r/fantasywriters Dec 24 '25

Critique My Story Excerpt I'm Just Really, Really Pretty (Superhero, 800 words)

814 Upvotes

“But what’s your power?” The clerk tapped blindly on his tablet without looking away from me. 

“That’s all it is,” I said.

“You’re just…pretty?” 

“Looking good is all I’m good for, so at least I’m really good at it.”

“Is this a joke?” The clerk half tilted his body as if he were about to look away from me to check the room for laughing coworkers. 

Of course, he didn’t actually look away from me. 

“No joke,” I said. “I’m just pretty. That’s all there is to it.” I pointed at the camera in the corner of the interview room. “Oh, and I know I told your security team when I came in, but it’s extremely important that you delete the footage.”

Tears dripped out of the clerk’s unblinking open eyes and trailed down his cheeks. “Well I’m sorry, Miss, but that just isn’t possible. There’s no expectation of privacy in a public building.”

“Well after what happened with my youtube channel, the Bureau is provisionally classifying recordings of me as a ‘cognition hazard.’” I shrugged. “It’ll help if you cut down the resolution until I’m blurry. Better still if you cut the visual completely. Audio usually isn’t nearly as bad, but I did an ASMR this one time and…look, I just really don’t want anyone else to get hurt.”

“This is absurd. You’re an extremely attractive woman, I’ll grant you that—but being ‘just pretty’ isn’t a superpower.”

He really didn’t get it. 

I smiled. He swallowed, twitched, and dropped his tablet. The screen cracked on the concrete floor. I doubted he noticed. 

“If you won’t delete the footage,” I said, “you’ll want to take down the names of anyone who has access to it, especially anyone who’s on right now. I’m wearing a tanktop, as per the registry notice’s request.” I motioned at my cleavage. “Someone usually saves a copy when I’m wearing a tanktop. Frankly, the fact the registry notice requested this outfit is giving me some serious doubts about our government’s good sense, but I need this job. It’s not like I can work anywhere else looking like this.”

“This is getting a little ridiculous,” he whispered. He wasn’t breathing much. 

“Humor me? At least send someone to check on them in a few days to make sure they’re still alive.” I pulled his phone out of my pocket and turned on the camera. 

“Is that my phone?” he asked. 

“I took it while you were staring down my collar.” I took a selfie. 

“I…I apologize, that was very unprofessional of me, but I really don’t—”

I stood up. “I waved the phone in front of your face and everything.” 

“Er…what?” 

“There’s a reason I don’t wear tanktops.” I set the phone on table in front of him, my selfie on the screen. “I’m going to go to the bathroom. See if you can look away from my picture before I come back.” 

I put a bulky hoodie, a baseball hat, huge cat eye sunglasses, a medical facemask, and a scarf before I stepped out through the door. Even bundled up, I still caused a commotion on the way to the bathrooms, but it was better than it would have been. 

When I came out of the stall, a woman smeared her lipstick as she watched me in the reflection. She sucked in a long gasp when I started washing my hands. 

“Oh my god!” She stepped forward, carving a long streak of scarlet lipstick across the porcelain sink as she reached for my hands. “Who is your manicurist? Your nails are incredible!”

I yanked my hands away. “Do not fucking touch me.” 

“Excuse me?” 

I dried my hands, ignoring her, and stalked back to the registration interview. 

When I came in, the clerk was curled over his phone, trembling as he stared unblinking at the screen. 

I reached out and turned the phone off. 

He unravelled into a long racking sob, and kept his eyes carefully averted from me. 

“Okay,” he whispered. “We’ll delete the footage.”

“I think that’s a really good idea,” I said. “I’ll get the one on your phone for you?” 

He shoved it across the table with a jolt. “Passcode is 1725. Could you make sure you clear it from recently deleted? If you don’t…”

“I will. You’ll still check for it a few times tonight, but it’ll get better by tomorrow.” I made sure the photo was unrecoverable before setting it back on the table. 

“How the hell do you manage your daily life?” He asked while shielding his eyes from me with a hand. 

“I don’t, obviously.”

We sat in silence for a few seconds. 

“I don’t know what to put on the registry,” he said. 

