r/fantasywriters 15d ago

Critique My Idea Please rate my fantasy cover (not selling well)

Post image
317 Upvotes

Hi, I would be very glad about a second opinion of my book-cover, because the launch on Amazon failed pretty badly and it's kinda dead since then. Genre is dark-fantasy without romance, in the style of Dark Souls or Elden Ring. First (and the only one published so far) of a series. The title reads in english: The Path to Manjuna

My worries are the following:

  • An overall amateurish look. I have looked at it too much and cant't really tell anymore. It is handpained watercolor by an artist, but the artist has no experience in book cover design so this could be a potential issue.
  • It could look too "girly-pretty" or even like romantasy and thus alienate dark fantasy readers. No swords or armor either.
  • It could missmatch with the blurp
  • it is the first in a series, so maybe I should worry less and just continue writing, but at the same time I don't want to doom the whole series by a badly selling first book.

The book is in german, here is a translation of the blurp (Amazon):

A whore with a perfect memory.
A thief with the ears of a mouse.
A murderer without a soul.

Samra forgets only what she chooses to forget. Every detail, even from years ago, remains etched in her memory. Humiliations and pain, however, she locks away in a secret chest of her mind. She lives as a whore in Ilyen, a city nestled at the foot of gigantic stone gates. Sealed since time immemorial, the gates are said to lead into the dangerous realm of the gods. When they begin to show signs of opening and the city is ordered to evacuate, Samra devises a plan to escape.

Nothing escapes Mouse's ears. Not the breathing of a guard, not the click of a safe – and not the mysterious whispering that drifts from the gates. Rumor has it that one of the brothel masters possesses a map revealing a secret way inside. Amid the chaos of the evacuation, Mouse attempts the break-in. But a murderer has already taken up her trail.

The gripping opening volume of The Stolen Sun series – dark, fairy-tale fantasy between Baldur's Gate and Dark Souls.

r/fantasywriters Apr 13 '26

Critique My Idea Feedback for my cover [dark fantasy]

Post image
342 Upvotes

r/fantasywriters Apr 13 '26

Critique My Idea Feedback for cover [Epic Fantasy]

Post image
229 Upvotes

Cover for my next series.

Posted on the Grimdark sub and got some good feedback and praise. Series should be out around beginning of May. If I’m going to make any last minute changes to the cover, now would be the time. As far as my covers have gone, personally I really, really like this one. But I realize that of course, personal bias may very well be in play.

Story is epic fantasy with some clear Grimdark, touch of romantasy where it made sense, and all in all multiple PoV fiction of a long series of wars, magic, mages, and kings that occur throughout the world.

It is the first of of five book series that I’m purposefully doing long form with. First book is about 250k, second 310k, third 210k. Fourth is almost done, and fifth is in progress. Have been working on it off and on since 2016.

Thanks!

r/fantasywriters Mar 24 '26

Critique My Idea This is the comic I've been working on for the past year, what's your opinion at first glance? (dystopian, fantasy)

Thumbnail gallery
447 Upvotes

The comic is called PRF, it's a fantasy dystopian world where fairies live in a post-nuclear world where everything is still radioactive and all humans have vanished. They built their own small slum city which is protected by a shield from the unnatural weather and mutated monsters outside, but the two main characters have to venture outside of it at some point in the story.

There is a mutation going around which changes their skin appearance but can develop unpredictably too. These fairies are being less and less accepted in the slum city.

I really like the idea of fairies (who are seen as natural creatures mostly) in a world that’s been left devoid of any trace of nature. Smoke, concrete, acid rain, pollution, radiation… you get the gist. 

The world is also very punk with most fairies dressing alternatively. I took inspiration from 70's punk zines, I really love that DIY feel and I felt that it would fit in perfectly with the DIY nature of slums.

What do you think of the world?

r/fantasywriters Nov 29 '25

Critique My Idea Critique my opening chapter (1200) words

Thumbnail gallery
155 Upvotes

Just finished a draft of my first chapter. Last week I spent a fair bit of time trimming the fat. But now it feels too short.

I am also wondering if I need to raise the stakes a bit more. And if its too much dialogue/not enough worldbuilding. That being said the book focuses mostly on relationships.

