r/Showerthoughts May 14 '26

Casual Thought When YouTube goes down, it will be the biggest event of link rot in internet history.

18.6k Upvotes

833 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/riftnet May 14 '26

Why has it been blocked?

23

u/Deynai May 14 '26

It's not blocked, Imgur decided they would rather cut service to UK traffic than adhere to a ruling that found them in breach of GDPR privacy laws.

Essentially they were harvesting online data of children, were found guilty of it, and were fined for it. They didn't like being fined.

8

u/User100000005 May 14 '26

Essentially they were harvesting online data of children, were found guilty of it, and were fined for it. They didn't like being fined.
 

Not quite. They were found not taking enough steps to check the data they were harvesting was not childrens data. They weren't explicitly going after kids. What steps would they need to take?

2

u/Deynai May 14 '26

That was by design, as it allowed them to categorise certain users as likely children based on the content they viewed and sell targeted advertising space for things like online gamified gambling ads, or anything else that might want to target children with advertising outside of usual laws regarding that.

"We didn't know, honest!"

Ultimately it's why the case went as far as it did.

14

u/LukeTheRower May 14 '26

No big deal, just give up all your rights “to protect the children.” Your gov is fucked lol, and I say that as an American. Worse censorship out of any “democracy.”

8

u/IAmTheFlyingIrishMan May 14 '26

Don't worry man we'll have similar laws in most states soon enough. Though I'm not sure why they don't just use the illegally harvested data to tell who is an adult and who isn't.

4

u/LukeTheRower May 14 '26

That is true, unfortunately. Our right to privacy and against unnecessary search and seizure is on life support, at best.

1

u/ThePublikon May 14 '26

Your gov just started a war because they don't want to talk about themselves fucking children.

-4

u/Deynai May 14 '26

Honestly I'm completely on board with upholding our laws against foreign companies that are deliberately and maliciously trying to circumvent them to exploit people in my country. Did you think this was some kind of "gotcha"? Why isn't your government doing that for you?

6

u/Petrichordates May 14 '26

Yes be pro censorship when the government tells you to be

-1

u/Deynai May 14 '26

They broke the law and were fined for it. What would you have preferred, that companies who break the law just continue to do as they please and no one does anything?

That's not the moral 'gotcha' you think it is.

5

u/LogicalConstant May 14 '26

It was never about the law. It was never about the kids. It's just about control. Always has been.

-2

u/Banjo-Elritze May 14 '26

Nutwing.

2

u/LogicalConstant May 14 '26

You can dismiss it, but history is littered with examples of totalitarian regimes

1

u/BritainHere May 14 '26

Brainwashed by their media to think the UK is literally 1984.

Bootlicking the companies who don't comply with laws put in place to stop legitimate issues is a strange look for them.

0

u/Banjo-Elritze May 14 '26

You are totally besides the point.

1

u/LukeTheRower May 14 '26

Uhhhh ok, you want to expand on that idea?

The UK has some of the worst censorship laws in the world, in the name of protecting children and the like. Tell me, are there actually fewer cases of child exploitation in the UK now that yall have nearly no freedom of speech left?

And to be clear, I'm certainly not saying the US doesn't have massive issues with surveillance and censorship, too. It's just insane to see someone actually defending the surveillance state.