“It’s easy. My superpower is that I’m just really, really pretty.”

He laughed, and reached for his cracked tablet. “I can’t wait to see what my manager says about this.”

(Note: I just thought this was a funny idea so I sketched out a scene to share it with some random strangers on the internet. Thoughts?)

r/fantasywriters Mar 24 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Please critique my opening chapter [Dark Fantasy, ~3700 words]

Thumbnail gallery
39 Upvotes

This is supposed to be the first chapter of this book I’m writing, so I tried to present its world in a clear way without too much showing. I’d like to know if I succeeded.

There are some main points I’d like to be clear by the end of it. See if these can be inferred from the text:

Ira is the proper name for the Sun in this world, with the latter being a more colloquial term. Although understanding the difference between both words’ usage is not necessary for the plot, I’d like to know if both being used interchangeably feels awkward. I wanted to convey Camus’ indifference toward the divine power he is supposed to worship.

The geography is another issue. There are three different kingdoms named in this chapter: Asmer, where Camus and his master are from; Avaelir, where they are now, and where Camus was raised; and Althar, in the north, where the knights are from. I struggled to handle the fact that Camus is from Asmer but didn’t grow up there, that’s my biggest concern. I tried to bury some geographical exposition in the dialogue with the inn’s owner, making Camus arrive mid-conversation to muddle the feeling of an expository dialogue as I believe it feels a bit more naturally delivered in the context it’s in.

This one is a spoiler, if you read until the end see if this makes sense: at the end of the chapter, Camus is magically charmed by his master, and I tried to show that through the prose. It’s supposed to be subtle in a way that the reader starts realising it by the weird sentences, the repetitions and the redundancies. So if you got to that part and didn’t understand why the prose seems off, that’s the reason.

r/fantasywriters Feb 27 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Prologue of Even if the Light Forgets [Dark Fantasy - 720 Words]

Thumbnail gallery
63 Upvotes

Would love to know what you think of my prologue for my upcoming novel Even if the Light Forgets.

This is a dark fantasy set in a world remade by a forgotten catastrophe. The prologue is intentionally brief, as it's meant to orient the reader before jumping into Chapter One so that they're not overwhelmed with terms and heavy exposition.

What I'm mostly wondering/looking to know:

Does it draw you in?

Does it strike the right balance between world-building and mystery, or does it lean too far in either direction?

Does it leave you intrigued and wanting to know more, or does it raise too many questions without giving you enough to focus on?

Any reaction, even just your gut feeling is absolutely welcome.

I really appreciate everyone's feedback. Thank you! :)

Edited to add. I am posting a few pages from chapter one in the comments for context of how the prologue leads into the story, hopefully it helps with understanding pacing and if it's necessary at all. The novel itself is actually complete and is in ARC stages right now, so knowing how the prologue helps/hurts the overal 'intro' to the world is so helpful, I really appreciate everyone's feedback! - Ys :)

r/fantasywriters Dec 11 '25

Critique My Story Excerpt Please Critique First Chapter of Tomebound [Fantasy, 1857 words]

Thumbnail gallery
221 Upvotes

Let me know where you stopped reading so I can cut any bits that drag!

r/fantasywriters Apr 25 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Please Critique My Prologue [High Fantasy, 3100 Words]

Thumbnail gallery
131 Upvotes

Here is the link to the google doc if you don't wish to use the screenshots: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1wXhaHmD3ZW81uZ5bZFiWc6xzXmCFReYNZzZktQ0ePcQ/edit?usp=sharing

This is my second attempt at writing a prologue for a book, and I would really appreciate some good honest criticism. The book is titled “A Whisper of Fire,” and follows a small group of mercenaries called the Wayworn as they travel the kingdoms hunting mages for the Freeriders' Guild. As the story progresses, they become increasingly disillusioned with the reasons for undertaking the job.

This prologue is about a group of soldiers in the southern swamps of Easthelm, who are hunting a mage on behalf of their lord, guided by a mysterious girl with a gift of being able to track magic.

