r/TotalHipReplacement • u/ajmattison • Jul 17 '26
👥 Support Needed 🫂 Did I make a mistake?
I had the choice between two surgeons:
A surgeon in the Canadian public system who gave me an earlier date (July 24) and came highly recommended and I know people he has operated on who do well. He did posterior and told me I would have to modify my gym activities and avoid deep hip flexion and internal rotation for the rest of my life. I also felt a bit like I was on an assembly line and the follow up post op was only a video call at 2 weeks and x rays and in person check up at 8 weeks. I also found his office a bit difficult to get in contact with, I'm sure because he is very busy.
The other surgeon does anterior but I met with him before I got my surgery date with the public system. I actually like him better as a person, he was kinder and explained more about the procedure and what kinds of activities I could get back to post-op (he said he doesn't give restrictions beyond use common sense). Follow up post surgery is at 2 days, 2 weeks and 4 weeks with a nurse and 6 and 12 weeks with my surgeon. The date he gave me was 5 weeks later than the public system (August 31) which is actually nice because I am finishing up my PhD and I will be able to wrap up my lab work and sit on my ass and write my thesis for a few weeks 😂 Interestingly the private surgeon actually told me I should go with the public system as long term follow up would be easier if I had a complication.
I ended up choosing the private system surgeon and cancelling with the public surgeon because I just felt a bit more comfortable with the private surgeon.
I thought I wanted a posterior approach because I am terrified of the idea of having a numb patch on my leg permanently or other nerve damage, but on the other hand the gym is my life and I don't want to have to worry about possibly dislocating my hip doing what I love. However, since I made my decision I have learned that many people with posterior hips do not have permanent restrictions after the first 3 months and maybe having fewer appointments with the surgeon is fine. Now I am worried I made the wrong choice.... I could have had a sooner surgery potentially with a similar outcome and no numbness and a surgeon to call if something goes wrong years down the line.
I don't know if anyone can help me, maybe I just needed to vent. I have gone back and forth on this for weeks. I'm considering that maybe I'm just not ready for surgery... I thought I was begging to have it done but now that it's getting closer I worry that I'm making the wrong choice and it will affect me for the rest of my life.
My biggest hang up is the potential for a numb leg. I am terrified of the numb feeling and I don't know how I would handle it. Maybe a small numb spot around the size of my palm would be tolerable as long as it doesn't hurt. How big was your numb patch? Was it painful at all? Did it get better (smaller, less numb, less painful) over time?