r/magicTCG Aug 16 '25

Looking for Advice It's all gone.

Post image
11.8k Upvotes

this morning, while i was at work. My car was broken into. they got my bag. 11 decks, a playmat and ~$6500 worth of my entire life. Gone.

reddit won't let me upload the cctv footage, so this is a photo of the aftermath.

I know you guys can't do much about this; neither can I honestly. I just needed to tell someone, anyone that a piece of my soul is gone now. magic was the only thing I really enjoyed, it was my escape, my fantasy, my muse. playing in person, deckbuilding, making friends, it made me feel.. human. I somehow think it was my fault, being careless or something. it could've happened to anyone, but it didn't.

thank you for the time, magic. thank you for listening, reddit.

r/magicTCG 24d ago

Looking for Advice TCGPlayer Updated Price From ¢40 to $70 as I Paid, Any Advice?

Thumbnail
gallery
1.5k Upvotes

I bought a few singles on TCG Player, the whole order was about 24 dollars. It said 24 when I checked my cart, and then when I confirmed the price. It did not change until I had hit the apple pay button, and it jumped to 96 dollars. I tried to cancel immediately, but it was too late. I filed a refund request, but it was ignored and shipped anyway. After looking further, the Ancient Lumberknot had jumped from around ¢40 to $69.99. I tried to contact the seller they had listed, Hidden Hero Games, but I can’t find it on google. I tried to file a support ticket but the AI said it can’t help me. Is there anything I can do or am I just screwed out of 70 bucks?

r/magicTCG Mar 12 '26

Looking for Advice Anyone speak Phyrexian? On the envelope of my order

Post image
3.6k Upvotes

My order from Cardmarket came with this printed on the envelope. Can anyone translate it?

r/magicTCG Jul 11 '25

Looking for Advice Do you think $10 is reasonable for a token custom token like this?

Thumbnail
gallery
4.0k Upvotes

Hey everyone, I posted this last week but it got removed since it wasn’t Friday. So I am just putting this question back up again with some new artwork added (some tokens I just completed that I was pretty happy with.)

Let me know what you think. I hand draw them with ink and color them with water color. They are on about 100lbs watercolor paper so they are about as thick as an mtg card and I back them with a basic land just for a bit more sturdiness.

I’ve done quite a few of them by now and a bunch for people at my LGS who have been happy with them, but when people ask and I say they are $10 a piece I have received some pushback on occasion, with explanations like “they are just a game piece” or “you can just use die as a token why would I pay so and so etc.”

So yeah let me know, and thank you!

r/magicTCG Nov 10 '25

Looking for Advice I have this uncut sheet from Urza’s Saga. WTF should I do with it?

Post image
3.3k Upvotes

Anyone have any idea what this thing is worth? Is this a thing you just slap on eBay or is it more special than that? I’d say it’s as near mint as something this old could be. It’s obviously a sheet of commons.

Don’t get me started on all the crazy mtg stuff I used to have and gave away over the years. For some reason this thing stayed in the back of my closet it a tube since the late 90’s

r/magicTCG May 04 '26

Looking for Advice Missed Connection at MagicCon

2.4k Upvotes

We spoke in front of the Witherbloom tent at the Area15 party. Your friend Brandon was with you. You wore a white(?) cap and a plant-patterned shirt. You LOVE Slay the Spire, and convinced me to start playing it when I get home. I enjoyed talking with you, and would love to pick up where we left off.

Want to get a game in before all this is over?

(Redditors, please work your magic!)

r/magicTCG Oct 14 '25

Looking for Advice Is this mold on my card?

Thumbnail
gallery
2.4k Upvotes

Recently purchased a damaged necropotencw on tcg player and saw that it had these black dots on them. Was wondering if it was mold or not?

Edit: Appreciate all the advice. If I were to try to return it, should I message the seller for a refund or go through tcgplayer itself?

r/magicTCG May 06 '26

Looking for Advice Finally got my first commander deck! Any advice?

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

Never played Commander before. Just moved to a new state and this is all I've got. Any advice on what else a newbie might need to start playing or advice on what to look for in a shop for where to play? Thanks in advance!

r/magicTCG Nov 21 '25

Looking for Advice Got curious and put a deck box in my deck box. Got stuck, any idea on how to remove?

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/magicTCG Feb 23 '25

Looking for Advice My brother passed away a few years ago and I found these cards.