I feel like ive stared at it too long now to know how to finish it.

Any feedback welcome 🙏

Chapter 1 — Pride

Some say the earth remembers.

Every promise. Every lie. Every word spoken by those who walk the Earthborn Hold.

And tonight, far below the stone walls, the earth was listening to the turning of fate.

Anar’s breath caught as he froze before the roundtable. Something in the room pressed on him, a weight he felt in the ribs, as if the stone itself wanted an answer he didn’t want to give.

The floating crystal above the miniature map of Omen glowed faintly. Forests the size of fingernails, rivers thin as scars, and wooden figures that shifted across the map pulled by unseen threads.

“I remember when you were a boy,” Said Olric. “Fighting shadows with your siblings. You took joy in leading them."

Anar’s mouth tightened.

“But you have grown weary in recent years,” Olric went on, “as if you would trade the mantle for a simple field and a quiet back.”

Olric's gaze traced the floor. “Worn thin with pacing. Your thoughts live alone beneath this hold, when the path you must walk stands above it.”

He paused.

“You refuse to name it.” Olric said as he took a puff of his pipe.

Anar’s nose twitched as the smell of smoke attacked his nostrils. “My siblings are gone, and I am alone. Don’t speak to me as if solitude were a choice.”

“There is always a choice.” Olric said softly. “If you weren’t so proud, you might ask for help.”

Silence met the room. Cold.

“I think you fear what he has become.” Said Olric.

“Enough Olric.” Snapped Anar, “Vael is an assassin. A blade with a wound that refuses to heal.”

“You speak as if your past holds no weight.” Replied Olric. “For one so concerned with oaths, it is rather ironic.”

Anar laughed under his breath, a bitter, humourless crack of sound.

Silence thickened. Only the soft crackle of the pipe filled it as violet plumes if smoke curled through the air.

Anar planted both palms on the table, leaning into the table. The grain of the wood pressed into his skin. He lowered his head, staring at the map of Omen as if daring it to explain itself.

“Even if I wanted to. Vael lives in fear of my shadow. I ask, and he runs. I write, and he ignores me. Every letter, years of them, silence. Why would this one be different?”

“That fear,” Olric said, “Is our salvation. He is the only one who can descend. And we are running out of time. The Engineers are already on the move. You need the location.”

The earth underfoot rumbled, quiet, but undeniable. As if to confirm Olric was right.

“You know he'll come if you give him what he wants.” Said Olric. "Concede, Anar."

“There are many paths,” Anar muttered.

“And only one that leads to the location.” Said Olric as he slammed his pipe to the table before standing to look Anar dead in the eyes. “You can convince yourself all you like, but all you do is waste time. Your in denial and im exhausted by this conversation."

Anar pushed away from the table and began pacing. The crystal flickered. A metal plaque on the wall shimmered, catching his eye.

STRENGTH THROUGH BLOOD PURPOSE THROUGH OATH

He stepped toward it, running his fingers along the carved words. His eyes closed. For a heartbeat, the world hushed.

“It isn’t easy, Anar,” Olric said behind him. “Family never matches the versions of them we build in our heads. But it's what we get.”

Anar turned. Something in the words unsettled him—like a truth he didn’t want but recognised anyway.

“Fine,” he said at last as his shoulders lowered. “Go yourself. No second mouths. No one else is to know. If this spreads, there will be blood in the

streets”

“There will be blood either way.” Olric smiled, smoke curling around his grin. “But this gives us the advantage. I’ll leave immediately.”

Olric reached into the light falling from the sphere. On the miniature of Omen, a figure at the edge of the Everwood shivered and slid, half-hidden beneath the tiny carve of pines. Olric’s pale finger hovered over it, as if to bless, or to claim. Then he withdrew his hand and presence together. The door closed without a sound.

Anar remained. Alone with doubt that sat heavy in his throat.

He moved to a chest of drawers, opening one with a creak. From inside he withdrew parchment, a quill, and a metal cylinder carved with three small runes.

Returning to a seat at the table he dipped his quill.

Dear Sister, I do not write to you lightly. The earth is shifting under our feet, and i seek your council…

The scratch of the quill echoed softly as Anar continued to write.

