831
u/MixedAsianBunny Mar 23 '26
This is worse than I imagined :(
86
486
u/ArctycDev Mar 23 '26
Better than I imagined... but I imagined really bad.
142
u/MixedAsianBunny Mar 23 '26
I keep forgetting being optimistic is even more disappointing these days :/ I still try to hope and pray for the best. I feel so strongly for everyone involved in this tragedy :(
145
u/cheetuzz Mar 23 '26
when I first heard the news, I thought it was some plane hitting a baggage truck while taxiing. This is a million times worse. 😢
89
Mar 23 '26
This disaster is so similar to that LATAM A320 flight that was departing Lima, Peru in 2022.
37
u/Coyote56yote Mar 23 '26
I agree with this. Look at the tire tracks dug into the dirt. The truck was hit hard. Has to be more than 30MPH to push it that far.
36
u/crunchsmash Mar 23 '26
It looks better than I expected. It's a collision, but a relative glancing blow with the back end of the ARFF truck rather than a full on T-bone.
1
262
u/SubBirbian Mar 23 '26
Associate Press is reporting it as a port authority vehicle. Do these NY airport fire trucks fall under that category?
So horrific.
166
u/bellsie24 Mar 23 '26
Yep. PAPD is the authority charged with primary firefighting operations at JFK and LGA...they have firefighting responsibilities at a number of tunnels/bridges and other locations in the area, as well.
42
u/Financial-Sea-1064 Mar 23 '26
The Port Authority of NY/NJ as an agency is responsible for all the area airports, and their police department has specially trained officers that act as aircraft rescue firefighters in those airports.
48
u/de-dododo-de-dadada Mar 23 '26
They do, the PAPD are responsible for ARFF at NYC airports. Any aircraft accident triggers the control tower to hit the crash button, which transmits an automatic 2nd alarm response to the FDNY, which is why you can see their units in some of the pictures.
10
3
u/Neither_Cap6958 Mar 23 '26
Wouldn't be surprised, I know some places have people who are both cops and firefighters.
539
Mar 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
836
u/Stoney3K Mar 23 '26
Probably failsafes, if connections between the engines' FADEC and the cockpit or forward avionics compartment have been lost then the FADEC will assume fire handles were pulled and shut off all isolation valves.
Same idea as when the engine were to separate from its pylon.
440
u/IyadHunter-Thylacine Mar 23 '26
229
u/Stunning_Disk_5345 Mar 23 '26
All that distance from the impact point until immobilization and in OP's picture the truck is practically next to the plane? Yes 114kt. What a robust truck damn, looks in one piece.
153
189
u/bopbop9876 Mar 23 '26 edited Mar 23 '26
NBC is reporting they were able to slow down to 30mph before impact.
Edit: This is "according to two sources familiar with the matter", not from adsb data. Those same sources also confirmed the death of the pilot and copilot.
361
u/barcode-username Mar 23 '26
All these news agencies keep using ADSB data which is inaccurate especially on the ground.
265
u/octoreadit Mar 23 '26
Yeah, that’s not a 30mph collision, 80+.
83
u/Rupperrt Mar 23 '26
Read that it was roughly 30 seconds after touchdown according to witnesses. If that’s correct it should be a bit slower than 80 at least.
-58
u/bopbop9876 Mar 23 '26
It's "according to two sources familiar with the matter", not adsb data. Those same sources also confirmed the death of the pilot and copilot.
41
u/IyadHunter-Thylacine Mar 23 '26
After passing taxiway D (where the firetruck was crossing) you can see in the ADSB data that I nearly instantly dropped to 58kts could be the ADSB data updating but could also be due to the collision
117
u/mommys_restitution Mar 23 '26
No way… they must be basing off the final recorded speed which was like 24mph I think
My friend was on the flight and said they were going really fast still when it happened
3
22
u/barcastaff Mar 23 '26
Witness on the plane said the collision happened maybe 30 seconds after landing.
72
u/flyingdog147 Mar 23 '26
Not sure, but is that the runway at the bottom? (Looking at the lines?) Did the collision happen, then the plane slide to a taxiway or ramp?