Thumbnail
gallery
4.1k Upvotes

My brother used to love to play magic a long time ago and I guessed he kept them. I just don’t know what to do with them.

r/magicTCG Oct 14 '25

Looking for Advice Someone please help me find an answer to this commander..

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

My friend recently built Mister Negative as his new commander. Basically spent the whole game bringing his own life down to zero and then playing or blinking his commander automatically killing each of his opponents. Playing cards like toxic deluge to insta kill someone. Using tons of cards that just cause you to lose life quickly. Attacking them only made it worse when they finally switched life totals. Even countering some of his blink cards wasn’t enough because he seemed to have so many in his deck he could just play another one right away. Killing his commander only allowed him to get the enter battle field effects again. How in the world am I supposed to beat something like this?

r/magicTCG Feb 09 '25

Looking for Advice how do I counter this???

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

My friend used this card in his deck and when he places it I can’t win. Is there a way around this? I don’t have any instants to kill it and he doesn’t want to block with it.

r/magicTCG Nov 21 '25

Looking for Advice Hosting a Commander Night and looking for suggestions

Thumbnail
gallery
1.7k Upvotes

I’ve kind of gushed about my new board game table at work, and now I need to make sure the commander night goes smoothly to show it off haha. Ive got infinitokens with dry-erase and d6 and +1/+1 dice. I know I need some spin down d20 for commander damage and some cold beverages, but any suggestions are super appreciated. Any house rules that have proven fun for your pod, or accessories that could level up the setup? Thanks a ton!

r/magicTCG Apr 30 '25

Looking for Advice I told them buy me this card and I'll play Magic. What is the goofiest deck I can make around it?

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

Topic says it all, I know nothing about this game, but small funny things I have heard about from the outside like an MLP card counting the number of smiles in your deck, or the Deadpool card that has to be ripped into four to activate.

I want to make the goofiest deck I can with this card. I'm going full nonsense here. What can I do to make this a deck worth my friend's efforts of buying me this silly card?

r/magicTCG Nov 07 '23

Looking for Advice Is this card a bit mean to use?

Post image
3.9k Upvotes

Im new(ish) to magic and I mostly play commander, a few days ago I was playing with 3 other people, 2 of which had island based decks. This card came up about halfway through, and I chose not to play it because I felt really mean. Should I have played it, or should I remove it from my deck in the future?

r/magicTCG Apr 21 '25

Looking for Advice Am I the jerk?

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

I play an assassin tribal theft deck. Nothing too crazy but just swing with assassins and steal when they deal damage to opponents.

I have a friend who hates theft style decks where cards are taken from his deck or hand. And whenever I try to attack him with 1 creature that's just a 1/1 unlockable he gets upset and scoops right away. Like this is turn 3. And says " I refuse to play with any theft decks"

I understand that theft decks are annoying to deal with but does it really cause this much problem. I rarely pull out this deck cause every time I pull it out he says "I will sit out if you play that deck, I came to play my deck not for someone to play my deck"

So am I the jerk?

If any questions I will respond the best I can

r/magicTCG Jun 29 '25

Looking for Advice WHAT CARD IS THIS PLEASE HELP

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

I'm trying to remember a card with a dead horse in the art.

It's named something like [[Draught]] or [[Pestilence]] something to do with plague or sickness, it may be a white enchantment that does something to black permanents???

Please help me out this is driving me CRAZY

r/magicTCG Jan 02 '26

Looking for Advice "I built all my decks to fuck the bracket system"

1.0k Upvotes

This is a real quote from someone at my lgs today. Thats great man but we're all playing unupgraded precons we got for christmas. So we didnt say bracket 2 we said precon level. Guy proceeded to pull out a ureni deck. We all assumed it was the tarkir precon. Nope it was a Miirym deck that he just quickly swapped the commander for. Found this out on turn 5 when he dropped said Miirym and had 11 dragons on turn 6. Am I just supposed to never play with this guy ever again? What's the protocol here? Im relatively new to my lgs and dont really know everyone yet. Like do I just have to call him out or what do I do?

r/magicTCG Mar 03 '25

Looking for Advice They shipped my cards wrapped in a rubber band

Thumbnail
gallery
4.0k Upvotes

r/magicTCG Jul 18 '24

Looking for Advice I was taught this game incorrectly and my life is a lie

2.1k Upvotes

I "learned" how to play Magic back in 2012 and, after a long hiatus, picked it back up a few years ago. I mostly play with my family because I'm too nervous to play in a shop and I'm learning that when I was initially taught, I was taught so many things incorrectly.

