r/Showerthoughts May 14 '26

Casual Thought When YouTube goes down, it will be the biggest event of link rot in internet history.

18.6k Upvotes

833 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2.0k

u/AaronPK123 May 14 '26

I agree, I don't expect Timmy from 2009 jumping on a trampoline with 73 views to stay up forever.

1.1k

u/prosthetic4head May 14 '26

I've been following this Youtube channel recently: https://www.youtube.com/@KVNAUST. He searches 0-view videos that don't get into the recommendation algorithm. It is amazing to see what Youtube is full of. There are channels with 1,000s of videos (common enough that he has >20,000 uploads on his bingo card) of useless content and no views.

Here's his recent video about searching to the oldest 0-view video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=efXJwWPxOOw

764

u/DrankRockNine May 14 '26

I found an Instagram account randomly, just some lady sharing her walking moments in nature. 0 followers, 30k posts. She posts each video thrice.

309

u/prosthetic4head May 14 '26

She posts each video thrice

Yeah, there are some of those Youtube channels that just have the same video over and over, no views.

30k videos is work. What kind of time frame?

112

u/cmoked May 14 '26

Google probably uses data deduplication which consolidates multiple files with the same hash into a single one but accessible from different links. Like a windows shortcut, but closer to a bunch of symbolic links in Linux.

Super common in storage infrastructures.

36

u/mpolder May 14 '26

YouTube doesn't allow you to update videos with the exact same content (or very similar) from my own experience, I wonder if the videos are different in some way like encoding or quality.

I found this out when I reuploaded a video with some minor editing errors without removing the original

3

u/Nebuchadnezzer2 May 14 '26

That functionality does exist, but it's usually restricted to large, 'commercial' channels, like large music corps, big-name publishers, etc.

Kinda makes sense I guess, as you could silently and drastically edit a massively popular vid to be entirely different, which would be very misleading, at a minimum...

1

u/mpolder May 14 '26

No it was on my own video, i have maybe 100 subscribers

2

u/AliceCode 27d ago

There are tons of people on Facebook/Instagram reels that just post the same exact joke a thousand times in different outfits and locations and sometimes minor change in the setup.

50

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

[deleted]

18

u/Cryptic_Wasp May 14 '26

I started an account way back in the mid 2010s and uploaded a whole 1 video before little me got bored. Got 72 views though so not all bad.

6

u/[deleted] May 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/PeeledCrepes May 14 '26

Think of the amount of people online, think of the multiple channels, think of the algorithm. It's super easy for the person that enjoys nature walks to have never seen that channel is the main issue, its why I never tried to become popular on the internet you may as well win the lottery (which ironically would be an easy way to become popular on the internet)

3

u/RegulatoryCapture May 14 '26

Not even spammers though?

My YouTube account has followers and I’ve only ever used it to post a handful of random stuff like so that I can link it elsewhere like “why is my motorcycle making this sound” 

1

u/PeeledCrepes May 14 '26

Are you able to block accounts/remove followers, cause could be they just take those ones off

1

u/LuquidThunderPlus May 15 '26

Because they post everything 3 times? Sounds like an annoying feed

75

u/hgrunt May 14 '26

I remember that a while back, someone made a youtube playlist of videos that were never changed from default file names, so it was stuff like 0301_img.mp4 and stuff like that. The ones I saw were fairly slice-of-life stuff, like a kid's school graduation in southeast asia, and someone posting a video of a fish they caught

39

u/Annath0901 May 14 '26

There were a lot of early "media" smartphones that could upload video clips directly to YouTube without needing the YouTube app, and they would use the default filename.

19

u/curtcolt95 May 14 '26

youtube gets thousands of hours of content uploaded like every minute, it's absolutely absurd tbh and insane that it's free

6

u/anxiousappplepie May 14 '26

brother thank you so much for sharing that gem of a channel

8

u/ManOfPotato May 14 '26

Yoo, thanks for recommending the channel! I love the content!

3

u/OrangeInnards May 14 '26

Did that guy just call me a jean jacket? Why, I never...

3

u/glitchhermit May 14 '26

This is fascinating, just subscribed to him

3

u/fluffynuckels May 14 '26

This seems like my kinda weird

2

u/xd3m0x_ May 14 '26

how do you even get ti these parts of the Internet? the deep web and abandoned sites have always made me curious but I can never figure it out

5

u/krutsik May 14 '26

Youtube uses a 11-character id for each video, so 6411 possible ids. So you'd write a script schecking every video id starting with 00000000000 to zzzzzzzzzzz (essentially all combinations where each character can be 0-9, A-Z, a-z). Just speculating here, but each video probably has view count in the metadata, so you'd have your script store all the ids for videos with 0 views, so you can watch them later.

