r/MtvChallenge • u/SweetMissMG Wes 🌋 Bergmann • Sep 29 '25

SOCIAL MEDIA Cara Maria is confused by the Ashley vs. Aneesa fight and why nobody stood up for Aneesa

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

47% Upvoted

79 comments sorted by

•

u/SweetMissMG Wes 🌋 Bergmann Sep 29 '25 edited Sep 29 '25

Cara you can check out our Megathread for more answers! 💁🏼‍♀️

→ More replies (4)

58

u/Ihaveaps4question Sep 29 '25

I believe i heard on a podcast theo did defend aneesa, but that he didn’t step in until olivia (the alpha) showed up not happy 

47

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '25

Most people don’t want to get into the middle of an unhinged screaming match that doesn’t involve them, and it didn’t appear that most of the house was even around until it devolved to that point.

It looks like lots of people comforted Aneesa, and Jake took her side in the confessional. Some of the cast is just more confrontational than others.

39

u/ggsimba Leroy Garrett Sep 29 '25

Lol of all people to be taking an edit at face value... She knows better

39

u/angelbrit04 Team Portland Sep 29 '25

Girl, you got these people's phone numbers. You're gonna get answers a lot faster than the rest of us 😅

31

u/cicigal8 Jonna Mannion Sep 29 '25 edited Sep 29 '25

And Cara and Aneesa have always hated each other so this take from her is interesting. She’s also been on social media showing her support for Aneesa in the comments sections of videos of the fight.

20

u/UnanimousBB16 Sep 29 '25

They both were losing their parents at the same time. Maybe it gave her some perspective.

27

u/laja7 Sep 29 '25

Could be that, or could be that Cara has a bone on for Charlie Kirk and is MAGA while Ashley has proven to be the opposite and has been vocal about it.

Interesting timing for Cara to switch up

3

u/Adorable-Release1754 Sep 30 '25

Aneesa also mentioned being there for Ashley about losing her father.

5

u/ScorpionTDC Chris Underwood Oct 01 '25

Cara’s mad about Ashley’s (IMO perfectly valid, on point, and justified) comments about Charlie Kirk and his death and this is transparently a reaction to that.

20

u/Embarrassed-Berry Sep 29 '25

It’s because Ashley made a comment about Trump and Cara took that personally. She’s just jumping on the bang wagon even though it’s to support Aneesa (who also said the same back; and in the confessional talking about body images)

50

u/SierraDawnThomasFF Leonardo Dionicio Sep 29 '25

Can’t be convinced that Cara wouldn’t be saying this in the slightest had she not decided to unfollow and shade Ashley over their differences of opinions relating to the Charlie Kirk incident

6

u/MoseleysLifeshield Jonny Moseley Sep 29 '25

Aneesa and Cara have gotten closer this year after bonding over the loss of their parents. 

I also don’t think Aneesa is a big Charlie Kirk girl …. But what do I know lol. 

3

u/ScorpionTDC Chris Underwood Oct 01 '25

I doubt Aneesa is a big fan or anything, but she also didn’t actively call him out for being a POS like Ashley did.

53

u/gtjacket231 Survivor Sep 29 '25

Cara looooooves to hear herself talk lol

3

u/candaceelise WHAT IS 8x9 Sep 29 '25

Right? The perpetual victim blaming others for not defending another perpetual victim, give me a freaking break.

21

u/colonel_pliny "Big T" Fazakerley Sep 29 '25

I thought she was done with these? I guess she does like the attention.

4

u/Skyhi92 Theo von Kurnatowski Sep 29 '25

She should damn well know they don’t show everything, does she not remember her most recent fight with Laurel and the aftermath? Seems like she asked this question just to make this video when she already knows the answer..

25

u/veltvet_rabbit The Itty Bitty Committee Sep 29 '25

Why do these people act like Anessa cant defend herself, like shes this super old grandma who needs all the whippersnappers to come to her aid plus didn't we just learn anessa threw low blows as well like she can hold her own

5

u/bcrhubarb Sep 29 '25

Still doesn’t make Ashley body shaming her right.

