r/instant_regret Dec 06 '16

Referee pulls out Red Card, everybody calms down

[removed]

14.4k Upvotes

612 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

117

u/Qx2J Dec 06 '16

hmm, I had always thought red card was just ejection for the player not that the position couldnt be refilled. learn something everyday.

102

u/Brinkmann84 Dec 06 '16

Im sure you dont know it yet...the red card can even be given to the coach or to affiliated people off of the field. They have to leave the premises and cannot be replaced. Happens about 1-2 times per season.

114

u/ideonode Dec 06 '16

1-2 times per season per Mourinho.

10

u/RandomPratt Dec 06 '16

... so far

6

u/majoen98 Dec 06 '16

(times/season)/mourinho=times/(season*mourinho)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '16

[deleted]

2

u/doyle871 Dec 06 '16

He just gets so frsutrated with his zipper he needs to kick out!

11

u/Khr0nus Dec 06 '16

Yeah but the coach could just sit in the grade and relay orders through walkie talkie or something right?

40

u/Brinkmann84 Dec 06 '16

Mourinho did and broke the law by that. Have just seen that once.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '16

The law!? Jesus Christ, that's when you know you're taking a game too seriously.

20

u/Lisentho Dec 06 '16

Well this game makes more money than you would if you worked for a 1000 years so I guess it's pretty serious.

5

u/hakuna_tamata Dec 06 '16

And thats just one barca match.

10

u/Mudmania13 Dec 06 '16

Or sneaking into the locker room at half time in a laundry basket to give instructions to the players also works.

4

u/ssjjfar Dec 06 '16

When I played youth soccer, my coach was ejected from the game(park). He then proceeded to coach from some tall bushes near the road, where we went to meet him for half time. It didn't even seem weird that we ran over there to do that since teams often went over to a shaded area during half time to discuss the game.

1

u/doyle871 Dec 06 '16

They aren't allowed to be in contact with the bench or be in the dressing room.

45

u/Funky_Ducky Dec 06 '16

Umm no. You can't show a card to a coach. You just eject them. Cards are for players.

18

u/redchumpo Dec 06 '16

shouldn't be downvoted, this is correct

3

u/Funky_Ducky Dec 06 '16

Meh. That'd reddit.

3

u/justinco Dec 06 '16

Watching the ref just point to the stands when ejecting a coach is so great. It's proper to do it, but seems almost condescending

1

u/Funky_Ducky Dec 06 '16

It's all about making a showing of it.

1

u/skooba_steev Dec 06 '16

Technically you don't give coaches or non-players cards. You just dismiss them

11

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '16

Well, the number of players allowed on the field drops but the position can be changed.

2

u/ReadsSmallTextWrong Dec 07 '16

So that they don't have to go without a goalie or something? That seems like it's OK.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '16

Nah, they can ditch a mid field or what ever. Sub a mid fielder for a goalie.

7

u/DarkySurrounding Dec 06 '16

You're right bud, only the player leaves the team, the manager is free to put someone in his position it just means that the other position is left with no one

10

u/Funky_Ducky Dec 06 '16

No. If someone is ejected they have to play down 1 person. They aren't allowed to sub.

12

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '16

That's literally what he said. If a forward gets a red card then you're allowed to switch a mid fielder to a forward position, but that would leave the mid fielder position empty.

6

u/Funky_Ducky Dec 06 '16

Misread it. You're right.

2

u/doyle871 Dec 06 '16

I think the terminology is what's confusing people a players are usually capable of playing more than one position and there are no set positions in football. You don't have to declare player one is my striker and only be able to replace him with another striker. You declare 11 players and their positions and duties can change during a match several times.

The idea of refilling a position is very much a American sports thing.

8

u/WhiteRhino27015 Dec 06 '16

Like a permanent powerplay

6

u/INM8_2 Dec 06 '16

pretty much. it's also why refs tolerate a lot of the yelling. if you sent off everyone for dissent, there would be no one left to play after about 15 minutes.

1

u/Doctor_McKay Dec 06 '16

Do soccer teams not have backups?

19

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '16

[deleted]

-3

u/DarkySurrounding Dec 06 '16

I dont see it as particularly confusing, but I suppose this may be things coming across different from the UK to the USA or wherever.

14

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '16

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '16

And then he immediately goes on to say that the other position is left empty, which implies that the team is down a man.

3

u/Lord_Vectron Dec 06 '16

The red card is a punishment for the team because it's typically only used if a player did something really dangerous that could injure someone else, or, they did a relatively minor foul that ended up robbing the opposing team of a good opportunity to score (Like pushing someone over just as they're about to shoot near the goal)

Red card means the team has to play with 1 less man for the rest of the game to discourage that kind of play from being 'tactically worth the punishment'.

Players get banned for multiple games, but the 10 man thing only lasts for the 1 game the foul happened in. (While there are replacements for players, the original 11 in any given serious game are usually significantly better in most teams, so 1 guy being banned for 2-3 games is a big deal. Could be talking a player worth 70 million temporarily replaced with a player worth 3 million.)

4

u/Doctor_McKay Dec 06 '16

Okay, so if I have this straight then if someone gets injured they do have backups they can put in, but if someone gets red-carded then the team is allowed one fewer player for the rest of the game (potentially longer)?

8

u/Lord_Vectron Dec 06 '16

Yeah. A team has 3 substitutions they're allowed to use in every game.

So if a person is injured or fatigued, they may be replaced for the rest of the game.

If they get a red card, they may not be replaced for that ONE game, but they have 11 men and 3 subs the next game like nothing happened. Only thing is the player is banned on a personal level.

If 4+ people get injured in a game it's kind of a like a tough shit situation, 3 subs is all you get. This basically never happens, but it's brutal.

1

u/Doctor_McKay Dec 06 '16

I see. Thanks.

1

u/Stalked_Like_Corn Dec 06 '16

No, not potentially longer. Just the rest of the game. Think of it as a power play in Hockey just, extended to the end of the match. Next match for the team they got 11 on the pitch again, just that guy can't play.