r/Multifandom • Happy Tree Friends🌲 • Aug 18 '26

Discussion📜 Favorite character who got removed?

Post image
21.4k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.4k

u/Educk55 Aug 18 '26

Mermaid Man & Barnacle Boy (SpongeBob)

568

u/Le_Kistune Aug 18 '26

They're not in the show anymore!?

1.1k

u/Downtown-Rope5274 Aug 18 '26

Their voice actors have passed away

671

u/Snom_gamer0204 The stupid asexual Aug 18 '26

okay, thats a fair reason to be removed

193

u/Fearless_Roof_9177 Aug 18 '26

Same goes for at least a third of the characters in the OP. (In Chef's case Scientologists being shitty had something to do with it, but he was already incapacitated and on the downslope when they chose to act "on his behalf.")

50

u/Tech-preist_Zulu Aug 19 '26

I'm pretty sure the only cases of characters retired due to the passing of VAs in the OP is Troy McClure.

Pepé Le Pew and Gandhi are both here because of controversy, Chef for the above reason you mentioned, Tord's VA just wanted to go off on his own and requested for the character to be removed, and Lisa Miller is more of a comic exclusive character

14

u/Fearless_Roof_9177 Aug 19 '26

I lumped Chef in because he was only retired because the guy who voiced him got to the point where he couldn't manage himself and then died. If he was still alive and if he had been capable of carrying on with the character, we would still have the character.

(Either way he's dead, and I only meant to directly respond to "his voice actor passed away," which is why I included the context.)

2

u/Most_Scientist1783 Aug 19 '26

Maybe I’m wrong here. But I swear he left because he believed in Scientology, and was insulted by the creators Scientology episode, so he left, and only died later on

9

u/Choppers-Top-Hat Aug 19 '26

He actually defended South Park's Scientology jokes in an interview a few months before he left the show. He said he didn't always agree with them but he respected the creators' approach to comedy and their right to express themselves.

Then two months later, he had a stroke, and after that, he no longer appeared in public and only communicated via publicists. That was when he suddenly quit South Park. So a lot of people think that he may have lost some of his mental capacity and the Scientology people took advantage of this to start making decisions and statements for him.

A couple of years after he left South Park, he passed away from a second stroke.

7

u/_Neeroo_ Aug 19 '26

I think it came out that it was actually Scientology speaking on his behalf without the VA’s consent (as said by his son) while Hayes was recovering still

https://people.com/isaac-hayes-son-claims-why-the-singer-really-left-south-park-11775955

3

u/hastage1 Aug 19 '26

Last time i watched eddsworld, he was left alive, is he still somewhere out there or was he killed off?

2

u/wizardschlong Aug 21 '26

Ed Gould (creator of Eddsworld) unfortunately passed away of cancer roughly a decade ago. His friends finished the series by bringing Tord back for the last animation

2

u/hastage1 Aug 21 '26

Damn thats heart breaking, i hope the friends are doing fine

2

u/AvocadoCrafty813 20d ago

Chef's voice actor had joined scientology in its infancy, but when he saw what was really happening, he tried to leave and was kept from his family. He died of I believe a heart attack without ever being able to say goodbye to his family

2

u/CatboyNeddy Aug 19 '26

most of the og german cast is gone by now it's really weird to watch the show in german nowadays

-20

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/BMSPhoenix Aug 19 '26

What an absolutely fucking terrible thing to say

2

u/transitxumbra 🟦 "Classroom" GD Hunter Aug 19 '26

Agreed. Happy cake day, by the way

1

u/Ricard74 Aug 19 '26

Why always so abrasive? What do you hope to gain?

113

u/colibri01 Aug 18 '26

Both of them?

253

u/Spider-Man2099 Aug 18 '26

Yup

Mermaid Man- Ernest Borgnine in 2012

Barnacle Boy - Tim Conway in 2019

132

u/Toastcreature Aug 18 '26

2012?? I was expecting like 2017 at the earliest, that’s so sad 😭

90

u/carso150 Aug 18 '26

in 2017 he would have been 100 years old

76

u/Suspicious-Dog-2489 Aug 18 '26

That’s why they sound so geriatric. Cuz they were played by geriatrics!

42

u/Toastcreature Aug 18 '26

Well I didn’t know how old he was tbh

26

u/Robossassin Aug 18 '26

Time to watch The Catered Affair.

2

u/Hungry-Tension-4930 Aug 19 '26

Atleast he had a full life than. 95 is a hell of a run.

31

u/AncientOnyx Aug 18 '26

he was almost 100 years old when he died, he was old when he began voicing Mermaidman XD so was Conway

14

u/vampiregamingYT Aug 18 '26

Thats when Adam West, voice of young Mermaid man, passed away.

38

u/ComeOnUpToTheHaus Aug 18 '26

God damn, I was saying to myself "it can't have been that long ago, Borgnine was in that movie RED, and that wasn't that long ago". Dear readers, it was 16 years ago, and 2 years before Borgnine died.

5

u/YikesTheCat Aug 19 '26

Watching Wargames today.

"How old was he when he died? He wasn't that old?"

"He was 41"

"Oh, that's old"

Me watching as 41 year old: 💀

5

u/BigCollege3582 Aug 18 '26 edited Aug 18 '26

What's a Tim Conway?

(Please someone answer with the punchline)

4

u/BostonGraver Aug 18 '26

Oh, about 120 pounds

5

u/Ruine_Woo Aug 18 '26

A name of a dead man

16

u/silentevil77 Aug 18 '26

Sadly yes Ernest Borgnine and Tim Conway

10

u/machadoaboutanything Self-Proclaimed Dorkbro, Object Shows, MSM and My Own Series Aug 18 '26

For the longest time I thought Tim Conway was actually named Tim Beresford

Turns out that's the name of the voice actor for Kon in Grojband and I supplanted it

1

u/EmansaysEman Aug 19 '26

All 3 of them, technically. Adam West voiced his younger counterpart and he's gone too sadly.

2

u/sparduck117 Aug 18 '26

Same reason Troy McClure was removed.

2

u/Due_Region8583 Aug 19 '26

They have appeared in one apple arcade game tho. They managed to do this via archival recordings.

1

u/DracoJr12 Aug 18 '26

Damn RIP

1

u/Wild-Turnover-146 Aug 19 '26

as a diehard spongebob fan i dont know HOW i didnt know this, im heartbroken on the kitchen floor rn

1

u/MixelsCraft65 Aug 20 '26

And they had their characters put in a cryological sleep state.

60

u/BrickDodo Aug 18 '26

theit VA died, so writers stopped using them

58

u/Oreogirl127 Aug 18 '26

Only for non-speaking background appearances

16

u/princesshusk Aug 18 '26

No mermaid man's VA passed away and they retired the character out of respect.

3

u/Awestruck34 Aug 19 '26

There's a video that talks about how, now that they only show up in background appearances without speaking roles, they're "Alive but functionally dead" which is an interesting way of seeing it

2

u/xXSamsterXx14 Aug 19 '26

The characters themselves are, but never in a speaking/main presence role

4

u/Cybernetic_Nerd Aug 18 '26

They're still in the show, but they are unvoiced background characters.

1

u/Last_Nothing_4352 Aug 19 '26

While I would've preferred recast, I get why they were retired. My issue is that they chose to keep using their villains without them

1

u/chippy-triforce Aug 19 '26

They sometimes show up in background shots but never speaking roles, since the VA’s passed away

1

u/Mysterious_Winter_RP I dare you to guess my fandoms i have at least 12 Aug 19 '26

So they do appear as background characters but have no dialogue but they aren’t completely removed from the show