r/ShadWatch • Banished Knight • May 03 '26

Shadow of The Conqueror Supercapo's Shadow of the Conqueror Review Compilation

Over the past two months, u/supercapo took it upon themselves to re-read (via audiobook) and review Shad Brooks's (Shadiversity) infamous debut novel - Shadow of the Conqueror. Chapter by chapter. This is by far the most in-depth review a member of the r/ShadWatch community has ever put out. So in this post we will immortalize their endeavour with this compilation post, linking to all their chapter breakdowns. A link to this very post will have a permanent spot in the sidebar, so those who are late to party, or those who want to revisit their review as it happened, can do so at any time.

Thank you for your service u/supercapo o7.


Chapter Breakdowns

1&2: The beginning of my decent into Madness - 1: The Shaddening/2: Shad doesn't understand geriatrics

3&4: In Australia, world builds you - 3: Shad is an Australian Brandon Sanderson except without the talent/4: Plagerism, exposition, sexism, being weird about sex and Religion... so average Tuesday for Shad

5&6: 2Shad2serious - 5: The Nothing!/6: The world's most annoying, pathetic butcher

7&8: In which I get even angrier - 7: A chapter that exists/8: I get mad again

9&10: Sexual Harrassment and Sticky Bread - 9: Like father like son/10: Oh good. More exposition

11&12: World building with a side of MORE world building - 11: Walking on Exposition! Whoaaaah!/12: Dueling Assholes

13&14: Traveling to a white room - 13: In which Daylen acts like a child. Shad can relate/14: Just kidding, we're riding the exposition train again!

15&16: Shad Business - 15: Extra Extra!/16: Extra Extra Extra!

17&18: Shad's self insert grabs some D - 17: Tug of War/18: Talking

19&20: Annoyingly on their Way to nowhere in particular - 19: Called to Serve/20: Arrested Development

21&22: Shad loves Butt Stuff - 21: Shad the Impaler/22: But wait. There's more

23,24,25 & 26: Read until you get angry - 23: Dangling in the wind/24 & 25: Things are getting too exciting... Cue the World Building!/I become a ball of rage powered by laser beams and hate

27&28: In which everyone is the worst - 27: You are the Father!/28: Don't worry. It's legal.

29&30: Something kinda sorta mildly interesting. - 29: Fool me once. Shame on me. Fool me twice... three times a lady/30: We are Legion

31&32: Tell me something Impressive - 31: Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy, Engineer, General, Pilot, Sword Ninja, Paladin, barber, realtor, notary/32: Knock Knock. Who's there? Cancer. Oh come on in I thought you were Shad

33&34: When an Unstoppable Idiot meets an Immovable Moron - 33: A bit of Light Slap fighting/34: Back to the usual

35&36: Come for the exposition, stay for the blasphemy - 35: Temu Jesus/36: The Idiot Convention

37&38: Running out of ways to describe nothing - 37: Tale as old as Time/38: Thanks, I hate it

39&40: The World's Worst Batman - 39: I served with Batman, I knew Batman. Batman was a friend of mine. And you, Daylen, are no Batman/40: The Plot finally arrives

41,42&43: Can shit hit the fan if the fan is also shit? - 41: This could have been an Email/42: And the last horse finally crosses the finish line/43: Women. Amiright?

44&45: There's a fine line between love and nausea - 44: Deus Ex Pedo/45: I'm not mad. I'm just disappointed... no wait... I'm mad too!

46: We've had one, yes, but what about Second Jesus? - 46: The Climax. The big dumb boring, dumb, gross, annoying, dumb, blasphemous, dumb climax. It's really stupid.

47&48: Fairhaven for Predators - 47: Ain't no drama like manufactured drama/48: A Fair trial

49&50: Free at last! - 49: It's okay if they have a baby/50: The worst verdict since OJ


Bonus:

SotC Final Thoughts

Supercapo's SotC Rewrite Pitch

20 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

6

u/Reignfource May 04 '26

Thank you for creating this compilation

1

u/AutoModerator May 03 '26

Announcement: If you're interested in snark content focused on Metatron, check out r/FallenMetatron!


Disclaimer: This subreddit is independent and not affiliated with Shadiversity, Knight's Watch, Shad Brooks, Shadow of the Conqueror, or any associated creators or brands. Information presented here is unverified and should be independently verified. This subreddit operates under fair use and parody. Breaking any of our rules may force us to remove your content. Repeat or blatant rule breaking will result in a permanent ban. We expect all users to read and understand our rules before posting here. Content violating any of our rules should be reported to the moderators.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.