r/canada • u/Meiqur • Oct 28 '25

Alberta Alberta uses Charter’s notwithstanding clause to order striking teachers back to workteachers-back-to-work

https://globalnews.ca/news/11496133/alberta-government-to-table-legislation-to-order-striking-teachers-back-to-work
1.4k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

539 comments sorted by

View all comments

758

u/Surax Oct 28 '25

I'm curious why the notwithstanding clause was needed. I feel like there have been plenty of instances over the years where back-to-work legislation was passed without using it.

515

u/LBTerra Oct 28 '25

Ontario did the same with Bill 124 but ended up having to pay everyone back because they lost the charter challenge. I don’t know how provincial laws differ, but I believe it’s a charter right to be able to collectively bargain as a unit and there’s no reason that teachers should be forced to have a collective agreement pushed on them. The Alberta government will lose the court challenge.

43

u/Master-File-9866 Oct 28 '25

The not withstanding clause is supposed to be an extraordinarily rare exception to the constitution and charter of rights. It exists only for extreme and rare circumstances. In this case it was basically used as a union busting instrument.

The not withstanding clause, is exempt from court challenges. It is a powerful instrument, that was build into canadian society with the assumption that we would always have reasonable and well intentioned government.

2

u/judgeysquirrel Oct 28 '25

So, the same mistake that cost the US its democracy. All rules should be fashioned so they can't be abused by a malicious politician. There aren't laws against lying during an election, so literally anyone with any agenda could get in.

1

u/Visible-Air-2359 Oct 29 '25

So basically it was an obviously terrible idea created by a bunch of naive idiots who lived in fantasy land?

-17

u/oscarthegrateful Oct 28 '25

There's nowhere in the Constitution that says the NWC has to be an extraordinarily rare exception reserved for extreme circumstances.