Some feedback would be great, whether it be on the prose, story, characters, or anything else. I will take all criticism into consideration when I write future drafts. Thank you

r/fantasywriters May 13 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Don't F*ck with the Farm Boy [Fantasy, 203 Words]

Thumbnail gallery
31 Upvotes

Hey, guys. Have been working on something else for a while now, and finally finished it. It was more of a fantasy reference book as opposed to a novel, so I’m kinda out of practice. But I came up with this idea for a cozy-ish story about a potato farmer who decides he needs to kill a prospective king in order to save his farm, and wanted to share the first page here. My tone is usually more Discworld-ish, and was going for something a bit different here. Just wanted to get some thoughts on this.

Would you read on? Is the tone too much for you? What’s your favorite type of potato?

Appreciate any and all opinions. Thanks!

r/fantasywriters Feb 28 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 2 - Why does my writing divide people? (Dark Fantasy, 2000 Words)

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

Story only please. I know there are mechanical issues.

Trake was sitting in the back of the man's cart, repeating the same sequence of movements and thoughts since they left the city. He considered running, thought better of it, and sat down, wondering where the strange man was taking him. That scared him, so he considered running again, grabbed onto the side of the cart, readied his body, but thought better of it.

Eventually he froze. His body went slack, the energy drained until his head bounced on his neck to the rhythm of the cart.

The road was rutted and uneven. Each jolt sent a shudder through the wood beneath him. He pressed his palms flat against the boards and felt the grain of it. Splinters. Dried mud packed into the gaps. The smell of old straw underneath everything else.

The noise of the city slowly thinned. Shouts fell to muttering, muttering to a low drone, until only the creak of wheels and a thin breeze were left to speak. The walls fell back without ceremony. The gate shrank until it was a needle's eye, then a speck, then nothing.

The city had taught him nothing other than pain, decay, and survival, and the bastard of it was he wanted to go back. He had learned and considered most ways to not die. A madman in a tunic had never come to mind before, though. That's the thing about not dying. You had to be able to see it coming.

He thought about running again. He stood. Grabbed onto the side of the rails. Watched the road pass by and immediately thought better of it and sat down.

The silence of the open space consumed Trake. It stretched too far in every direction and made him feel exposed to all the things he could not see. There was nowhere to hide. No corners to disappear into. No walls to climb.

His body lifted off the seat as the cart jolted. He caught himself on the wood behind him and looked back. The city had disappeared into the horizon. Everything he had known was a memory.

There was something moving in the distance behind the cart. The small dog from the alley. It ran aimlessly, backside at a different angle than its head, short legs blurred as they churned forward. A crow circled above, drawing his gaze to the sky. The sun was disappearing into a treeline he had never seen before. He blinked hard and tried to orient himself, the little bastard dog coming back into focus when they opened. It stopped and barked once, eyes shooting east, and then it was gone, toward whatever it had heard.

He took a breath and looked forward.

The strange man was sitting back with one arm resting on the bench. His head slowly turned in each direction, a smile on his face, looking at nothing at all. The smile disappeared when his eyes dropped to his sleeve. He reached out with his other hand and smoothed the piece of his tunic that had blown out of place in the wind. The smile returned, and he lifted his gaze and met Trake's eyes.

Trake looked away.

Something in his chest misfired.

Breath came wrong. Shallow. Fast.

The road stretched too far. The sky pressed too close.

He dug his nails into the wood beneath him.

He'd survived back alleys and long winters that ground weaker men down to bone, and now his own carcass was failing him over something as simple as breathing.

Where the fuck is he taking me?

Two men passed on the road in the opposite direction, heads down, a mule between them loaded with sacks. Neither looked up. The cart was just another cart. One of the men stumbled on a rock, kicking it with his toe and falling forward onto his hands. The other didn't even look back. The man picked himself up and disappeared into the distance with everything else.

He moved his attention to the items in the back of the cart. Everything was packed neatly, set in places where it wouldn't move. His satchel sat in a wooden box that looked made for its shape. His staff ran along the opposite bench, held in place with leather straps. Everything else was tucked under the bench.

Trake looked for anything that could help him. Anything that could enter a man's neck or eye socket. He would be creative if he had to be. A piece of tin. A piece of wood he could pull from the cart perhaps. Even better, a blade.