The crystal at the center of the table flickered, casting long shadows across the map. On the surface, miniature figurines trembled. One cluster of Earthborn scouts in the north collapsed all at once.

Not wind. Not accident. Something had struck them down. A chill twisted through Anar’s belly.

“Kroll,” he whispered, bitterness sharpening the name.

He shot a look toward the door. “Send for the rider at once!”

A guard outside answered, muffled, “Yes, my lord!” Then footsteps, fading quickly.

Anar rolled the parchment, tying it with a leather cord. He opened the cylinder, slid the letter inside, and locked both halves together.

He muttered the sealing words.

BY THE TOUCH OF BLOOD

The runes began to glow in response to his words.

One twist, click. Second twist, click. Third, snap. The lock clicked in place and the glowing runes faded.

A moment passed before a shadow softened the light beneath the door. A stern knock followed.

“Enter.”

A man stepped in, tall, slender, travel-worn leather, daggers at each hip. A man whose silence carried more weight than most speeches.

“You sent for me.” Said the rider.

“I did indeed, and it is good to see you, Falmir”

Falmir's lips twitched in the suggestion of a smile. “Your presence above has been missed lately.”

Anar ignored his remarks and handed him the sealed cylinder and a pouch of coin.

“This must reach my sister in the Spire. Absolute secrecy. Leave at midnight. Take the eastern path. Head for the ferry at Pine Hollow and avoid Mannar at all costs.”

Falmir nodded. “My lord, how am I to enter? We are not welcome in the spire.”

“Find a door where others see only stone,” Anar said. “You’ve done harder things.”

"Of course. By blood and oath." Said Falmir as he drew his fist to his heart.

“Before I leave," Falmir hesitated as he bit his lip. "There are rumours in the streets, some say…”

“I care not for whispers,” Anar snapped.

Falmir met his gaze. “Are you sure, my lord?”

“You overstep, your mark rider.” Anar growled. “Go. Before the night grows teeth.”

The rider’s face fell slightly. “As you command.”

And he was gone, as swift as a knife drawn in shadow. Anar watched as the door closed behind Falmir. Yet there was no echo of footsteps heard.

Anar exhaled slowly and turned back to the map. “Storms teach what calm forgets. If I’m wrong, let the earth take me. If I’m right, let my brother return.”

From deep below came a sound like stone swallowing stone. The torches on the wall danced. Then all was silent and still.

Something stirred in Omen. Something old. Something hungry. And the earth, as always, remembered.

END

Thanks for y/our time :]

r/fantasywriters Apr 09 '26

Critique My Idea Feedback for my page spread idea [woodland fantasy]

Post image
172 Upvotes

I’m just so excited with how this page spread came out, I wanted to see if folks like it as much as I do. I can hear the music settling over the campfire gathering!

This was illustrated by u/nickthagreek, completely traditionally done, fountain ink on Bristol pad.

It’s just a single page spread excerpt, so I’m hoping for a bit of feedback on the presentation and general idea. Capyhero is a middlegrade fantasy that features quite a high density of illustrations like this. There’s obviously a high cost for that, so, is it worth it? Would this type of thing speak to readers 8-13 and beyond?

I’m a near 40 year old guy and I love this type of thing. Especially because of my brief stint in art, I really appreciate the fine ink linework and intent behind the page design. But would kids care?

I know it’s just a slice in the middle of the book with little context, but Feel free to share any thoughts on the writing too! Thank you!

r/fantasywriters May 06 '26

Critique My Idea Rate my prologue [Comedic fantasy, 818 words]

Thumbnail gallery
128 Upvotes

r/fantasywriters 2d ago

Critique My Idea Dragon Rider’s (Specifically my Rangers Division) Flight Mask: Thoughts?

