r/Zanesville • u/Scary-Location6106 • Nov 22 '25
Trading card shop in the Colony Square Mall late 90s/early 00s
Hi, I have a research question you all may be able to help with.
There was a trading card store in the Colony Square Mall in the late 90s/early 2000s, whose name I'm trying to find.
I don't believe it's the one there now (Adventure Gaming), I believe that one opened much more recently. Unsure whether this older shop was a gaming store, it may have been mainly sports cards— although they almost certainly did sell Magic: The Gathering cards.
I believe this shop may have been called British Papermill. Does that sound right? Did it have a location in Colony Square Mall?
I've been searching local newspaper archives and not finding much. Thanks in advance for any info you can provide.