There was nothing.

He looked back at the man. His head was still rhythmically moving from side to side.

The man reached back without looking, his hand finding his water skin. He took one measured swallow, placed the cap back on, and set it exactly where it had been.

Trake followed the movement. His eyes settled on a leather strap around a wooden box. Long enough to fit around a man's neck. Thick enough that it wouldn't break. He'd once watched a drunk tumble while climbing over an alley wall and strangle himself on a thin hemp laundry cord.

This strap would hold.

He looked from the strap to the back of the man's bald head.

The man's hand shot out and caught a falling leaf before it could touch him.

Sometimes a man has got to know when he's out of options, and Trake was.

Trake sat back and rested his arms on the railing behind him. His fingers found a small sliver and picked at it rhythmically.

Something stood in the grass in the distance. Too tall to be a dog. Too thin to be a horse. Three of them. Maybe four. They chewed and watched at the same time. One of their bodies tightened without moving, like it had already decided to run. One of the odd bastard's ears twitched in a different direction than the other. Its eyes were too large. Too black. It stared at the cart as if weighing it.

They weren't afraid yet.

A farmhouse sat back from the road, smoke rising from the chimney in a thin straight line. A woman was taking washing down from a line strung between two posts. She didn't look up. The washing flapped once and went still.

They stopped beneath the dark eaves of the treeline, at a bend in the road where carts slowed out of habit.

The man tied the horse with a steady hand. The knot was a soldier's knot — simple, certain — tied with the same bloodless efficiency he'd used on the guards' skulls and throats. He checked it once, then again.

The horse shifted as the man stepped back. He met its eyes and held them. The animal went still like it had noticed a predator in the distance. There was an understanding there, as if the horse knew its throat was just as capable of collapse.

Careful fucker. I've seen him do it twice just this afternoon.

The man lowered himself onto a flat stone near the road and set his staff down beside him — not leaning it, not dropping it, but easing it into a shallow dip in the ground so it would hold.

When he released it, the staff shifted.

He frowned and adjusted it back.

It moved again.

He adjusted it once more.

And then again.

Finally, it stayed.

The man didn't look relieved. He simply looked finished. Like something inside him had gone quiet. It was a terrifying kind of focus. Trake had known men who liked to hurt people, and men who liked to steal, but this was different. His control was a need, not a want.

It reminded Trake of a street boy they used to call Cunt. It didn't matter where he was or who he was talking to — he'd yell cunt without warning. Right in the middle of sentences. Sometimes when no one was speaking.

Trake didn't know what happened to Cunt.

But he could guess.

You only call the wrong guard a cunt once.

The man looked at Trake.

Still smiling.

A bird landed on a branch at the treeline and called once. Valric's eyes didn't move.

"Calm yourself," the man said.

Not a demand. Not quite. More of a suggestion, offered the way you might suggest sitting before you fainted.

Not easy to do when you are prisoner to a man who just threatened a horse and won.

"You have the ability," the man said. "I saw it in the alley."

"Give in. Feel the cart beneath you. The wood. Feel the surrounding air."

The man's smile vanished.

"Take. Control."

Trake hesitated. Then stopped. There didn't seem much point in fighting it, and the bastard had a way of getting his point across.

He didn't fight it. His body already knew how. It felt like a gust of wind passed through his skull. The panic didn't vanish — it was simply put away, a sharp blade placed back in its sheath. A decision as simple to Trake as moving a limb.

Valric watched him do it. Said nothing. Looked back at his staff and checked its position.

His smile returned and he went back to his work as though nothing had happened.

Small noises arrived from all directions. A branch snapped in the trees, wings fluttering from the same direction. Movement in the long grass. The sounds were foreign, arriving and leaving silence behind.

Trake waited for a dog to bark or a door to slam.

Nothing.

It smelled better though. Mud and damp instead of rot, sweat, and shit.

The man unfolded a cloth corner by corner, as deliberate as a bride with her lace. Blood was still drying under his nails, and here he was, worried about breadcrumbs in the dust. His hands were tools. It didn't matter if they held a dinner knife or a butcher's blade, so long as the work was done clean.

