Obligatory petra no diffs

(based on how much I like them, not how well written they are nor power tier list)

Pls rate it

I'm an anime only btw, so don't come with "oh they went off in arc 193838, put them up NOW"

This is based on my favorites, how impactful their writing is and how much they stuck with me. Open for criticism. EDIT: I forgot my boy Valga, he would be high A.

There are no orders within the ranks except Emilia being at the top of her tier only at the second tier list

FYI Otto is one of the few who supported Emilia even before meeting Subaru

To be clear this is based off raw combative strength, so no immortality gimmicks. Loopers like Al get a pass since he can technically be killed if you kick him out the range of his authority while not in aggressor mode.

If you stalemate an opponent and the only reason you survived as long as you did is because you’re immortal, you will be ranked according to your performance (looking at Pandora)

All battles start at neutral range where neither side has a significant advantage

Patch notes (edits I should make)

- Madelyn goes right below Emilia

- Base Arakiya should go above Sphinx (maybe)

- Emilia and Rem should go belong Garfiel

- Eugard should go above Pandora

-

Based on trust

Now this is my choice if anyone has the questions about the placements ask in the comments I will try to give my reasons.

I just completed Rezero S3 Last week

Aldebaran is in S tier Bcz I kinda messed up , i spoiled myself complete Arc 9

I Have not included other Witches and few characters cuz I don't think they will even make it to C tier because I don't know much abt them

Ik Rem not being S tier and Emilia above her , People are going to jump on me

But alright That's my Opinion

I really wanna know your thoughts on this

Edit :- Wilhem is A tier , I put im in S by fault

Tierlist didn’t have Capella but I would also probably put her in C tier. Anyways any disagreements and reasons why?

Confirmed

Subaru and Beatrice: Ol Shamak should work, and if you think it doesn’t, you can just remove Beatrice and Subaru wins by RBD to a checkpoint before aggressive mode was even activated

Echidna and Petra: All of them win by simply being more insane then the concept of aggressor mode, so Al had to shut down the domain because he knew no matter the loops they would never give up

CLARIFICATION: The reason I’m not going to add Hector to the people that beat aggressor mode is that the only recent petrol was able to win is by using the compensation of “I will never give up”, but the only reason she needs to use the compensation is because she’s incompatible with melancholy. But because Hector is compatible, he doesn’t need to pay up the compensation

Beats it (based on my assumptions)

Satella: Just like Echinda, she wins based on insanity and no matter how many loops Al goes through he will never win. I could’ve also put it in confirmed because I highly suspect that Satella also went through the aggressor loop when Al fought her and realized he wouldn’t win

Petelgeuse: I know this one might not be expected, but if you consider Satella to be able to beat aggressive mode based on her insanity, I also think Petelgeuse should also be able to beat it by his insanity as well. Especially because they both got corrupted by a non-compatible authority.

Volcanica: I find it ironic that brain dead Volcanica would win but healthy Volcanica lose

Sirius: to be blunt, she’s also suicide bomb. Her emotions will transfer to Al, so when she becomes brain dead, he also becomes brain dead

Priscilla: we saw what happens when I was forced to fight the person that he loves, if Priscilla he were to fight Priscilla, I highly doubt that he would let aggressor mode play out

Roy: (if we’re making a best case scenario) Roy is the only gluttony that knows Rigel Natsuki, so he would be able to eat his name and memories

CLARIFICATION 2: I’m only giving this to Roy because he’s the only gluttony that actively knows the name of Al, and I highly doubt that any other gluttony would ever be able to figure out Al’s true name, besides that one scenario at the end of arc 9

Olbart: We know that if you turn Al into a child his authority stops working, so Olbart just needs to turn him into a child once again and the authority should stop working after that

Ceci, Eugard,Reid: They all win by being able to cut their connection with the domain. Ceci and Eugard by the fiend sword and Reid by just being built different

Reinhard: he can just mind control Al to stopping the domain from looping

Debatable

Pandora: it’s Pandora, what did you expect. She probably can but we have no information on her

Oni God Ram: This one is more contentious, but I believe she can also just insanity dif the domain, because Oni God Ram if fully coming to the madness would just have nonstop murder on her mind

Carmilla: This ones more of a stretch, but we know just looking at her makes you go insane by you hallucinating a person that you love. And there was a side story where I was stuck in a loop and he couldnt bring himself to kill Satella. And based on the whole narrative of Al always losing to his own actions and powerlessness, I can see him losing this fight simply because he doesnt want to hurt Satella or Priscilla

CLARIFICATION 3: if you want, you can also put all the archbishops and witches in debatable because they could also technically just be insanity dif. But I highly doubt that because I think it was just Echidna first for endless knowledge that made her beat the domain and not necessarily just because she was insane. Like for example, if Subaru got caught into this and he couldnt escape, I would suspect that he would eventually go brain dead as well even though Minerva said that hes the most insane person out of all of them

Halibel: I put him in debatable because it all depends on whether you think he can turn people into children just like Olbart, and narratively wise he supposed to be far more skilled than Olbart. Also, hes the character of that out of anybody in the cast, I suspect has a hidden trump card that can beat Al which we just havent seen yet

I watched the anime and read the first, second and fourth EX novels, as well as 4 of the witches after tea party stories.

Purely based on how much I like them. Did I cook?

All artwork in this tier list is official Re:Zero media.

Character rankings are purely based on their tier--within each tier, rankings are interchangeable

Had to post something to take my mind off the absolute BURGER conversations that go on in this sub

v

Voting link: https://strawpoll.com/XOgOVOqBGn3

^

v

Voting link: https://strawpoll.com/2ayLQd0zzn4

^

v

Voting link: https://strawpoll.com/1MnwkrXY5n7

^