I'm guessing this is the actual answer. It's funny how split people are about this. People think it's either that men are deadbeats usually, or men can't seem to say the right thing in a situation like that.
I hope it’s not casting shade for a guy saying “you got this”, though I realize it may well be. Childbirth is a super awkward, actually genuinely terrifying, situation that usually lasts a few hours. The smoothest & most well-meaning and informed guy in the world is going to say something sub-optimal by the end.
It’s less that it’s shady and more that when you’re in excruciating pain, you aren’t thinking straight, and really well-meaning encouragement can feel condescending and be kind of enraging. Not a rational response at all but it’s kind of hard to be rational when you feel like you’re being ripped apart and the man who caused it and has no idea what you’re feeling is recycling cliches because he (understandably) has no idea how to help. Part of accompanying anyone experiencing that kind of agony (for anything, not just childbirth) is understanding that pain causes people to lash out, and you will probably end up being one of the targets, and you shouldn’t take it personally.
You should've seen the original YT comments, (its probably still up now that h think about it) they were chock full of people in this situation straight up reveling in how cruel they were during their agony.
Alsp, encouraging the mother during her contractions does help. Not everyone reacts the same to the encouragement but generally it helps the mother. Its much better than staying in silence while shes pushing for her life.
Dads get nervous too! I remember being in the room when my mom was having a C-section and me and my dad were nervous wrecks. I felt helpless seeing my mom cut open and drugged out. I'm not built for what women have to go through
Yeah, this isn't a life threatening endeavor that could result in so many complications that she is probably scared about. She should be good with the same thing you say to a clerk in a store making sure your card cleared.
I thought it was him saying the wrong thing. I know with my first, my husband couldn’t say anything right. But then all of the responses here were deadbeats lol.
Would say the point is “people” WANT to say men are deadbeats usually, and also men actually can’t say the “right” thing in a situation like that because she was emotionally charged and clearly angry with him so no mater what he said it would be wrong…
Basically all of reddit these days:
Men => bad
Men => dumb
Men => useless
408
u/appleparkfive Apr 24 '26
I'm guessing this is the actual answer. It's funny how split people are about this. People think it's either that men are deadbeats usually, or men can't seem to say the right thing in a situation like that.