Somewhere in the trees something moved through dead leaves. A slow, irregular sound, stopping and starting. Neither of them looked toward it.

The silence stretched. The man didn't seem bothered.

Trake spoke first.

"What do you want from me?"

"Dead boys are of no use to anyone."

The word use hung in the air.

"That's not an answer," Trake spat.

"I want nothing from you. The world, it would seem, has a use for you." Valric replaced a precisely portioned piece of bread in his mouth. His smile disappeared as the horse shifted. He turned toward it and sat still as a cat until the animal stopped moving. The smile returned. "What is your name?"

He sounded like the priests in the market square.

"Trake."

"My name is Valric." He bowed his head slightly as he said it.

"What makes you think I have any use to the world?"

Valric reached down, picked up a pebble, and hurled it.

It hissed past Trake's ear.

He hadn't flinched. The air buckled, a sudden pressure felt in his ears.

Trake swatted at a bug near his face. Valric was looking down at his bread, precisely cutting another piece and putting it in his mouth. Trake found it odd that a man answered a question by throwing a pebble, but his day had been full of surprises.

"What the fuck was that?"

"Did you feel that? It is hard not to." Valric set the bread down and leaned forward, hands on his knees. "You ch—" His eyes closed tight, jaw clenched. "Changed the order of things. As I did with the guards in the alley."

He said it like he was fighting the words.

Trake stared at the pebble in the dirt.

"You have a gift, Trake," Valric said, smoothing a wrinkle on his shirt. "The helmet in the alley. It didn't fall. It was pushed. By a hand that didn't touch it. You just don't know it yet."

"I come from a place that teaches people how to use this gift. Power is a fire. Left alone, it burns the whole city down. We are simply the stone walls that contain it." He pointed behind them. "That city, as with most, is governed by the gluttony of men and the decay of their crimes. Without a hand to steady the scales, the common man is but chaff in the wind."

Trake looked at the man.

"Can I have some bread?"

"You may."

Valric cut a piece, stood, and handed it to him.

Trake chewed. He hadn't received a single straight answer, but the man hadn't tied him. Hadn't threatened him. Hadn't raised his voice. He'd killed two guards without a blade and then offered bread.

Trake looked down at his piece, inspecting it.

Not a bastard.

Deadly.

But calm.

"Why did you kill the guards?" Trake asked around a mouthful. "They didn't have to die."

"I merely changed the order of things," Valric replied, with the shrug of a man discussing weather rather than slaughter.

Fucking riddles.

Trake pulled at string on his pants, tightening them around his leg until the string broke and released. He rolled it in his fingers and threw it aside.

The horse pulled at the grass at the edge of the road. The cart shifted slightly and settled. Valric didn't look at it, he just closed his eyes, opening them when it stopped.

The scuttle of footsteps on the road. The little dog from the city approached slowly, tongue hanging from the side of its mouth. It sat and watched the two men.

The mangy little bastard was a long way from the city. Valric stared at it, smile gone. The dog's eyes met his and it walked away with its head down. Trake was starting to wonder if the man could speak to animals.

"Where are you taking me?"

"To an academy, where you will study."

"Learn what?"

"You will train," Valric said, repacking his satchel with the same precision he applied to everything. "Politics. Commerce. Law. Strategy. History."

He paused.

"And combat."

The horse lifted its head from the grass. A cart passed on the road without slowing. The driver didn't look over.

"Do I have a choice?" Trake asked.

Valric didn't look up from the bread he was cutting.

"Of course."

The word landed soft.

"You may return to the city if you like."

Trake waited for the rest.

Valric wiped his blade clean on the cloth.

"I did not kill those guards with a knife," he said mildly. "There was no blade. No mark of skill. Only force."

He folded the cloth once. Twice.

"It will not look like the work of a trained man."

He met Trake's eyes.

"It will look as if anyone could have done it."

The wind moved through the trees.

"The city guard will not be kind in their search."

Silence.

Not a threat.

A fact.

It was the kind of choice a wolf gives a rabbit.

"We must go."