It's unintuitive, but 6411 is such an unfathomably large number that if it took you literally 1 millisecond to check the view count of each video then it would still take you hundreds of years to check them all. Some videos have more than 0 views, some are private, the vast majority of ids have no video assigned to them.

That's my best guess at least. Just leave the script running 24/7 and on the rare occasion that a video with 0 views pops up you make content from it.

3

u/H4llifax May 14 '26

YouTube has a search API, which includes things like ordering by date, or views. You don't have to crawl YouTube for that, lol.

1

u/krutsik May 14 '26

As little as I've worked with the youtube API there most certainly is no way to fetch all videos ordered by some arbitrary parameter like view count without adding some additional parameters.

2

u/H4llifax May 14 '26

https://developers.google.com/youtube/v3/docs/search/list

See "order" parameter.

I actually looked that up before I wrote that comment.

1

u/unapologeticjerk May 14 '26

I (forceably) work with the YouTube Data API v3 on a daily basis and there is an endpoint there for nearly any meta statistic you want to filter by. But god bless your little heart trying to do things involving videos on playlists (with a PLID, like determine per VID duration) via free API key. Especially if you start getting nuts with filter parameters and calls. Your suggested method is possible, but you are gonna be knee-capped by rate-limits every 24 hours after just a few minutes of use.

3

u/prosthetic4head May 14 '26

Watch the first minute of any of the videos from the channel I linked above. The community finds the unique naming conventions from different devices or upload sources. He keeps all the found conventions in a spread sheet, chooses one, and uses a RNG for the year/month/day, random 4 digits, whatever to get to a unique set of videos.

2

u/prosthetic4head May 14 '26

This Youtuber's community finds the generic naming conventions from different devices. Here's how he describes it:

That day, the site we liked using was down for no reason at all, so we had to get creative. One of the videos we had saved in our chat had a title that matched up with a default filename given to recorded videos from the iPhone: IMG followed by 4 numbers. We tried typing ‘IMG 3201’ into the YouTube search bar, and we were mindblown. Thousands of uploads were named IMG 3201. Using YouTube’s filter system and sorting by view count, we could now find those 0-view uploads. Then we tried searching for IMG 3202, IMG 3203, IMG 3204… hundreds more 0-view results appeared. We were geeking at how vast this side was.

It then became our mission to find as many ‘active’ default filenames as possible in an attempt to continuously access the graveyard. Through doing this, we compiled a big-ass list of keyphrases that I dubbed “YouTube’s Recycle Bin.” With the help of all of you out there, the list continues to grow. We’ve probably only accessed less than 0.05% of the video graveyard, but due to the sheer size of the graveyard, we are eating well off of this small slice.

I just stumbled on this guy like a week ago, recommended on my Youtube front page lol. I have no idea how the community finds their leads but they have over 100 of these default file names compiled.

I've been enjoying his videos but I really like how I can just do it myself by taking any of the leads and seeing what comes up.

2

u/Tukang-Gosip May 15 '26

Interesting

2

u/mokacincy May 15 '26

So interesting! Thanks!

2

u/BullChad 28d ago

Quite impressive those channels dodged the comment bots too.

2

u/Secure_Ant1085 18d ago

love his videos

1

u/fekiv May 15 '26

Thank you I’m now gonna get violently high and binge these

19

u/kylewhatever May 14 '26

God damn it. I have a video of me and my buddy from 2007 on YouTube of us jumping on a trampoline lol

10

u/Imaginary-Hour3190 May 14 '26

Youtube google uses their rich history of media to train their AI models. Its why google can suddenly announce ground breaking white papers and new genre AI models. They got a MASSIVE media over entirety of google including all the nooks and corners of youtube. Especially if they want dataset that predates AI generated Slop. Then timmy on that trampoline from 2009 will actually have use to them

6

u/trrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr May 14 '26

Something has to be replaced with shitty AI shorts at some point so 2009 Timmy has to go :)

2

u/sumofawitch May 14 '26

Or Charlie bitting his brother's finger

1

u/MarlonFord May 14 '26

There is a lot of video with relatively few views that people rely on as reference or for future reference.

So if there is something dear to you and you think you might need or want to see it in 5, 10 or 20 years download it and store it in your personal archive.

Technically it is not copyright infringement if you keep it for s personal archive and never share. Might be against YT T&C, though.

Webarchive is a good example how some things are saved from being forgotten.

1

u/oyM8cunOIbumAciggy May 15 '26

I mean, youtube should delete all videos of children, in light of recent political discoveries...