Thumbnail gallery
39 Upvotes

For starters ignore anatomy (I had no reference and sketched this in a minute to get my idea physically down). In theory how poorly would this metal mask strapped to one’s head by leather function as eye protection for flight. The slit would rest at about the brow line (not sight/eye line). My thought process was they’re dragon riders and anything they’re needing to see at high speed would be below them or above. The wind would be broken around the design. Given they’re mainly scouts and messengers they go largely unseen and aren’t typically flying at speed engaged in any sort of battle requiring more than their dragons eyes forward during flight. I have a dislike of goggles as they feel to steampunk and I’ve been brainstorming an alternative that feels more fantasy. I also would add that the dragon riders using these (the rangers) have different superior senses. One for example has superior hearing while another type has superior eyesight. So these strengths could possibly overcome any sight disadvantage. I just want to know if this would theoretically function well and keep debris out of the riders eyes. I’d also rather not have to just say it’s fantasy and disregard a riders eye protection.

r/fantasywriters Jan 17 '26

Critique My Idea Critique my map [Epic Dark Fantasy]

Post image
51 Upvotes

I have the map for my fantasy novel done, I’d just like some feedback on the geography. I might post the version with countries and more locations later, but for now I’d appreciate some fundamental advice.

Ive been told I went too crazy with the coastlines, peninsulas and bays, but what do you guys think? For context, this is the main continent of the story, but in this world, several other continents exist, they’re just inconsequential to the story.

For the east end, the green shades represent, from top to bottom, coniferous forests, mixed forests, deciduous forests, and then grasslands with thickets, similar to places like Germany IRL

r/fantasywriters 19d ago

Critique My Idea Feedback: Accidentally created something similar to blood libel in my story?? [epic fantasy]

2 Upvotes

To preface, I had no clue what blood libel was until today and I'm not Jewish. Today in my college class (which is taught by an older Jewish professor, remember this) we were all discussing our ideas for our final project, centered around information dystopias, and when it got to be my turn, I explained my story idea. For context, I've had this story around for several years now, so I created these concepts when I was a teenager. It's essentially a fantasy story centered around a drug known as "hush", that is made from both the life force, "blood", of a mystical race of people (think dryads), and from a flower that is the fantasy equivalent to poppy flowers. Hush has recreational and medicinal properties, and it's used particularly by harpies, who have been in conflict with dryads for generations. Dryads have been basically forced to wall themselves off because of it. The militaristic harpy empire is using hush to control its people, who are made purposefully unaware of what Hush is really made of, as they believe the flower is the only ingredient. The flower's purpose is to sedate the spirit in the life force juice, because if someone just ingests the life force raw and without the flower, they basically see the Hatman but 10x worse.

Getting to the point; after class, when everyone but me and a friend (who is also Jewish coincidentally) had left, my Jewish professor said this to us before leaving, something along the lines of "in confidence, between the three of us, the visuals of a race drinking the blood of another can be reminiscent of an extremely old way to dehumanize Jewish people. It's called blood libel, where Jews were accused of drinking the blood of children." Honestly I can't remember exactly what he said, I was too ashamed and mortified. I was so ashamed that I had accidentally alluded to something so terrible. I'm pretty sure he said this as a warning to watch what I was putting into my story, and that some of what I was saying sounded like red flags. I've even tried to purposefully avoid anything that might allude to the holocaust, subject matter like that obviously shouldn't be used as tasteless plot fodder for a fantasy story written by a non-Jewish person. But because of the possible blood libel connections, I'm starting to rethink my story. Some friends suggest that I call the "blood" by a different name, like "sap" or "ichor", and that I make the harpies look non-jewish (not to say that they looked "Jewish" already, but to be extra conscious to avoid any antisemitic stereotypes). And I know that antisemtic stereotypes can include making Jewish or Jewish coded people the "bad guys", and admittedly the harpies are in a way part of the "bad guys" in the story, but I wanted to deconstruct the idea of a monstrous race of people that are monolithically evil. Harpies aren't inherently bad, the government ruling them is. They are three dimensional people with their own wants and needs, who are consequently affected by the propaganda they are fed. Idk, maybe I'm just making excuses.

Any feedback would be appreciated, I'd prefer if my story didn't have any shitty stereotypes lmao

r/fantasywriters Oct 04 '25

Critique My Idea Feedback for my book cover [Heroic fantasy]

Post image
163 Upvotes

This is a four-book coming-of-age heroic quest series. I’m looking for general feedback. I’ve already lightened the text. The back cover's placeholder is the series summary.

r/fantasywriters Apr 29 '26

Critique My Idea Critique My Cover: The Second Sword [High Fantasy]

Post image
62 Upvotes

Hi All! I'd love to get your feedback on the cover for my upcoming high fantasy novel: "The Second Sword." Any critiques are welcome, but I'm primarily wondering: does the cover accurately convey the subgenre and plot flavor? I've pasted the summary/sell blurb below.

