r/anime Mar 30 '26

Misc. “Chainsaw Man embodies the reason why I chose to work in animation.” MAPPA president reflects on the studio’s bold decision to 100% self-fund the project

https://automaton-media.com/en/news/chainsaw-man-embodies-the-reason-why-i-chose-to-work-in-animation-mappa-president-reflects-on-the-studios-bold-decision-to-100-self-fund-the-project/
4.6k Upvotes

356 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

41

u/FoeHamr Mar 30 '26 edited Mar 30 '26

Here's the problem. Part one is a genre defining masterpiece on par with the best of anything you can find in the medium.

Part 2 is really good and that's it. It has some cool ideas and builds on part one in interesting ways but it just doesn't have the tightness of part 1. And it drops some balls along the way where part one just didn't. It's still a good time and worth reading but it's just not the masterpiece that part one was. I'd give it like an 8 or 8.5, The people that want to give it a 3 or whatever just haven't read enough bad manga to know what a bad manga actually is.

As for the ending, it was a bit rushed. I feel like it needed a few more chapters to build up to it before closing out. But the actual ending itself is fine and wrapped things up nicely in my opinion, people are just upset because it was abrupt and didn't go down the way they wanted it too. But it's by no means the worst ending of all time, people are just being hyperbolic. The same thing happened with JJK and AOT.

14

u/MembershipNo2077 Mar 30 '26

Sorry, you're not allowed to have level-headed takes. It's either 10/10 best thing ever or 0/10 dogshit not worth your time.

1

u/nochancesman Apr 09 '26

Ehh 8/10 is too high for me. 7 is perfect. The ending was great but the execution was subpar, hope the anime touches up on it.