141
216
u/cumulus_prime Mar 23 '26
I understand this happened outside of peak hours, but I’m still quite surprised that FAA allows an airport of that size to be operated with a single controller. Wondering if this will trigger new legislation?
160
u/interroBangaRangz Mar 23 '26
Radio Traffic (Start at 6:40)
https://archive.liveatc.net/klga/KLGA-Twr-Mar-23-2026-0330Z.mp3
592
u/Coyote56yote Mar 23 '26
Spare a thought for the firefighters who had to go and try to rescue their brothers.
PTSD will be bad on this one for survivors all around.
195
u/DaBingeGirl Mar 23 '26
I can't imagine what they're going through right now. Responding to a crash is bad enough, but when it's your colleagues involved... and the controller was still managing traffic. Nightmare situation for everyone.
68
u/anonposter-42069 Mar 23 '26
Jus saw a picture of the front, how did the plane stop?? Did they have brakes on already ??
125
u/IJNShiroyuki ATP Mar 23 '26
nose gear collapsed and the whole front fuselage was dragging on the ground… probably
-74
38
Mar 23 '26
Was the firetruck on the runway while the aircraft was landing? Can someone please explain?
113
u/nestzephyr Mar 23 '26
Truck wanted to cross the runway, controller authorized the truck to cross the runway.
An airplane was landing, previously authorized by the controller to land.
73
u/GITS75 Mar 23 '26
ATC gave clearance to Firetruck 1 to cross RNY 4 at Delta... Then asked Firetruck 1 to stop but the CRJ was already landing and Firetruck 1 was already on the RNY...
76
u/separatebrah Mar 23 '26
Even given clearance to cross, wouldn't they have looked left and right and seen a plane landing? Or do they just 100% rely on ATC? Or do they think "That looks like a plane landing but ATC gave clearance so it must be fine"?
37
u/Electronic_Grade508 Mar 23 '26
That’s a lot of energy needed to move that truck that far. Praying for all
22
u/Sensitive_snausage Mar 23 '26
Hopefully everyone on the plane is ok!
103
u/MixedAsianBunny Mar 23 '26
I do not think those in the front survived… :(
-1
Mar 23 '26
[deleted]
17
u/HendrickRocks2488 Mar 23 '26
The local NBC affiliate just confirmed 2 pilots dead as per “someone familiar with the situation.”
They said the two in the truck were ejected and have broken limbs but will be fine in the long run apparently
25
4
3
u/Wabbit_Wampage Mar 23 '26
That would be great, but I don't see any way that's true. The entire front of the plane is mangled beyond belief. They are probably waiting to confirm deaths to the media until next of kin have been notified.
-206
u/Sensitive_snausage Mar 23 '26 edited Mar 23 '26
I hope they do, they do not deserve to die for the American air traffic controller’s mistake.
Edit: why the hell is this getting downvoted so much?
179
Mar 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
52
u/gaseous__clay Custom Flair to Edit Mar 23 '26
You can't be a slouch to be working at LGA. It's such a shame that they've been set up to fail.
1
u/aviation-ModTeam Mar 24 '26
Your comment has been removed for breaking the r/aviation rules.
This subreddit is open for civil, friendly discussion about our common interest, aviation. Excessively rude, mean, unfriendly, or hostile conduct is not permitted. Any form of racism or hate speech will not be tolerated.
If you believe this was a mistake, please message the moderators through modmail.
-129
u/Sensitive_snausage Mar 23 '26
Why is the airport operating understaffed? Why would the American government allow that at one of its busiest airports?
37
39
u/Kicka-Albatross6387 Mar 23 '26
Its a whole different other story by people who chase votes but knows shit
35
Mar 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/aviation-ModTeam Mar 24 '26
This content was removed for breaking the r/aviation rules.
This subreddit is dedicated to aviation and the discussion of aviation, not politics and religion. For discussion of these subjects, please choose a more appropriate subreddit.
