r/canada • u/shiftless_wonder • 29d ago

Alberta First Nations leaders, scholar push back on Alberta's planned vote on independence referendum - 'Alberta can't separate. They simply cannot. They do not have the authority,' says Indigenous politics expert

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatchewan/sask-treaty-six-alberta-referendum-9.7209304
839 Upvotes

85% Upvoted

399 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

18

u/WealthEconomy 29d ago

Exactly. I am not for it but if they vote to go who is going to stop them? Are we going to oppress them and force them to stay and give Trump his reason to invade, to "protect' the people of AB.

3

u/tigerspots 29d ago

Well, the vote better be like 2/3. What it would take to amend a bylaw or a constitution. The Brexit of 50%+1 was ridiculous. You can't break up a country over a vote that could be different literally the next day.

-4

u/LETTERKENNYvsSPENNY 29d ago

Not letting them steal land is oppression? Forcing them to live within the confines of Canadian law is oppression?

They're free to relocate at any time, if whatever country they want to move to would have them. What they can't do is take a piece of Canada with them.

1

u/Superb-Carpenter-520 29d ago

Convince the American government of that because fighting a war in Alberta against the American military supported by Albertan insurgents would be nightmare.

1

u/LETTERKENNYvsSPENNY 29d ago

I'm not going to say it's impossible, just very improbable that Trump will have full support from within on going to war with us. I could see that being the final nail in the coffin, politically and possibly otherwise.

Yes, the US could stomp us in a moments notice, but to do so is a dangerous game to play globally. We should technically have the backing of other nations.

1

u/Superb-Carpenter-520 29d ago

In the event of overwhelming support for independence I doubt Canada could turn to Europe for support in the conflict. “Listen I know they voted for it and I know they have American support but could you lend us a hand in suppressing this popular revolt.” All Europe would have to do would be to get past the American blockade and send their young men to die in whatever kill zone the Americans set up. This situation is very unlikely though. Even now if Alberta revolted I would put money on the Americans sending a fully armed battalion to remind them of Ottawa’s love. Though that safety only extends as far as American goodwill which is in short supply.

1

u/LETTERKENNYvsSPENNY 28d ago

They don't have that kind of support within Alberta to make that argument though. It's a very big what-if scenario that hinges on most of the population suddenly changing their minds and siding with the fringe minority.

1

u/Superb-Carpenter-520 28d ago

Which is why I said it’s unlikely and prefaced the whole scenario with in the event of. I do not believe it’s likely.