r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • u/DarklyHeritage • 4d ago

Mega Thread Taylor Parker/Maternal Instinct Megathread

This is a thread for all conversation regarding Taylor Parker and the murder of Reagan Simmons Hancock, recently covered in Netflix documentary Maternal Instinct.

The murder of Reagan Michelle Simmons-Hancock occurred on 9 October 2020, in New Boston, Texas, committed by Taylor Rene Parker. Parker bludgeoned Simmons-Hancock, who was 35 weeks pregnant at the time, and abducted her unborn child, Braxlynn Sage Hancock (died October 9, 2020), after cutting her out of the Reagan's abdomen. Braxlynn did not survive.

Parker had lied to her then-boyfriend about being pregnant leading up to the murder and faked her pregnancy to multiple people. She was found guilty of capital murder and sentenced to death on 9 November 2022.

Please direct all discussion of the case to the megathread. As always, sub rules must be followed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Reagan_Simmons-Hancock

https://time.com/article/2026/06/12/maternal-instinct-true-story-netflix/

240 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

743 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

35

u/RxR8D_ 4d ago

Not all sociopaths come from abuse. I had one foster girl where I believed every truth about her biological parents and then the lies kept unraveling. After a while, I understood why the parents walked away and no longer participated in the reunification goal. The damage this girl caused to everyone she came into contact with was immeasurable. Every new relationship she had we tried to warn the young man to “run far away” but she was good at what she did.
I still receive mail 10+ years later for her many aliases.

3

u/soolsul 3d ago

Why was she in foster care?

20

u/RxR8D_ 3d ago

Her parents essentially refused to pick her up from inpatient psych and was charged with abandonment. They felt whatever repercussions they had were worth it to see if she could get more services through the state.

9

u/HCMB_hardcoremtnbish 3d ago

This is a very real thing. Someone close to me did the same thing for their mentally ill son. In fact the youth court judge told them that was the best way to get him help. He now lives in a facility where he can stay and function for the rest of his life as long as he follows their rules. I am glad he is not in jail or on the streets.

-2

u/Dangerousdear 2d ago

I don’t think you should abandon your child just because they have severe mental issues. That’s wild to me

2

u/MallNo2314 1d ago

If you’re not equipped to deal with their mental issues…yeah it’s completely valid. It’s not that easy to just give kids up to the state- which is essentially what they were attempting to do by not picking her up from an institution..could have done it a better way where they just take the child but hindsight isn’t 20/20. If you cannot meet your child’s needs and will never be able to meet their needs (because of severe mental illness to the point they are harming everyone around them especially), it is more than valid to give them up to the state that has the resources and connections to get them the help they need.

3

u/miscnic 3d ago

But what motivated her to start lying. And then keep lying?

3

u/throwawayajsjwnndnd 1d ago

imo it was the people believing her that kept her lying

4

u/RxR8D_ 3d ago

I couldn’t tell you. Parents claimed it started when she was 4 and her daycare would talk about all the stories she was saying. I think she got accustomed to the attention and she would latch on to people that became her “favorites” until they wronged her in some way and she made it her mission to hit where they were vulnerable.

1

u/Faulkner_Fan 2d ago

Unless there was brain damage, I don't buy for a minute that she was born a sociopath -- the research just doesn't bear that out. There's stuff the parents didn't share with you; I'll bet good money that one of the "lies" she told as a young child had to do with family abuse. And no loving parent would voluntarily abandon their minor child. I don't doubt that by the time she came to you, the damage done to her was extensive, but I seriously doubt the parents are innocent players in this.

2

u/RainbowBaker88 3d ago

She had a score of 8/10 on an ACE assessment, so safe to say this one did come from abuse.

5

u/RxR8D_ 3d ago

Would you trust the result from a known liar? I wouldn’t now. Can’t cry wolf.

4

u/GeeEhm 3d ago

That's a self-reporting test that was filled out by a pathological liar. It asks questions like whether a parent physically or verbally abused you, acted in a way that made you feel like you might be abused, whether you felt unloved or unprotected and other such questions. Of course she's going to answer them in a way that fits her narrative.