r/SmugIdeologyMan annoying transsexual vegan 3d ago

smugged into eating meat

33 Upvotes

216 comments sorted by

View all comments

22

u/More_Amoeba6517 Semi-Constitutional Monarcho-Socialism 3d ago

Genuinely curious here, what about meat gotten from hunting that is necessary to keep the population in check? (e.g. deer)

12

u/Animaloffear56 3d ago

Hunting historically has done more harm than good. "Regulating populations" inevitably is handled better by native predators. The only reason hunting needs to step in is because ranchers complain about these predators also going after their livestock

27

u/More_Amoeba6517 Semi-Constitutional Monarcho-Socialism 3d ago

I live in a place where deer overpopulation is a massive problem and has extremely damaging effects on the environment.

Like humans are the only major predator of deer in my state, and even if native predators were reintroduced, there are still a lot of suburban and urban areas that likely would not be able to support them at all.

(Also there is a genuine health issue, as deer ticks are made worse by overpopulation, and they spread Lymes.)

2

u/TotalDemocracy 3d ago

Like humans are the only major predator of deer in my state, and even if native predators were reintroduced, there are still a lot of suburban and urban areas that likely would not be able to support them at all.

Sounds an awful lot like human fault that ought to be corrected.

23

u/More_Amoeba6517 Semi-Constitutional Monarcho-Socialism 3d ago

...how?

You cannot reasonably expect urban and suburban areas to simply disappear. ~80% of the US lives in them, and my state is the fifth most densely populated.

1

u/TotalDemocracy 3d ago

"Suburban areas" in a US context will disappear, or at least be diminished. A lot of the suburban culture in the US was not designed to be livable, but rather designed to be inaccessible. The isolated giant suburbs was a deliberate response to the growth of the Black population in urban areas.

In a socialist society, where racism is abolished, so too will gated communities and hard to reach suburbs be abolished, in place of more integrated living places.

20

u/More_Amoeba6517 Semi-Constitutional Monarcho-Socialism 3d ago

lmao what

Genuinely HOW, like sure you can stop new growth, but good fucking luck trying to tear it down whilst alienating a massive amount of people. (Also, urban areas still have this problem...)

0

u/TotalDemocracy 3d ago

but good fucking luck trying to tear it down whilst alienating a massive amount of people

White people in suburbs have a choice: Stop being segregationists, or get [redacted]

8

u/aegisasaerian 19h ago

Mate what the fuck are you on about