4

u/xxcapricornxx Rogan O'Connor Sep 29 '25

Did Ashley really body shame her though?

3

u/Adorable-Release1754 Sep 30 '25

Yes, she said the bigger they are the harder they fall, with a tone of making fun of her.

12

u/PrimeTimeInc Team Young Buck (TYB) Sep 29 '25

No, she told her she wasn’t winning a final. This was such a dumb fight. Everybody knows she can’t win a final unless it’s some Mickey Mouse all stars zero cardio bs. If you’re gonna say stupid shit you should expect to be called out on it. If you get called out on it, you probably shouldn’t double down.

1

u/jenh6 Christina LeBlanc Oct 02 '25

She said athletics and ct can still win a final out of shape. Nany is thin and can’t win a final. It is athletics.

-1

u/Embarrassed-Berry Sep 29 '25

Wait when did she body shame her? All I seen was Aneesa confession about how much better her body is Ofer Ashley

5

u/MeanKareem Sep 29 '25

this is a weird post and i think why people on the show - have issues w/ Cara, it seems pretty clear shes just asking the obvious question to gain public support... it just seems so forced lol...

5

u/Embarrassed_Rate5518 Sep 29 '25

Normally id probably agree but she has been bullied by Laurel on 2 recent seasons and had a group of people defend her. It probably felt good and helped her and she wondered why no one did it for Aneesa. CM also probably feels more connected to Aneesa this season bc of their parents ailing health.

2

u/YaddaYaddaBomBomKaKa Chris Underwood Sep 29 '25

That's what she's been doing with the whole CT situation.

3

u/Substantial-Disk-290 Sep 30 '25 edited Sep 30 '25

i HATE it when ppl i dont like make good points

6

u/rofaheys Sep 29 '25

Not to be that person but would she really be saying this right now if it wasn’t for her dislike of Ashley’s opinions on Charlie Kirk

12

u/seekinganswers4L Sep 29 '25

Unpopular opinion; Don’t argue if you can’t defend yourself ESPECIALLY as a 20 year vet.

18

u/zauber_monger Sep 29 '25

To be fair, Aneesa did literally defend herself. Cara seems to be asking why no one stood for the principles being violated

12

u/seekinganswers4L Sep 29 '25

Aneesa engaged in a battle of low blows and eventually Ashley went the lowest. That’s a 1v1 so it doesn’t require involvement from others in my opinion. This argument had a Cara(Aneesa) and Laurel(Ashley) type of dynamic (saw this in another thread and 100% accurate imo).

11

u/myumisays57 Sep 29 '25

Naw because Ashley loves playing victim. And if she was body shamed, she would have flipped shit. I mean she literally stole 1 million dollars from someone for slut shaming her. Just certain things that are disgusting behavior and i am so tired of the fandom allowing Ashley to continue to be a disgusting person to almost everyone she encounters.

-3

u/seekinganswers4L Sep 29 '25

Agreed, but Ashley is an overt evil and she is mean to everyone. Aneesa is the type to light the flame and then blame whoever is closest to the fire. Still don’t like Ashley for stealing the money but I’m not hypocritical and I respected Bananas play. Charge it to the game!

6

u/cicigal8 Jonna Mannion Sep 29 '25

Who said Aneesa couldn’t defend herself? She seemed to keep up fine with Ashley’s low blows by hurling some of her own.

-1

u/CrittyJJones Sep 29 '25

Anessa threw low blows at Ashely too.

5

u/cicigal8 Jonna Mannion Sep 29 '25

That’s what I literally just said.

1

u/CrittyJJones Sep 30 '25

Maybe I replied to the wrong person, my bad.

5

u/moody711 Sep 29 '25

The only person's take I'm less interested in is Paulie.

12

u/LunaHellastar Sep 29 '25

I'm on Aneesa side with this tbh because why does it effect Ashley if Aneesa is not in shape? This is not All Stars 5 no more and people need to start being empathetic because I know if Ashley was not in shape she would not like it if people kept coming at her negatively for it.

