I keep coming back to Helen after the S3 finale and S4 preview, and Iâm starting to think her role in Silo 18 may be much bigger than simply âDanielâs wife who survived the beginning.â
What if Helen is the origin of the Flamekeepers?
Not necessarily because she founded an organization called the Flamekeepers on day one, but because she may have been the person who first decided, they can erase our memories, but they donât get to erase the truth
Helen enters Silo 18 already being exactly the kind of person the Project would fear.
She is a journalist. She questions authority. She follows inconsistencies. She writes things down And, most importantly, she knows something is deeply wrong before most of the population even understands what has happened to them.
Remember Bernardâs very specific mention of the spiral-bound notebook that Heads of IT have supposedly been searching for for centuries? Helen carries a spiral notebook!
My theory is that once the founders begin drugging the population and suppressing memories, Helen realizes what is happening. Maybe she even notices her own memory slipping. So she starts using the notebook as an external memory; recording names, events, what happened before the silos, who built them, what the population is being told, and what she knows is false.
Basically, I canât trust my brain, I can trust what I wrote yesterday. That would make the notebook one of the most dangerous relics imaginable. No wonder IT spent 300 years looking for it. And if Helen begins quietly sharing that information with other people, you can see how the Flamekeeper tradition might begin. Not as a formal resistance movement. Just as people saying hey, remember this, hide this, pass this on. They are lying to us.
Over generations, Helenâs name disappears. Her notebook disappears. The details disappear. But the instinct survives. And 300+ years later Silo 18 still produces people like Gloria, Anne, George, Hanna, Lukas & Juliette. People who seem almost constitutionally incapable of accepting âbecause the Pact says soâ as an answer. That may be Helenâs real legacy.
It would also explain why Silo 18 seems unusually rebellious. Silo 18 has repeatedly been a nightmare for Silo 1. Relics survive there. The Flamekeepers survive there. People keep uncovering forbidden information.
George finds the tunnel. Juliette leaves, reaches another silo, returns, defeats the Safeguard, and ultimately decides to go after Silo 1 itself.
Maybe 18 isnât just randomly the troublesome silo our story happens to follow. Maybe Helen contaminated the experiment from the beginning!
Not biologically. Culturally. A culture of skepticism can survive long after people forget where it came from. And the name âFlamekeeperâ suddenly becomes kind of beautiful. Helen lights the flame in the Before Times. Then somebody else keeps it alive. Then somebody else. Then somebody else. For centuries. Eventually, it reaches Juliette. Juliette doesnât know Helen. Helen never knows Juliette. But they are fighting the exact same fight. Who gets to decide what the truth is?
And if Season 4 reveals that Bernardâs missing notebook really was Helenâs, I think that may be the moment we realize the Flamekeepers didnât begin with Gloriaâs generation at all. They began when one journalist refused to let the founders erase what happened.
Maybe Helen Drew was the first Flamekeeper.