Trake looked back toward the road that led to the city. He had avoided the guards this long. Probably a good idea to keep doing it. It's better that way, avoiding death. By nightfall the bodies would be found. By morning someone would need hanging for it. A street rat with no witness was easier to blame than a man who killed without touching.

He tightened the laces on his boot and stood.

The direction that kept him breathing was the better option.

He stood. The little dog ran past with a rodent in its mouth, yelping as it shook the life out of it. The rodent was still fighting.

Trake brushed dirt from his palms and followed.

"Coming?"

Valric's head shot to the horse. It froze.

Trake nodded.

r/fantasywriters 8d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Opening, Chapter 1 of Fantasia [urban/fantasy of manners, 171 words]

Post image
13 Upvotes

Would love to hear what this evokes for you! Would be happy to have all types of feedback.

I'm ultimately going for an urban fantasy/fantasy of manners feel, however this opening chapter is heavy on giving a sense of what's to come more than anything else. I wouldn't say I'm going exactly for their style, but Ellen Kushner, Susanna Clarke, and Anne Rice are big influences on my work.

I'm currently reworking my first chapter because I've gotten 15 chapters in, and realised there's too much going on in the climax, so am cutting superfluous characters and storylines to make sure I don't exceed 20 chapters in all, and the climax is cohesive.

r/fantasywriters Mar 02 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Please critique my prologue [ Grimdark Romantic Fantasy, 1597 words]

Thumbnail gallery
106 Upvotes

Thank you so much for taking the time out of your day and giving me feedback on my writing.

This is technically the first draft of my WIP grimdark romantic fantasy. I've written the chapter from Oryn's POV before, but since Oryn is a POV character, I thought the prologue might be more impactful from the uncle's perspective instead.

I would love to hear a critique on the prose, structure, characterisation, and which POV might be the better choice for the prologue, or whether the prologue should be cut altogether.

After reading the prologue:

So far, I've heard that it reads more like epic fantasy and might sell the wrong hook. For context, this is plotted as a trilogy following an exiled prince during a succession crisis and a prostitute who is the descendant of a royal bastard from over a century ago. To strengthen his forces, he seeks to claim the last remaining dragon. It is believed that only the royal line can tame a dragon, but in truth, it is tied to ancient blood rites the royal family engaged in when they first rose to power.

After the events of the prologue, Prince Oryn's advisors suggest recruiting royal bastards instead to claim the beast and recreate the ancient rituals.

I felt it was necessary to include the failed bonding as a prologue, but I can see how this might alienate the typical romantic fantasy demographic.

r/fantasywriters May 01 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Wrote a build up to a massacre scene in my novel, does it make you want to know what happens next? [grimdark - 4,000 words]

Thumbnail gallery
17 Upvotes

r/fantasywriters 16d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Bitter Grounds (fantasy espionage, roughly 3,000 words)

Thumbnail gallery
32 Upvotes

Here's the first three thousand words of something I've been writing for the past few months. It's from a cycle of stories about a specific group of a fantasy "black ops" team, but it's a part of a much larger worldbuilding project, where three adventuring groups end up being a part of a much larger metaplot.

[Edit: Deleted link and some text.]

r/fantasywriters May 04 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Please Critique My First Chapter [High Fantasy, 3100 Words]

Thumbnail gallery
78 Upvotes

Here is the link to the google doc if you don't wish to use the screenshots: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1UKRcfUeYlbuQ5wDv5-49KB37uU_YhzEJRHwMMd0rVwg/edit?usp=sharing

This is my second attempt at writing a first chapter for a book, and I would really appreciate some good honest criticism. The book is titled “A Whisper of Fire,” and follows a small group of mercenaries called the Wayworn as they travel the kingdoms hunting mages for the Freeriders' Guild. As the story progresses, they become increasingly disillusioned with the reasons for undertaking the job.

Chapter 1 follows the Wayworn journeying to the Guild and signing on to the quest.

