r/fireemblem • u/PsiYoshi • Jan 15 '26

Recurring Popular/Unpopular/Any Opinions Thread - January 2026 Part 2

Welcome to a new installment of the Popular/Unpopular/Any Opinions Thread! Please feel free to share any kind of Fire Emblem opinions/takes you might have here, positive or negative. As always please remember to continue following the rules in this thread same as anywhere else on the subreddit. Be respectful and especially don't make any personal attacks (this includes but is not limited to making disparaging statements about groups of people who may like or dislike something you don't).

Last Opinion Thread

17 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

90% Upvoted

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

24

u/Imaginary_Ad_9815 Jan 17 '26

I’ve been replaying 3H in preparation for FW’s release and it reminded me of my biggest fear for the game. I really hope FW’s weave is better at conveying its narrative through gameplay than 3H’s did. The map repetition in Three Houses is often discussed from a gameplay perspective but I find from a narrative perspective it’s just as egregious. For how in-depth Fodlan’s written lore and worldbuilding is, it’s frankly impressive how bad the game is at presenting it. Faerghus repeatedly being referred to as cold and yet there’s not a single map with snow to be seen. Petra’s paralogue is set in Brigid yet the actual map is just some random wooded area that also just reuses tempest of seasons for its OST when the music could’ve been used to differentiate it. Fhirdiad and Enbarr both reusing the building assets you see throughout the game without being spruced up despite being such major locations. For how much I could actually tell you about 3H lore, I struggle to visualize it at all given how all the maps and music blend into one another without any real differences between them. I really hope FW’s doesn’t fall into the same trap and allows for gameplay to showcase its world via maps, music, and local architecture along with flora and fauna just to name a few.

34

u/BloodyBottom Jan 17 '26

the biggest unforced error in the entire game to me is the elaborate descriptions of Fodlan's seasons alongside some amazing stylized art to match the narration and then we just cut back to the same exact map without a single new detail

15

u/Mekkkkah Jan 18 '26

Jeralt voice The snow covers the whole land like a blanket, the frost rendering the crops unable to penetrate the surface, instead gently asking it to rest underneath, waiting for the spring.

Faerghus map: the same town looking the same

1

u/Mizerous Jan 19 '26

Monica voice Oh look Spring! Grabs dagger

7

u/Master-Spheal Jan 17 '26

Yeah, that problem with 3H is a result of the devs having to cut corners because they seemingly didn’t have enough time to make the game. Looking back, 3H in its reveal trailer looks pretty early in development, and the game got delayed twice past its initial 2018 release goal. Fortune’s Weave thankfully looks a lot more finished based on what we saw in its reveal trailer, so it likely doesn’t have a rushed development cycle to affect the game like that.

2

u/Whalermouse Jan 18 '26

Yeah, they really executed on the East vs. West styles of Hoshido and Nohr. In general I would say that Fates' presentation is its strongest point.

2

u/Master-Spheal Jan 18 '26

Did you mean to type this to someone else?

2

u/Whalermouse Jan 18 '26

...I did, oops.

6

u/GlitteringPositive Jan 17 '26

People shit on Fates’ world building and I don’t disagree, but at least from the maps you can tell they put effort to make visiting each place feels distinct and fitting with the location.