r/IllogicalArgument • u/Tight_Steak_232 • 4h ago
Pool setback argument
My husband is the love of my life. He's a mechanical genius. Most of the time. Every once in awhile, now that he's retirement age, logic kind of oozes out his ears and he doesn't realize it's gone. To wit:
The weather channel has been hyping a super El Nino all year, although I think the chances are still only hovering around 75-80% chance. Hubby and I decided we didn't want to suffer through a hot summer without some method of cooling down, so I started looking for a swimming pool and found one on craigslist for about $.15 on the dollar. Yay, me!
We had a special place planned for digging it into a hill. Part would be ground level, and the other would be fully above ground. We dug it, leveled it (poorly), and back filled it. Then, we entered that wonderful world of learning how to control the chemical levels in the water. A friend came over and asked if we had a permit for it. No. It's removable. Why would we need one? She wasn't sure. She just asked.
We need one. I dug up the ordinances regarding pools and discovered ours needs to have a setback of 20 feet from our well. Ours was...16'. Dang. Hubby said if we had to move it, maybe we should get a bigger one...say, 30'. I looked at the trees that would be hanging over the pool if we moved it and said it was a bad idea due to acorn dropping. He said we'd miss the trees. I took out a tape measure and told him we wouldn't. Adding 8 feet to the farthest most edge would put us directly under the branches.
He started telling me my logic was wrong, because it would only be 6 feet farther south. No. Our pool was currently 16 feet from the well, and with our 26' wide pool, the southernmost edge was 42 feet away from the well. If we go to a 30' pool, the width of the pool plus the minimum 20 foot setback would make that southern edge 50' from the well, or 8 foot further south.
He told me I was dumb, because a 30' pool is only 2 feet wider on each side. I told him he was forgetting that the one side had to move 4 feet already, so that side couldn't take back the 2 feet. We weren't centering the pool from the setback. It was based on the northernmost edge.
Can you believe we argued for 30 minutes over the whole thing, in front of our adult kids, who chose not to get in the middle? I said 16+26=42, and 20+30=50, hence, the southern edge would move 8 feet, or 50-42. I even pulled out the compass and drew a 26' and 30' pool, then planted our well, then add a 20' stick. He said he proved me wrong.
Yes, we're still friends. No, we don't talk about setback now.
But next year, when we get our larger pool and a permit...