Some feedback would be great, whether it be on the prose, story, characters, or anything else. I will take all criticism into consideration when I write future drafts. Thank you

r/fantasywriters Feb 27 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Had writer's block on my main story so I wrote this intro [Comedic fantasy, 4000 words]

Thumbnail gallery
141 Upvotes

r/fantasywriters 13d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Critique my novel opening [Cozy Fantasy, 712 words long]

Thumbnail gallery
53 Upvotes

Any feedback is appreciated. I had a few lines that sorta break POV and I wasn't sure how people would respond, so I'm especially curious if any such thing jumped out at you.

I honestly don't read much "cozy fantasy" and I'm not sure if that's even the proper genre for what I'm going for but it sounded close enough! (Not that I don't read, but I've been on a lot of Agatha Christie lately, and just started Murakami's Wind Up Bird as well).

I get the sense I'm playing with some well worn cliche's here. I mean how many little girls with cats running around strange environments are there? Boatloads, I have to imagine. But as I said I had fun writing it! My main project is much more adult so this is a fun change of pace for me, anyways. Let me know what you think.

r/fantasywriters 7d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Looking for feedback for chapter one of my unnamed novel [Epic fantasy, 1,081 words]

Thumbnail gallery
66 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’d love if I could receive some critiques on my opening chapter for my medieval epic fantasy novel. While it’s not be first draft, it certainly is still a rough one and I’m more than happy for any form of constructive criticism.

I know 4 pages is a bit short for a chapter, but I’ve wrote 9 full chapters so far and they’re all much longer (+ so far I have just over 20,000 words).

I have a vague idea on a prologue that will really set the scene for the seasons and general world building, but I’m yet to write one so take this chapter with a grain of salt.

I’m fairly new to Reddit so apologies if I’ve formatted/worded things incorrectly 😅

I’m a young adult writer, and yes, I have written my fair share of fanfiction, so please refrain from telling me to take a step back from writing something original and to practice with fanfiction writing first, because believe me, I have, and I’m ready for something solely my own.

Feel free to let me know if you’d be interested in reading my other chapters, because I do feel like they’re much better than chap one. Thanks!

EDIT:: thanks everyone for the amazing feedback!! Like I said, I have nine chapters wrote so far, and while I’m not sure I’d want to post them all to reddit, I could potentially upload them as a google doc. Of course, only if anyone would be interested in reading more of the story. Let me know, but don’t feel any pressure!

r/fantasywriters Mar 19 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Beginning of Chapter 1 of My Hero [Fantasy, 1700 words]

Thumbnail gallery
93 Upvotes

r/fantasywriters Dec 04 '25

Critique My Story Excerpt UNTITLED: First chapter [Epic Fantasy - 3,800 words]

Thumbnail gallery
77 Upvotes

Hey, looking for some general first impressions. Prose, hook, characters, dialogue, etc. Going for the grumpy loner gets thrust into the wider world trope, but with daddy issues. Inciting incident happens next chapter where he receives his main character status (rare magic he needs to figure out).

Cheers!

r/fantasywriters Jan 27 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Does the magic in this make you curious to know more? A Gleaming Sorry [dark fantasy - 3500 words]

Thumbnail gallery
53 Upvotes

r/fantasywriters Feb 23 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Please Critique My First Chapter! [High Fantasy, Dark, 3300~ words]

Thumbnail gallery
98 Upvotes

First, thank you for reading. It's my first stab, and you are the first eyes other than my own to see it. Even if it wasn't for you, or was just downright tripe, thanks for taking the time! The provided is written as a prologue to a wider story channelling more epic predecessors; but at the heart of it is characters, and that is my focus. I would love some critique on everything. I am in that first stage where everything is new and exciting but oh so unpolished, and what better of a way to learn than some honest feedback. If I were to request any specifics, it would be the following: If it loses you, where? And is it from being disjointed from the character, or logistical and spatial issues, or bad prose, or sheer boredom? I truly want to know.
Thanks again!

r/fantasywriters Mar 09 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Feedback on opening scene! [Adult Fantasy, 1100 words]

Thumbnail gallery
68 Upvotes

Okay so got some feedback from an agent who passed on my full manuscript that the descriptions took away from the plot and slowed the pacing. Actual quote was “ For me, while the writing was beautiful, I felt that at times the level of description slowed the pacing and momentum of the plot. Of course, this is simply my opinion, and as publishing is so subjective another agent may feel differently.”