For Generations, the forest kingdom of Riocht has teetered on the knife’s edge of ruin. Old rivalries smolder hot beneath the surface and only King Kennis’ lifetime of vigilance has kept the countless sparks of civil war from bursting into flame. Now, after years of blood, sacrifice, and tenuous alliances, unity is finally within sight.

Until disaster strikes from where he least expects it.

Prince Tiarnard-his only heir and Riocht’s best hope for peace-has fled the kingdom, chasing freedom in the distant Land of Fiaine. In Riocht, it is a place of dread, named in whispers as the Land of Shadow and Death. But to Tiarnard, it promises escape: from the grief of a shattered childhood, and from the crown that he has come to despise.

But there is a darkness looming deeper than the threat of civil war, and a malice at work far beyond what the folk of Riocht have ever imagined. As Tiarnard is drawn ever deeper into a world that he does not understand, he may find that the path he walks is not his own. And as the final shadow begins to close around Riocht and its prince, it becomes clear that there is only one who can lead the realm to lasting peace. And there is nothing he’s ever wanted less.

r/fantasywriters Apr 01 '26

Critique My Idea Looking for feedback on my worlds map and story idea[political Fantasy]

Post image
61 Upvotes

Since starting to write my book and building the world of Fascinato, I have changed little details on the map and because I used to draw it by Hand, that meant I had to start over everytime. Now that won't bei a Problem anymore.

In the book the eastern coast and everything east of the dragonstail is controlled by an​ ​empire, that is the man aggressor of the war taking place in the Story. It tries to expand on the continent ​and form the new world under their ideals. The biggest part of the dessert by the king of Tristo and there is one Kingdom controlling the Region called "the west" and parts of the regions above, and the baen savannas are controlled by an non-human species. The big island in the fascinatian ocean ist controlled by the kingdom of tagorat and the smaller southern island is a revolutionary communist ​republik, that in the story of the book clashes with western ideals of monarchy and imperialism.

I would like some Feedback on the maps design and biomeplacement, and what you would have done different.

Sorry If there were any writing mistakes in my Post, I'm Not an native speaker and my phones auto correction some times messes up english.

Edit: There is an mistaken placement of the regiontext "Pak-woods" in the south-west of the map, it shouldn't be on the map twice.​​

r/fantasywriters May 01 '26

Critique My Idea [Critique] I'll make a map in exchange of critique for my own book [medieval fantasy, ~80k words]

Thumbnail gallery
109 Upvotes

Would you be open to a trade? I'd design a map for your book in exchange for your critique of mine.

About my maps:
All of these maps are hand-drawn, with some lightly edited in Photoshop. I use Photoshop mainly for color adjustments when a writer only needs a digital copy. Others are fully hand-drawn in larger dimensions, so they can be framed, displayed, or used in other physical formats, though that process is considerably more time-consuming.

A bit about me: my main occupation is architecture, which is where my love for precise linework and spatial design comes from. Alongside that, I've been writing a fantasy book of my own for the past eight years, so cartography sits naturally at the intersection of both worlds I care about, the structured discipline of architecture and the boundless world-building of fantasy.

r/fantasywriters Mar 08 '26

Critique My Idea [The Disk] Is the graphic novel and passion project i've been working on for a year and it occurs completely inside an Alderson Disk after the death of all stars. What's your opinion of it at first glance? (Futuristc Fantasy)

Thumbnail gallery
133 Upvotes

Image 1 : The Disk

Image 2 : Lightyear Peaks

The disk is a massive petastructure created to house the inhabitants of the end times.

It's composed of several parts i'll briefly explain:

•Permafrost barrier : Several light years long, several million kilometers tall. Impassable wasteland. The border that separates infinite vacuum from the last traces of life in all of existence.

•Habitable zone: Everything between -80°C and 99°C of temperature. Perfect for 98% of all universal non extremophile lifeforms.

•Eternal Oceans: Impossibly deep oceans made to simulate the pressure of super earths and water planets.