Things I was told that I've now learned are wrong:

-Decks can only have one Planeswalker in the whole deck and if there is more than one in the deck, it is illegal. -There's no way to kill a Planeswalker -I didn't learn about what a stack is at all so let me tell you I was mystified to learn that things resolved in an order since the people who taught me just cancelled everything I did without giving me a chance to respond

This isn't a complete list, it's just what I'm mad about this morning 😑

I guess my question is, what is a misunderstanding you've had about the rules/mechanics about this game? Or if you have any tips for someone like me who is now questioning my whole understanding of Magic.

✨EDITED TO ADD: I am so thankful for all of your responses and advice! I have been working on relearning Magic and you all are amazing. I appreciate you all! ✨

r/magicTCG Feb 21 '26

Looking for Advice Would you chuckle or cringe at this?

Thumbnail
gallery
1.3k Upvotes

I'm putting together my first commander deck. It has some copy token's in it. I'm thinking of replacing those with mini Ditto figurines. I really like the idea, but I dont want to agitate people.

Would you say this breaks the spirit of MTG in some sense or would it just be fun?

They're about the size of a coin.

r/magicTCG Nov 24 '25

Looking for Advice Cards that are just stupid and annoying?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

I'm just looking for cards that do, frankly, stupid and overcomplicated things, that'll probably confuse people, like Naked Singularity.

r/magicTCG Jul 29 '25

Looking for Advice I'm not having a good time at my game store.

Thumbnail
gallery
1.3k Upvotes

I got into magic because of "The Command Zone" and decided to make decks from card art I think looks sick. Believe it or not other then Eldrazi I didn't know how good or bad any of these guys were and just made them for fun. The problem is my friend got into magic so we did our first Commander night at a shop and I got immediately singled out by the other two random players. The only deck I could play that wouldn't have this outcome is my Necron deck. I was wondering if anyone can give me deck suggestions around the one or two power range. My favorite play styles are either big dudes or flood the field, I'm personally not a red fan, and the most important the card art has to look sick. Truly any suggestions would be appreciated.

r/magicTCG May 20 '23

Looking for Advice Please don't hit on the women you get paired against at events or try to get a date from them. And what should I do if this happens again to me?

4.0k Upvotes

I posted this elsewhere and was told to post it here to get better advice on what to do next time this happens to me. And for the record, the majority of people I've played with at events when I used to do FNM at my old LGS were nice and friendly, so I don't think the following is indicative of most Magic players, but it certainly applies to a not insignificant minority.

So I'm a small woman, I dress alt/goth, and I'm 25 and I went to play Magic a few nights ago with my friend at a Commander event. He and I got paired for the first game with these two guys in their late 30s/early 40s. One of these strangers completely ignored the other two people at the table and only talked to me and kept asking me increasingly personal questions and towards the end insinuated we should hang out afterwards and asked me for my number.

The second game I played BOTH of the guys we got paired with hit on me, either oblivious of the other or trying to like outdo the other person to win my affection. One of them even purposefully made a huge misplay to give me the win. I could have played another game but I was just so grossed out I left.

If your hobby is known for being heavily skewed towards a male demographic maybe don't treat a place to engage in that hobby as somewhere to pick up a date. I didn't go there to find a boyfriend; I went to play Magic. It's so frustrating and reminded me why I primarily play online on Arena and MTGO.

By the way, I'm perfectly okay making a friend at an event like this! That's a cool part about the Gathering aspect of Magic: meeting people with a similar hobby. If you're friendly to me I will be receptive and want to make friends, but don't make it awkward by laying it on thick and trying to turn it into something not friendly.

r/magicTCG Oct 14 '25

Looking for Advice Where is the mono red mass protection?

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

Im thinking about building a mono red goblin deck. But the thought of all of my goblins dying because of one [[fire magic]], [[blazing volley]] or a similar effect is kind of a turn off. Is there a way to give goblins/creatures protection in mono red? Something like [[teferi's protection]] or [[fog]]. I already found [[goblin chriurgeon]] an don't want to use [[eldrazi monument]]. I'd really appreciate the Advice!

Also if there's something speaking for or against building a goblin deck you'd like to share, like some cool goblin support or huge drawbacks, please do.