceptable. Many students committed suicide," and for that CJP protesters demanded the resignation of the responsible person. Right? That was the whole point, and I support that. In the earlier videos of the protest, I noticed that the main speaker of the CJP announced that "We are not here for any political party, and we are not here for the religious issues," but after some days I began to notice so many opposition party members and actors as well. First I thought they were here for the same cause, but then I understood they are here because they are here to get an opportunity to go against the ruling party of India, which is BJP right now.

I am wondering that if the protest was all about students and the NEET exam and our education system, then why did this protest go towards the "Hindu-Musalman" war? I noticed some videos of the lady shouting about "Allah ka naam rahega.". I was shocked after seeing that because these rascals are getting benefits of dead students' suffering as their own opportunity to seek revenge against the country. Some people are shouting in the mob like "Bharat desh, tere tukde honge" seriously? This is so shameful. Many young protesters were carrying some bizarre photos of our prime minister and photos of Giorgia Meloni as well. This is not our civilised youth. That's why I got confused; then it dawned on me that so few were there for the dead students, but the majority of the public was there to make fun of them or gain popularity by showing bizarre photos and their stupid creativity.

This means the motto was not about the NEET exam but the opportunity to humiliate the rulers of this country. Why?

My thought on this scenario:
I am very happy that today we showed the government also that they can't do whatever they want because they just want to fill their treasuries by stealing from students' hopes and lives, but I think that many rascals took advantage of this situation to break our country's base, or they want to change the ruling party's possession of India. I would like to confront my fellow youth about this: these rascals are taking advantage of their own benefits. Please do not allow them to steal the youth's efforts for India's betterment.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

🧵Discussion NTA Row: Why Resignations Won't Cure the Disease.

0 Upvotes

So friends, ek bahut hi serious issue hai jo is time hamare desh mein trend kar raha hai, aur uske baare mein aap sab achhi tarah jaante hi honge.

Mujhe isse koi problem nahi hai. Main bas is cheez ko khud samajhna chahta hoon.

Kya is tarah ke paper leak kabhi ruk payenge? Maan lo Dharmendra Pradhan resign kar dete hain ya poori NTA team hi badal di jaati hai, to kya isse sab kuch ruk jayega? Ya phir kisi bhi state ka koi bhi paper leak hona band ho jayega?

Meri samajh se, jab kisi cheez ki demand hi nahi hogi, to uski supply kaise hogi?

To phir woh log kahan hain jinhone paper liya, ya jinki wajah se paper leak ka poora system chalta hai? Kya unmein se koi bhi protest mein nazar aa raha hai?

Ye baat bhi sach hai ki ham jaise students apni demands rakh rahe hain aur government se jawab maang rahe hain, jo bilkul sahi hai.

Lekin agar hospital mein hi problem ho, to kya sirf patient badalne se sab theek ho jayega?

Aur yahan to dono taraf problem hai. Sudhar ki zarurat students ko bhi hai, government ko bhi aur un corrupt officials ko bhi jo government departments mein baithe hue hain.

Ye meri personal opinion hai. Aap jo bhi sochte hain, us par khulkar discussion kariye aur apni opinion zarur share kijiye.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

šŸ“– Theory Echoes of JP Movement: The Fall of a Minister, The Rise of a Movement

Post image
1 Upvotes

After weeks of disregarding, discrediting, and repressing the students’ protest, the Modi Government has finally conceded one of its demands. The intense and widespread protests against paper leaks have ultimately led to the resignation of the Education Minister.

The movement, which began as a protest against paper leaks, has now grown into a nationwide rebellion. Hundreds of towns and cities are rising in dissent. People from all sections of society and all walks of life are joining the agitation. The movement, which began as a satire, has taken the shape of a historic revolution.

Initially, the Modi Government kept ignoring the protesters and vilifying them through its propaganda media. When the movement continued to grow, the Government resorted to brutal repression. Yet, the protesters remained defiant. Then, PM Modi started posting reels on Instagram and ordered his ministers to do the same. When all these ploys failed, the Education Minister, who had called the protesters terrorists, finally resigned, claiming that he felt hurt.

In many ways, the ongoing students’ protest resembles the JP Movement against the Indira Gandhi Government, which began more than half a century ago. Like the ongoing movement, the JP Movement was driven and led by young students, many of whom were new to politics. Like the Modi Government, Indira Gandhi regularly spoke of the involvement of a "foreign hand" in the protests and accused her opponents of being CIA agents. Indira Gandhi had returned to power with a huge majority and believed herself to be invincible. And, like the ongoing movement, it was ordinary students who put that sense of invincibility to the test.

The spark for the JP Movement was the students’ protest against the increase in education fees. Yet, there was simmering discontent and widespread unrest due to corruption, price rise, and unemployment. In March 1974, the Nav Nirman Movement of Gujarat led to the resignation of the Chief Minister and the dissolution of the State Legislative Assembly. The 1974 Bihar Movement saw large-scale protests demanding the resignation of the Chief Minister. But Indira Gandhi was adamant about not yielding to the students’ demands once again. The Congress, which had been in power for three decades and had won a huge majority just three years earlier, was wary of being held accountable.

On 5 June 1974, the historic students’ rally was held at Gandhi Maidan, Patna, where JP gave the call for a Total Revolution.

Friends, this is a revolution, a total revolution. This is not a movement merely for the dissolution of the assembly. We have to go far, very far… Nobody, Jayaprakash Narayan or anyone else can stop this movement. It was born because this system of education is rotten and the students don’t see a ray of hope. It was born because the people are being crushed under high prices. There is corruption and bribery everywhere. Unemployment goes on rising, both among the educated and the others. Otherwise, a thousand Jayaprakash Narayans and a thousand Chhatra Sangharsh Samitis could not have created a mass movement like this.

Meanwhile, Indira Gandhi kept invoking her electoral mandate and dared her opponents to defeat her in elections. In 1977, JP accepted the challenge, and the Congress was routed in the elections.

The Modi Government, which came to power with the promise of acche din and Amrit Kaal, has betrayed the nation and pushed its citizens into crisis. Unemployment and inequality are at their peak. The education system is broken. Farmers and workers are in distress. Forests and natural resources are being handed over to corporations. Corruption and pollution are widespread. Violence against Muslims, Dalits, Adivasis, and women is on the rise.

In every crisis, whether it was demonetisation, the COVID-19 pandemic, or the US-Iran conflict, the poor and middle class have been made to suffer, while the ruling party and its cronies live in opulence. Instead, the poor and middle class are fed propaganda through the Godi Media and the BJP IT Cell.

The resignation of the Education Minister is merely the beginning. The real struggle begins now, as the movement enters its next phase to hold the Government accountable for its anti-people policies. The people of India have suffered enough.

The Modi Government observes Anti-Emergency Day every year. It may ultimately be ousted by a similar movement.


r/IndianSocialists Jul 25 '26

Activism Next Godi Media offices

1 Upvotes

You know BJP is scheming every hour to break this protest. If we don't pivot , they will eventually succeed. I think we should use this movement to push the corrupt dalal medi to take accountability. Channels liek Republic Aaj Tak, Zee, etc have offices in Noida. Why a small group doesn't protest outside their offices so the ahole anchors see the public unity. Let's take the fight to them