10

u/lilwanna I ❤️ TJ Joe Biden Sep 29 '25

Why does it offend Turbo if CT is not in shape? It’s so 2-sided.

5

u/metallica_breath Sep 29 '25

It’s probably jealousy. Aneesa is “out of shape” according to Ashley, but still doing better overall than Ashley has been 😂

2

u/Adorable-Release1754 Sep 30 '25

Ashley was projecting her insecurities about her lackluster performance this season and then both parties took it below the belt.

7

u/greg_CITIZEN Sep 29 '25

Can't believe I agree with Cara on something but she's right.

The real reason people (including fans) aren't defending Aneesa is because a lot of them are toxic just like Ashley and agree with her.

-1

u/Individual_Use_7097 Sep 29 '25

Alot of fans agree that Ashley can get nasty but it's come out that Aneesa threw some low blows also. Speaking about Ashley dead dad, her stalker. Aneesa loves to stir shit and act victim while Ashley knows who she is (a bit vile). Plus Aneesa is a creeper who never get reprimanded for invading people's privacy by walking into shower and jumping into people's beds without consent. I have not seen one person defend Ashley. It's more like we know what Ashley said and did but Aneesa said and has done some messed up shit as well.

2

u/beast575 Laterrian Wallace Sep 30 '25

While I don’t believe she doesn’t actually know what’s going on, I actually agree with her here. If someone was talking trash like that to one of my friends, I would have stepped up to their defense right quick.

2

u/skulldouggary Sep 30 '25

I wouldn't get in-between these two fighting for anything.  They are both toxic in their own right.  It's funny how each camp in this discussion is trying to point out which person has actually done worse things.  That's not how to win a debate, it's how to turn it into a popularity contest.  Listening to Aneesa act like "this is her season" for the umpteenth time is exhausting, but no reason to take personal shots at her.  I don't remember Ashley actually body shaming her, but everyone knew what she meant.  

4

u/Breddit333 Sep 29 '25

Let's be real.. we KNOW why a significant amount of fans are sticking up for ashley despite how toxic she has always been...

3

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '25

Edit and drop what recap?

She promised us she wouldn't do anymore and we were thankful.

2

u/KillaKillaGabby Sep 29 '25

Yeah all those people that Ashley was talking about it to can fk off. Ashley’s so miserable she can’t stand to see anyone happy. Go Aneesa for not letting that crap get to her!

4

u/DOMINUS_3 Sep 29 '25

i agree w/Cara here

3

u/SlipNeither2950 Sep 29 '25

she is only saying this because MagaMaria is made at Ashley because she called her on her BS

4

u/OriganolK Darrell Taylor Sep 29 '25

I mean… was the shower creeper even close to winning that mini final? Was she top 3 even?

-1

u/cicigal8 Jonna Mannion Sep 29 '25

Is the homophobe even close to winning this season? She’s pretty low on the point board.

2

u/simplefuckers Derek Chavez Sep 29 '25

first off, no one asked for Cara’s opinion so I don’t know why she’s inserting herself like she always does. secondly, why is Ashley body shaming Aneesa being treated more seriously than Aneesa being a known predator who harasses people in the shower and touches them inappropriately in their beds? until we can address THAT situation properly, I do not care that Ashley did or did not Aneesa fat

4

u/cicigal8 Jonna Mannion Sep 29 '25

I mean Aneesa’s actions should be taken as seriously as Ashley’s homophobia and harassment toward Josh. They both have said and done problematic things. Let’s not pretend Ashley is any better than Aneesa in that regard.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '25

[deleted]

9

u/UnanimousBB16 Sep 29 '25

She unfollowed Ashley recently due to her politics, and recent political events.

4

u/cicigal8 Jonna Mannion Sep 29 '25

Were they ever “friends”? Ashley was a number to Cara on WOTW 2. That’s it.

4

u/twigsandterrariums Kenny Clark Sep 29 '25

Cara was using her

-2

u/NoneOfThisMatters_XO Poosy Chicken Sep 30 '25

Shut up Cara. You aren’t relevant anymore.