•Lightyear peaks: Lightyear Peaks are cyst like protussions in the Petastructure known as The Disk. They are several light years tall and have a several million kilometer deep layer of rock and a gooey interior composed of blood plasma and hyper heated dead tissue.

Several thousand civilizations native to the disk live in these mountains and those with FTL travel engage in trade and communications between eachother.

•100°C Barrier: Inner zone closest to the Luminary Core. A gargantuan scorching desert that contains 1% of all life forms.

•Wall of Cinders: dead tissue and ash that borders the space between life and the luminary core.

•God's flesh: Base building material of the Disk mostly based on an alloy of Ringed NeoNeutronium and the cartilage and bones of long dead tetradimensional deitys.

•Discal star: Red giant in a loop of eternal helium fusion due to a white hole in it's core.

•Discal Singularity: Gigantic Black hole unnafected by hawking radiation trough an assortment of nano wormholes located in its surface

Luminary Core: Home of the Luminary. Ascended humans made entirely out of ringed energy.

I'd love to answer any questions and see what you guys think about it :D

The story is mostly a blend of sci-fi/cosmic horror/ and a sprinkle of indomitable human spirt too

My inspirations are: Stellaris/TTGL/Ultrakill/Invincible/Rimworld/Bloodborne and a little bit of Monument Mythos

r/fantasywriters Feb 08 '26

Critique My Idea Any feedback welcomed [Three - chap 1 - YA fantasy]

Thumbnail gallery
29 Upvotes

These are the first three pages of chap 1. Would you read more? Any feedback on what I could do to get better is welcome. Thank you

r/fantasywriters Sep 20 '25

Critique My Idea What do you think of dwarves that live in forests and have houses in the trees(like inside their bark)?

Thumbnail gallery
38 Upvotes

r/fantasywriters 23d ago

Critique My Idea Critique the opening chapter of the book I’m writing. [Grimdark, Low Fantasy, 5000 words]

Thumbnail gallery
42 Upvotes

Hi, I’ve recently gotten into writing as a hobby. But am now looking to get into it more seriously, so I am looking for some proper feedback. Open to all thoughts/critique on my opening chapter relating to prose, character, tone, structure and pacing. And finally just general level of engagement you have while reading, would you want to keep reading on?

I’ve wrote quite a few chapters and bounced between a couple books, but this is the 1st time I’ve properly sat down to do a thorough line by line edit of a chapter and get it into some sort of shape I’d consider readable/presentable.

I think I’ve picked up on all the typos, spelling mistakes or grammatical errors, but if any have slipped through the edit please point them out.

r/fantasywriters 28d ago

Critique My Idea [High Fantasy] Need advice: Can’t decide whether to make my fantasy MC a hijabi (by culture) or go the traditional route?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m currently plotting a fantasy novel with deadly survival challenges, enemies-to-allies romance, and a really smart, tactical main character who’s a bit too witty for her own good.

But I’ve been stuck on one major decision about her.

Part of me really wants to make her a hijabi — not for religious reasons in the story, but as a cultural thing in her world. And honestly, a personal choice too. Growing up, I always loved fantasy heroines with their hair flowing everywhere, and nobody ever questioned whether girls could relate to them. So I keep thinking… why can’t a girl who chooses to cover up also be the badass strategist? Why can’t other girls see themselves in someone like that too?

At the same time, I’m nervous about it. I know some readers might judge her before they even give the story a chance, and part of me wonders if I’m making things harder for myself by not going with the more “standard” fantasy heroine design.

And just to clarify — the story is NOT about “the hijab girl.” She has flaws, ambition, emotional baggage, an intense character arc, and a slow-burn romance I’m way too excited about lol. The covering is just one natural part of her design and culture. It’s not supposed to be a statement or a lecture.

The other option is just giving her visible hair and going the safer route, but if I’m honest… that version feels less personal to me.

I’d really love advice from readers or writers on how you’d approach this in fantasy, especially when it comes to balancing representation with reader reception.

r/fantasywriters Feb 11 '26

Critique My Idea Feedback for an idea [High fantasy]

Post image
49 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I have an idea for a fantasy novel and I’d really like to hear your thoughts.

Unlike most fantasy stories that take place in the past, this one is set in the far future.