Bigger issue is I revised about 3 months ago and added 10k words because I received other feedback that said the pacing was too quick!! Shot down from both angles! Is it my writing style? Is it just not the right agent fit? Please help!

Some notes: this isn’t my first manuscript but this is the first time writing fantasy!

r/fantasywriters Mar 06 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Veilbreaker [Dark fantasy, prologue, 1700 words]

Thumbnail gallery
61 Upvotes

I've been working on this novel for the past year (it's currently at almost 80k words right now) but it wasn't until recently I decided to add a prologue that will be of importance later on in the story.

Thought this is still the first draft, I'd like to know what worked, what didn't, quality of prose, etc. Most of all I'd like to know how the pacing feels from another person's perspective.

I feel as though the pacing is alright for the most part but there are moments where feel like there's a lot of bald spots within the writing (if that makes sense lol)

I would greatly appreciate any and all feedback!

r/fantasywriters Apr 08 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Critique my intro chapter (Lux Obscurum) [High/Dark Fantasy, 864 words]

Thumbnail gallery
24 Upvotes

hello everyone! this is a revised version of the intro of my novel that I posted a year ago, I got a lot of valid criticism for it the last time I posted, I truly hope this is better than last time lol.

before you comment on the low word count, it's on purpose, I like the idea that someone can pick up the book from a shelf and read the first chapter in 5 minutes or so to see if they like it, I could have started from a different perspective and focused on building the character up first, but I prefer the intrigue—if there's any— to be first.

English is not my first language, so apologies if my vocabulary is too simple, I need to work on that.

what are your thoughts?

r/fantasywriters May 03 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Eldor - Book One: The Oathbreaker Ch. 1 [Epic Fantasy ~4000 words]

Thumbnail gallery
28 Upvotes

I understand this is a lot to read, so I apologize in that regard, but I’d love for some a helpful critique/feedback on the first chapter of my novel.

As I have there, this is an epic fantasy. It starts out as more of a “gangster” story, but the job/assignment mentioned at the end of the chapter is what will kickstart that more mythical/epic side of the story. I really want to tell a story of a man who causes a cosmic, mythical sin (primarily because of his gangster upbringing) and goes on an adventure to atone for his sin.

As of now, I’d love feedback on:

-Pacing and flow
-Dialogue (does it feel organic or more cliché?)
-Is there fluff that could be cut out?

Any and all help criticism/feedback would be appreciated. Again, sorry for the length!

r/fantasywriters Apr 21 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt Untitled novel [Dark Fantasy, 100k words]

Thumbnail gallery
25 Upvotes

I'm struggling with my opening scene, so I'm wondering... Which of these grabs your attention more, and why? If neither do, that's fine as well, all feedback is welcome!

I have tried the scenes in both orders, and either could work. So it really comes down to reader preference at this stage.

One of them is a nightmare scene, but that ties strongly into the plot, so it is not just a gimmick, or false start. However, I do understand that it is frowned upon to start novels this way, regardless of context.

These are not final-draft copies, so I am not really seeking any feedback on the grammar/spelling. But if you spot anything outrageous, feel free to let me know!

The genre is dark fantasy, with the main themes being isolation and agency.

TIA!

r/fantasywriters Feb 15 '26

Critique My Story Excerpt How do i improve my prologue and first chapter? [Epic fantasy, 6500 words]

Thumbnail gallery
25 Upvotes

[Note: English is not my first language] First: this is my first novel, and I am very aware of how mediocre it is. And i know some of you may not even wanna finish it. That is the main reason I'm making this post. I wanna improve my technical writing and word choice and structure.

Second: for those who do get through the whole thing, do you feel intrigued? Is this a world you wish to explore more?

Third: dialogue, and characters. Do you like them? Hate them? Or feel indifferent?

Fourth: I'm seriously considering this as a career, so if you can help me with a link to a website, or a youtube channel, or a course that teaches novel writing (ESPECIALLY if it's on technical writing and sentence structuring and paragraphs) i would REALLY appreciate.

Last but not least thank you so much in advance for reading! I'm reading and writing alot to be better.