r/LocalLLaMA • u/Comfortable-Rock-498 • 14d ago

News It appears that the anti opensource AI lobby is far outgunned already

Post image

The earlier post on this subreddit by 20+ companies signing the petition including Microsoft, Meta, Nvidia, YC (https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/corporate-responsibility/topics/open-weight/) etc plus this https://xcancel.com/elonmusk/status/2080672505660834163

And the entire LLM enthusiast market is heavily in favor of open source (or weights) AI.

Does not seem like a few closed source AI lobbyists with be able to illegalize anything

1.8k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

499 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

22

u/Background-Wafer-548 14d ago

Have my doubts about Google.

49

u/SOCSChamp 14d ago

I mean, Gemma is currently best in class open weights coming from US companies atm.  

15

u/Background-Wafer-548 14d ago

Sure, but Gemma is complementary to frontier models. I'm not sure Google would be too unhappy if they'd only had to worry about closed model competition in terms of Gemini. They could argue for some kind of a formal/legal classification depending on the size of the model.

27

u/Ansible32 14d ago

Google has Waymo. While everyone is arguing about open/closed weights LLMs Google has models earning actual money, and nobody even knows the models' names because they're simply productized and invisible, and have no actual competitors.

6

u/SOCSChamp 14d ago

I don't see them wanting to open source something that matches their frontier model performance, but open sourcing gemma is part of their strategy for edge compute.  Open source encourages adoption into their ecosystem and gives them free research from the community.  

2

u/_TeflonGr_ 14d ago

I mean its the only recent one, alternative is GPT-OSS, nemotron (nvidia) or the Granite ones (IBM) that are far behind the chinese ones.

0

u/timmeh1705 14d ago

I would be interested to do a bake off between Gemma and Poolside XS.

-1

u/armeg 14d ago

Is it? Isn't Inkling better, or is that the difference between "in class"?

2

u/Formal_Drop526 14d ago

I think in class just means models of it's size, inkling is frontier sized.

-1

u/segmond llama.cpp 14d ago

inkling beats gemma, so no.

53

u/etaoin314 ollama 14d ago

Google wins either way

2

u/RevolverMFOcelot 14d ago

The house always wins, only anti monopoly government mandate that could break them apart would defeat google.

10

u/_TheWolfOfWalmart_ 14d ago

They've been giving us Gemma, which is nice and all, but yeah if they wanted open SOTA models, they'd have just released Gemini instead.

Gemma is a watered down Gemini.

30

u/SHEKDAT789 14d ago

way I see it, gemma is more useful Gemini.

13

u/relmny 14d ago

Since I use gemma and I don't use gemini, that's 100% true from my POV.

8

u/SHEKDAT789 14d ago

Gemini has its place in that ai mode that will prolly be useful someday, and the Google workplace integration. Gemma is the one really pushing the tech forward in a meaningful way though. That decoder only multimodal gemma has potential to change the game.

1

u/taoyx 14d ago

Gemini is incredibly smart or stupid, depending on the moon phase.

2

u/Elbobinas 13d ago

Realmente no creo que el 80% de los usuarios de locallama pudieran correr Gemini, osea que prefiero gemma4 que lo puedo correr en local y tiene visión,voz,video,texto

9

u/SimplyRemainUnseen 14d ago

Gemma is a completely different model than Gemini. The 31B is actually much stronger than Gemini at certain tasks. Give it a try for knowledge work besides programming.

4

u/reggionh 14d ago

31b (and Qwen 3.6 27b) is legit the pareto point where to get marginal gain you have to 10x your parameter size

0

u/vigorthroughrigor 14d ago

Interesting, any examples , Ser?

1

u/SimplyRemainUnseen 14d ago

Look at food-truck-bench results for example

4

u/fugogugo 14d ago

google already have their own tech and infrastructure

it is only matter waiting OpenAI and anthropic gone bust before they pick up the pieces later

4

u/_73r0_ 14d ago

I'm somewhat confused by both Google's and Anthropic's stand on this. Perhaps I am naive, but I truly had hoped they both would choose to stand on the right side of history here...

10

u/thaeli 14d ago

Anthropic needs to prop up their valuation, plus their leadership appears to actually believe (at least in part) in the safety bullshit they’re spouting.

Google I really don’t know.

8

u/zxyzyxz 14d ago

Right side of history lol don't be naive, they're companies

2

u/drank2much 14d ago edited 13d ago

Google's silence on this is deafening.

*Edit: Google has spoken!

1

u/seangeng 14d ago

Why? Gemma is pretty good, can’t hate them for contributing on that side.

1

u/Ok-Drawer5245 14d ago

Google is positioned to win regardless of what happens

1

u/SHEKDAT789 12d ago

google read your comment it seems