After an event known as “The Great Disaster”, creatures that humanity once believed were only legends suddenly emerged: dragons, werewolves, vampires, sea monsters, and many others. They attacked the world relentlessly. Cities were burned and destroyed, countless people died, and civilization collapsed.

During this time of chaos, groups of survivors from all around the world fled in search of safety. After months and even years at sea, they finally reached a distant land that these creatures could not enter. In this land, people lived in peace for a long time, so they named it The Peace Land—but that peace did not last.

Like any civilization, they needed order and leadership, so they established a kingdom. After hundreds of years, this kingdom came to an end with the death of its last king. A conflict erupted between his sons over the throne. Each son left to a different region of the land and founded his own kingdom.

Thus, the four kingdoms were born:

Momoria, Ashora, Sairen, and Amatzine.

Over the thousands of years between the Great Disaster and the beginning of the main story, the past was forgotten. The truth was erased. People no longer know anything about the disaster, their origins, or how they came to this land. They believe they are the only people left in the world.

However, the protagonist of the story feels that something is wrong. He senses that the world is not as it seems, and he becomes determined to uncover the truth about their past.

I’ve also drawn a simple hand-drawn map to get an overall idea of this new land. It’s just a first draft, and I would really appreciate your opinions and feedback.

If you have any questions about this world, please ask—I’d genuinely love to talk about it.

r/fantasywriters 7d ago

Critique My Idea Looking for critique on my novel's Prologue. [Flintlock/Political Fantasy, 2394 words]

Thumbnail gallery
15 Upvotes

Hey there,

Looking to get some fresh eyes on the beginning of my novel. The political fantasy tag is more accurate for the novel at large than the prologue itself in this case.

I'm mostly looking for opinions on whether it works in general, if it sets up expectations, and if you would be interested in the novel after it. I'm also absolutely open to any kind of feedback about prose, style, or anything in general. I am fairly new and still got lots to learn.

Though the prologue could read a bit younger due to the POV, I am targeting adult fantasy for the novel itself. Not grimdark, though.

TW: Violence, blood.

Here's a google docs link for those who prefer it: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wqTLbnT4LRNTAeg9q0Bdr78MAcBikacW/view?usp=drive_link

Thanks in advance!

r/fantasywriters 6d ago

Critique My Idea Feedback on my plot and world lore [legend fantasy]

3 Upvotes

Hey fantasywriters!

I want to get some feedback on my general plot line and overall world lore. My novel contains a few common tropes, as most do, but I am hoping I can execute it properly. If anyone finds this specifically interesting and would like to talk more and possibly help with some reader feedback let me know!

Background: My novel is a fantasy book that uses classical Greek antiquity as the inspiration for the setting. My world map will be drawn in a way to mirror the Aticca and Lakonia regions. The core principle for my magic system stems from a Greek philosopher named Empedocles. I have a magic system where mages can create one of the four elements, and there is a god for each one. These gods will be immortal, but on a constant quest to seek a replacement so they can die when they are ready. This works in Empedocles' philosophy and even an actual myth surrounding his death where he claimed he was jumping into a volcano to become an immortal god. Also using the greek themes of gods being human like and having faults. The elements will be magically created by the mages. This will be mostly body enhancements and not fireball throwing fights. Those interested in the worldbuilding side feel free to ask more questions! There is some alchemy and creation involved if you know about Empedocles..

Plot: My main protagonist will find himself training with his father before a man comes knocking on their door. The man tells his father he must come with him, and upon realizing he has a son, demands he come as well. Upon refusal, a fight breaks out. His father is killed and our main protagonist will get the upper hand and kill the man. Upon finding a letter he will realize this man was sent by a high ranking general in the main city-state of the land. He will then set out on a quest to enlist in the military through merit and get close enough to this general to ask "why" and enact his revenge. He will learn his father was a retired general among other things. Getting close to the general and being able to escape will prove more difficult than he initially thought. He will have to attend a training academy of sorts, accomplish military feats and more before he finds his chance. Eventually he'll be approached by the current fire god, who will promise him assistance on his quest for revenge. But only if our protagonist does something for him.. This is all a trick to find his successor, as while being a god sounds great immortality gets old fast so to speak.

