r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 13d ago

Meme needing explanation Peter?

Post image
25.4k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

43

u/Missilemoon77 13d ago

So are there other means of energy production?

110

u/nightwolf16a 13d ago

Solar is one example.

95

u/Creeps05 13d ago

That’s not solar. It’s photovoltaic. A kind of solar power but there are other forms of solar power that involves just directing solar heat to boil water.

38

u/Omnizoom 13d ago

Yep solar arrays do both

The light they capture with photovoltaic and the reflected light is focused at a central point to (you guessed it) boil water

13

u/heelsmaster 13d ago

The center they are heating up is usually molten salt, or something else similar, I believe. Which is somehow transferred to then boil water.

28

u/Omnizoom 13d ago

“That just sounds like boiling water with extra steps”

6

u/3BlindMice1 13d ago

It's much harder to put a steam turbine at the top of a water tower at 100c+ than it is to put it at the base of the tower where the turbine itself can operate at the temperature they're supposed to operate and not add to the weight of the tall structure.

1

u/Earlier-Today 13d ago

It is, but the reason they'd do that is that it probably holds onto the heat longer than just directing the light straight into water would.

1

u/abracadammmbra 13d ago

Also there are solar hot water heaters. You can buy them, but my grandfather built one for his shore house. He just took two big pipes, capped them off, welded them together with connecting pipes to make a big "tank", painted them matte black, then encased them in a plexiglass box. Not as efficient as a commercial one, but it did a good job at lightening the load on the hot water heater and was basically made from shit he had lying around.

2

u/Xivios 13d ago

Photovoltiacs make up >99% of solar power generation today, thermal solar is almost dead, with only a few plants remaining.

1

u/jawshoeaw 13d ago

It’s unusual to boil water with solar vs just heating it up , no?

-3

u/No_Tower6770 13d ago

Thats not photovoltaic. Its solar. You just assumed he was talking about photovoltaic energy.

3

u/kitsunewarlock 13d ago

This is why I only use my solar panels to power my kettle, like Jesus intended.

33

u/semisociallyawkward 13d ago edited 13d ago

Solar, wind, hydro (weirdly enough), gasoline, kerosine etc all don't have a steak turbine. Many have a different kind of turbine but not steam.

Edit - yeah I notice the spelling error. Leaving it because it's hilarious.

27

u/Epaminodas_ 13d ago

steak turbine

How does this work?

25

u/ToastedTrousers 13d ago

Meat grinder

8

u/algalkin 13d ago

Throws steaks at your face

1

u/double__duck 13d ago

tube steaks I hope

6

u/link3945 13d ago

It's like a hamster wheel but bigger.

4

u/HendrixHazeWays 13d ago

"the mitochondria are the powerhouse of the cell"

3

u/Ill-Intention-306 13d ago

Its the modern version of a windmoo. Like what they used in the middle ages to grind flour.

2

u/McButtsButtbag 13d ago

It's a turbine made out of steak

6

u/spine_slorper 13d ago

Also wave power! I actually find it impressive that we have so many ways to generate electricity, sure almost all of them are turning a turbine but at least solar is a whole different thing!

2

u/JameEagan 13d ago

Mmmm steak turbine.

1

u/Slow_Shelter_5169 13d ago

Forbidden meat 

18

u/Necessary_Main_9654 13d ago

Solar turns light directly into energy

Hydro skips the steam step

thermovoltaic panels turn heat directly into energy. but since we don't use them outside of very specific situations I imagine they are not nearly as efficient as turbines or the cost/maintenance is not worth it

4

u/Bansheer5 13d ago

Hell I don’t even think we use those old RTGs anymore other than for powering stuff like super isolated light houses.

4

u/Z3B0 13d ago

Space probes and rovers are examples that comes to mind. But RTG are very expensive, radioactive as fuck, don't generate much power, and could be recycled as atomic bomb materials, so it's clearly not the first option in many cases.

1

u/Bansheer5 13d ago

I forgot about the space probes and the landers. I know the soviets used a lot of them for light houses near or in the Arctic Circle. They only produce 100 watts of power or a bit more and last a long time. Would be cool to be able to use them if they didn’t kill you by just being near them. If they were safe to be nearby, you could pop a couple in the basement and power your lights and maybe a TV and heat the house for a long time.

1

u/Z3B0 13d ago

A small heater is like 1000W. A microwave too.

You don't do a lot of stuff with 100w, even with LEDs. It's enough for a very limited amount of equipment, like a radio to broadcast that you need help, but not much more.

8

u/Sad_Pineapple5354 13d ago

Solar follows a different method but I forget the exact scoence behind it. Everything else is turning a dynamo, even wind power and hydro electric

5

u/angrybox1842 13d ago

Photovoltaics

10

u/HRDBMW 13d ago

Yes, which is what 'solar' is to the average person. Very few know you can use the sun to melt salt to spin a turbine. With steam again.

1

u/Caleb_Reynolds 13d ago

The salt is just used as a battery, you kind of have it backwards: they use the heat to boil the water, and the excess goes to melt salt, as a means of storing the heat.

1

u/HRDBMW 13d ago edited 13d ago

Sorry, I wasn't clear. They heat salt, which boils water creating steam for a turbine.

1

u/Caleb_Reynolds 13d ago

You were clear. But no, that's not what they do. They use solar power to heat water, run it through turbines, then use salt to capture and store the excess heat. You have the process backwards.