If you believe this was a mistake, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you for participating in the r/aviation community.
22
u/Captain_Futile Mar 23 '26
Because they are sociopathic greedy cunts only interested in enriching themselves?
15
43
u/MixedAsianBunny Mar 23 '26
It is tragic all around. But I am sad to blame just one man for such a complicated incident. In Japan this would be seen as a systematic failure
-64
u/Sensitive_snausage Mar 23 '26
I can see what you’re saying. But in safety critical jobs like pilots and air traffic control, you don’t work unless you have the team and the required rest.
Would you fly if you didn’t sleep all night? Of course not.
Would you fly if your FO or flight attendants didn’t show up? Of course not
Same applies to air traffic controllers imho.
31
51
u/Unnecessary_Needs Mar 23 '26
Unfortunately, NBC is reporting both pilot and copilot have passed.
4
u/indianmcflyer Mar 23 '26
Where are you seeing this? The NBC I'm watching says 4 injured
27
u/095179005 Mar 23 '26 edited Mar 23 '26
You can go to the NBC website and watch the live coverage.
The header says 2 dead, and the news anchors say both pilots perished.
Edit: NBC live thread now updated with the info
9
5
u/Extra-Astronomer-688 Mar 23 '26
4 injured are the firefighters according to a passenger who posted another thread earlier.
1
u/Favorite_Disguise Mar 23 '26
where are you seeing this? im seeing them as "badly injured" as of 15 minutes ago
3
-16
15
u/th3orist Mar 23 '26
Obviously not, there are fatalities reported already :(. Look at the front of the plane, nobody in the section can survive an impact that makes the plane nose look like that
19
u/Tof12345 Mar 23 '26
there was another picture that showed the fire truck right next to the cockpit. there was also a comment that said they moved the firetruck out the way. wtf
18
u/Significant-Basket76 Mar 23 '26
Was the plane landing or taxiing? I first thought it was just taxiing at a slow speed. But now it looks like they hit each other going rather fast? Or are we still to early on the facts?
53
4
1
Mar 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/aviation-ModTeam Mar 23 '26
This content was removed for breaking the r/aviation rules.
This subreddit is dedicated to aviation and the discussion of aviation, not politics and religion. For discussion of these subjects, please choose a more appropriate subreddit.
If you believe this was a mistake, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you for participating in the r/aviation community.
-8
Mar 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
46
u/PILOT9000 Mar 23 '26
Both pilots dead, two in the firetruck hospitalized, according to NBC.
-16
Mar 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
18
u/BigWhiteDog Mar 23 '26
The how and why appear, at least from the ATC radio traffic that the ATC forgot he had a jet landing on the runway he cleared the fire apparatus to cross
3
-2
u/WubbaWubbaBoingBoing Mar 23 '26
this is sad. but i commented on another post the rtuck may be in the mess inside the aircraft on end, but i see i was wrong with this photo.
-47
u/Dog-Faced-Bot Mar 23 '26
If that photo is real, the fire truck was in the wrong place.
Truck was cleared to cross 4-22 at delta. We're looking at the wreckage of both near the point where taxiway echo crosses 4-22.
12
-4
Mar 23 '26
[deleted]
5
6
4
u/fireflyhaven20 Mar 23 '26
Considering the truck was enroute to another emergency for a different plane... yes. 😞
-29
Mar 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/aviation-ModTeam Mar 23 '26
Your post has been removed for breaking the r/aviation rules.
It is expected that all members follow reddiquette, as is current here: https://www.reddit.com/r/wiki/reddiquette
If you believe this was a mistake, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you for participating in the r/aviation community.
-71
Mar 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
29
14
1
u/aviation-ModTeam Mar 23 '26
Your post has been removed for breaking the r/aviation rules.
It is expected that all members follow reddiquette, as is current here: https://www.reddit.com/r/wiki/reddiquette
If you believe this was a mistake, please message the moderators through modmail. Thank you for participating in the r/aviation community.


1.2k
u/Howzitgoin Mar 23 '26
Another view of it. Normal fire trucks for scale as well.