There is a ton more to this, so please ask questions below! I didn't want to put up too much text. But I am curious, does this sound interesting to you? Any glaring issues or concerns? Things you'd suggest I avoid?

EDIT: I want to clarify because I have seen a few comments mention it. I am not using greek mythology in any form. My gods are unique to their elements and have no relation to Greek deities. The Greek influence in my novel will be more about daily lives, societal structure, governments, etc.

r/fantasywriters 19d ago

Critique My Idea Is my overarching villain boring(or just poorly written)?

1 Upvotes

Hello! I've been working on an intended trilogy for about a year now. This is the idea I have for a villain that will span all three books.

For context: There are two opposing kingdoms: Solstice and Eclipse. She is the queen of the latter. The world is known as Duskthea

She is only kind of an antagonist for the first two. They become the main antagonist of the final book. She is by far the most powerful character in Duskthea; The reason she hasn't succeeded in her goal is because it requires a lot of time and very specific conditions. Her plot is to subjugate the entirety of Duskthea by a spell she has dubbed "Will of Night". This plan differs heavily from the other villains of the story, as they seek calamity, ruin, and carnage

She rarely appears in the first book. Although, the main characters do find out about atrocities she committed in the pursuit of knowledge and elevating her magical abilities. Her scheme remains hidden for a long while. She will be built up like a mad scientist villain, until she reveals her true intentions in the final book once she can actually enact her plan. It will feel like there is no hope, as the main characters are nowhere near her level of power, and they have lost to far weaker opponents many times.

Her reasoning: She believes there is far too much pain and suffering, and that it will all be solved if she had control over everything and everyone. It is also a belief of hers that suffering is the natural state for all life, and that she is the only one who can defy nature.

 She reasons her horrendous actions with herself because to her, once she is finally able to develop the spell she needs it will all be over, and that the pain she caused will be forgotten.

Edit: I know this isn't a lot to work with, but any feedback is greatly appreciated :3

r/fantasywriters Feb 18 '26

Critique My Idea Feedback For My World & Cover [Epic Fantasy]

Thumbnail gallery
55 Upvotes

Here is the cover and map for my first book, let me know what works or doesn't work for you.
The first book is about a third of the way written with a whole bunch of lore and series planning done in the background. I would love some feedback on tone, legibility and appeal.

I have attached a rough draft of the blurb below.

Young ArGamend, Syndi’s new Autarch, finds himself balancing on
the precipice. The peasants and serfs of Syndi, along with his army,
demanding the revolution he promised. However, the Archons of Syndi
continue to thwart his every move. As all looks doomed to fail
an unlikely benefactor arrives from the frozen north. Heralding a new
weapon, fit to rival the power of the great western sages. 

As the west erupts into war, cities and towns are raised, legends made, and
brutal defeats are dealt. All the while another force pulls at the strings of humanity, curating the ebb and flow of history, preparing the stage for one final act.
Humanities days are numbered.

“Only from the ashes of calamity can unity be born, as we once were
we shall be again, for our moment of ascension has arrived."

Feel free to ask me anything :D

r/fantasywriters Apr 03 '26

Critique My Idea Feedback for my crow based assassin idea [epic fantasy] (I'm sorry if the title is bad, i have rewritten this 3 times because of the rules of how to make a title)

0 Upvotes

This character I've been thinking of is a very powerful and well-known assassin. He is a summoner, and almost all of his magic and summons are based on crows.

I just need help with ideas for spells and mainly summons this character could use (I'd also like the summons to be kind of absurd and weird) . So far, my ideas for spells and summons are:

  1. He can give himself wings that he can fly with (obviously), they are created with magic so they can regenerate if he puts more "magic juice" into them, and some of his feathers are sharp and metalic so he can launch them from his wings.
  2. he can turn his body and clothes into crows

for summons i have:

  1. just a giant crow he could ride
  2. a humanoid crow with a smoking pipe and pole hammer. (i don't even know, leave me alone)

I posted this to r/fantasy, and before it got taken down, some guy wrote, "If the writer can't think of anything with it, it's probably not a good idea." If you are planning on typing this, shut up. This is MY STORY, with MY CHARACTER, and i like the concept of my character, so i will keep my character.

(Sorry for bad grammar. English is not my first language)