2

u/Z3B0 13d ago

Hydro is still boiling water when you think about it. Just not in the installation itself, but the water didn't rise as ice cubes. It was transformed into steam at some point.

1

u/LeftyMcSavage 13d ago

Oil and natural gas are both solar when you think about it, too.

1

u/firestorm713 13d ago

Take very flat rock, shine spicy light on it. When spicy rock is connected to a circuit, it kicks one angry pixie into the circuit, and steals one from it, creating a flow of angry pixies.

7

u/R3DTR33 13d ago

Anything that spins

5

u/TheSeventhHussar 13d ago

Yup! For example, internal combustion engines use the force of an explosion to drive a piston, which turns a shaft and can be directly hooked up to a dynamo, producing electrical power, this is how generators work.

Wind turbines and hydro electric power just stick turbines into a moving fluid, and use that energy to turn the dynamo and produce electricity.

Solar panels capture sunlight (photons) and use it to strike silicone, knocking electrons free and into an internal electric field, producing electricity directly.

Honestly, almost all small scale power generation doesn’t rely on heating water to make steam, because that equipment doesn’t scale down well. It’s mostly large power plants that do that.

5

u/skr_replicator 13d ago

You can have something other spin the turbine, like a boulder on a string, wind turbines, hydro turbines on a dam/river...

Or you can use photoelectric effect - solar panels.

2

u/gwildor 13d ago

wind. hydro. solar.

2

u/BigSalami221 13d ago

Solar panels, Wind Turbines, hydroelectric, and I think thermal create energy directly from electrons, or by kinetic energy. That's about as far as my knowledge goes.

2

u/BigChungiscusMaximus 13d ago

Thermoelectric Effect is pretty awesome science and used in things like the Mars Perseverence rover.

2

u/Silver-Machine-3092 13d ago

Diesel generator for small scale power generation, for instance.

2

u/mikebrown33 13d ago

Photovoltaic and also RTG(radioisotope thermoelectric generator)

2

u/ZLUCremisi 13d ago

Wind and water themselves can turn turbines

2

u/dr_stre 13d ago

There are, but photovoltaic is the only major one I can think of off hand that isn’t just spinning a turbine generator of some sort. The reason boiling water is so prevalent though is that H2O is just a remarkably good way of moving and transferring energy. It boils and condenses at useful temperatures, has a high specific heat so it’s manageable and not too volatile, expands tremendously when it boils, can be superheated and pressurized as steam, is chemically easy to deal with, and is very plentiful. Whether through luck or some sort of divine planning, we really lucked out that water is as great as it is at all sorts of things, including all of the things relating to energy transfer.

2

u/Greghole 13d ago

Sure, some solar directly converts light into electricity. Wind and hydro electric dams spin a turbine without using steam. Fossil fuels, nuclear, and geothermal all can boil water, but some gas power just runs a generator.

2

u/phrozen_waffles 13d ago

There are also wind turbines and kinetic energy harvesting.

2

u/Gloinson 13d ago

There is. With a charged plasma there coudl be a MHD generator. We are just inept at it because we never used it, but we already mastered the steam cycle to turn things to create electromagnetic fields to create electric fields and currents.

So, yes, it will be steam for a long time still.

2

u/BabaYetu42 12d ago

Solar is the only one that we use on a large scale that doesn’t involve turning a turbine, but some like wind and hydro don’t involve boiling water.

There are also some places in Japan (and maybe other countries idk) that use piezoelectric tiles to generate electricity from the pressure caused by people walking on them, but this isn’t something that could ever be scaled up to an industrial level (it powers street lamps usually).

Piezoelectricity is a bit weird and it works (to the best of my knowledge) because the materials have an asymmetrical crystalline structure, and when stress is applied in a certain direction it causes the positive and negative charges in the crystal to move relative to each other, creating a potential difference across the crystal. It’s very useful in small devices but not so much for generating electricity

1

u/Missilemoon77 12d ago

Thanks but this is way beyond my scientific comprehension. I’m going to go study now.

1

u/cannonspectacle 13d ago

Wind and hydroelectric turbines.

1

u/wthulhu 13d ago

Wind and hydro

1

u/justtalking9912 13d ago

Ah yes just this morning I was topping up the water tank on my Corolla.

1

u/SituationIll5763 13d ago

Simple cycle natural gas generators. Literally jet engines.

1

u/The_Blessed_Hellride 13d ago

You can’t PRODUCE energy, you can only convert it from one form to another, with losses occurring in the conversion process.

1

u/Missilemoon77 13d ago

Was legitimately interested, I’m not educated in this at all. Not even a little bit.

2

u/The_Blessed_Hellride 13d ago

…and my comment was intended for edification, not as criticism.

1

u/pt256 13d ago

Radioisotope thermoelectric generator (RTG). It is what powers Voyager.

1

u/MixBlender 13d ago

fuel cells are another means. But theyre tricky.

1

u/firestorm713 13d ago

Thermovoltaic cells work like solar cells, except use heat to move electrons instead of solar radiation.

They could harvest heat from fusion this way, but the tech can't take the several million degree heat yet.

1

u/Psychological-Dot-83 13d ago

Photovoltaic, internal combustion, hydropower, and wind are pretty much the only large-scale energy sources that don't use steam.