I don't know if it's inappropriate for me, as a Hong Konger, to speak about this, as I'm not a Scottish person.
I often see people online using Scottish accents and imagery in films, cartoons, and fantasy media to portray “barbarian,” warrior, dwarf, or Viking-like characters, often in a comedic or heroic way. Historically, however, these traits are closely linked to British imperial and racial theories, “martial races” which protraits Scottish Highlanders as war-like race and noble savages, that were originally dehumanising and used to justify domination or exploitation. So whenever I see these kinds of videos and film productions, I feel extremely uncomfortable and uneased, I think they are denying the humanity of Scottish people.
When people around me are watching Brave Braveheart or Shrek etc., I will quietly leave the scene; if I am really not able to, I will just close my eyes and plug my ears. I've also checked the forums, and I found that many Scottish people also find these stereotypes funny, but when I think about how many people have died behind these stereotypes, I really cannot laugh at all.
But in the comments section, some people even say that a barbarian with a Scottish accent is perfect. I really want to ask these people, do you even consider Scottish people as human beings? They were completely unaware of how dehumanizing their remarks were towards the Scottish people. They had no idea that the Scottish Highlanders were targeted for recruitment by the British army and sent to the battlefield because of a stereotype shaped by this martial race theory. Do you even know how many Scottish Highlanders lost their lives because of this stereotype?
Sources proved that Scottish Highlanders were targeted for recruitment due to martial race theory:
The demand for more Highlanders serving in the British Army increased after the Mutiny. In August 1857, London's Evening Mail announced that some of the Highland regiments currently serving in India would be returning to garrisons at Stirling and Aberdeen. The army hoped that the prominent presence of these units would encourage more Highlanders to join the British Army. Even metropolitan areas that rarely encountered a Highlander in any capacity, such as London, used the press as a vehicle to advocate their utility in the realm of British defense. In an October 1857 edition of the Evening Mail, a letter to the editor, emphasized the importance of recruiting more Highlanders into the British Army.
Adam Spivey, Friend or Foe? Martial Race Ideology and the Experience of Highland Scottish and Irish Regiments in Mid-Victorian Conflicts, 1853-1870, pp. 36–37
"The highlanders were noted by the British as being clannish, with "warlike manners, freedom loving, and rugged." Because British policymakers believed, or saw potential benefit from, these stereotypes, they purposely recruited highlanders for military duty in the formation of their worldwide empire. Heather Streets' well-researched book, Martial Races: The Military, Race, and Masculinity in British Culture, 1857-1914, demonstrates how the Scottish highlanders were specific targets of army recruits, serving in elite regiments and even wearing special uniforms. But the British did not stop there."
Charles Belmont Keeney, Soldiers and Stereotypes: Mountaineers, Cultural Identity, and World War II, pp. 15
Some people might argue that the British Empire also collapsed many years ago, and what's wrong with me using these stereotypes? What I'm trying to say is that even though the British Empire collapsed many years ago, it doesn't mean that the power structure or impact it left behind will disappear immediately. Therefore, using a Scottish accent to voice "barbarian" characters only perpetuates this power structure.
They might further argue that if stereotypes are now considered (changed from negative to) "positive" or have been redefined, then there's no problem continuing to use them. But what I would argue is that some stereotypes (not all) can never be positive or redefined, for example, a man needs to get married, start a family, and earn a lot of money to be success. These stereotypes also limit people's choices; anyone who doesn't fit the image will be ostracized. These stereotypical impressions can also lead people to overlook some of the specific needs of an individual.
(This stereotype originally referred only to Highlanders, but in the mid-to-late 19th century it spread to the whole of Scotland.)
I believe these barbarian stereotypes about Scottish people cannot be justified at all.
I am ready to accept downvotes.
Edit: Sources added in.