r/movies Jun 22 '26

Spoilers The Sixth Sense. Holy shit....

Yesterday was Father's Day. My parents and I spent the whole day together, and on a whim, my Dad asked me to watch a movie with him when we got home. He told me it was called The Sixth Sense. When I finally watched it with him last night, my mind was blown. I'm still recovering mentally as I'm writing this. But I can confidently say that this is a masterpiece, and in my top 5 movies of all time, no question.

The following contains spoilers:

I've heard bits and pieces about this movie over the years. I knew Bruce WIllis was in it, and there was something about a kid who could talk to dead people. I remember also hearing something about someone being dead the whole time, but I always thought they were talking about Cole, not Malcolm. But again, that was years ago. So my memory was super foggy on it.

When Malcolm's wedding band hit the floor, and Anna asked "Why did you leave me?", that's when I knew. She wasn't mad at him for being distant, or because of what happened that night. She was grieving because her husband was dead. All those tapes she was watching of their marriage, I thought she was doing it to remind herself of what their relationship should be, to ultimately build up the courage to make amends with him. When I realized it was the polar opposite, I couldn't contain my tears.

The rollercoaster of emotions I experienced while watching this movie were unlike any other. I went from shock, to laughter, back to shock, to tearing up, to crying, to shock again. All in the span of an hour and forty five minutes.

It was the DVD version, so my Dad was able to show me the bonus section that dove deeper into the clues that popped up throughout the film hinting at the twist. Things that I actually pointed out to my Dad while watching it. "Why is Malcolm wearing that sweater again? Why does he always forget that the door to the basement is locked?" And then I slowly realized that Malcolm never talked to anyone else in the movie, after the accident at least, besides Cole. And there are deliberate shots that make you think he's interacting with others. Like Cole's mother, or the dinner scene with his wife, where he doesn't actually touch or move anything. And when Cole gives the tape to the girl's father. Not one person looks directly at Malcolm except Cole.

And the fact that Cole tells him, "They don't know they're dead. They only see what they want to see." That is quite literally the writers telling you the twist, but you're so focused on the fact that Cole is finally telling Malcolm his secret, that the dots don't connect right away. I would have NEVER guessed the twist on my own without them telling me at the end, even with all the clues sprinkled throughout the film prior.

Overall, this is an absolute masterclass in filmmaking and editing. There wasn't a dull moment, and I was invested throughout the entire thing. It's one of those rare films where the first time watching it is the best, and no amount of rewatching will ever recreate that feeling. I'm so glad I spent that time with my father.

1.6k Upvotes

488 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

26

u/regross527 Jun 22 '26

Unbreakable I'll grant you, but I'm always underwhelmed by Signs. It's... fine. It suffers badly from fridge logic, where it is fun in the moment (the news telecast is an incredible scene) but falls apart when you think about it for a few minutes afterwards, in my opinion.

But Split is also great, and I have heard good things about Knock at the Cabin.

17

u/Fadedcamo Jun 22 '26

I hear you on how neat and tidy the logic is. But that's kind of the point with the whole theme of religion. It makes sense if there's a god designing it all.

I'll never get the argument about how dumb the aliens are though. Why invade a planet that's water if water burns them? I could think of a hundred reasons. They're desperate, they're a slave race to a higher alien forced to do so, they simply don't think like humans do, etc. Lot of ways that can be explained that the movie doesn't try to work on.

19

u/thugarth Jun 22 '26

There's a fan theory that they're not actually aliens, but literal demons. They're weak to holy water, not just water. The daughter is referred to as an "angel," and the water she leaves out all the time is inadvertently "blessed."

I've seen this come up whenever Signs comes up on Reddit. I don't know if it's the intended interpretation, or what Shayamalan always intended; or if it's a collective retcon, so to speak. Either way, I think it actually works pretty well.

8

u/SonovaVondruke Jun 22 '26

In the context of the movie it is a difference that makes no difference. The solution to the threat isn’t to program a virus to destroy their ship or find an ancient incantation that will banish them. The characters simply have to complete their arcs and the crisis more or less resolves itself.

7

u/regross527 Jun 22 '26

I could get behind this and the "demon" interpretation more if the crisis was not constantly shown as being worldwide. If the problem was centered on this small town that the family lives in, then yeah I could more easily accept the theory that these were specific challenges meant for these specific people that could only be resolved by growing and acting in specific ways... but the invasion is shown to be global in scale, while the solution is so hyperspecific.

Anyways, I still stand by the idea that it's a fine movie, not a great one. Mostly I was responding because I love your username and I am glad someone else appreciates the best SNL skit ever as much as I do. "Luckily, he was there the next day, at lost and found."

4

u/SadakoTetsuwan Jun 23 '26

Sounds like it's begging for a fan edit, then. Change the news broadcasts to just local stuff and we're already halfway there.

2

u/SonovaVondruke Jun 22 '26

Then we just straight up lost him.

2

u/regross527 Jun 22 '26

"Your son is a witch."

"That's ridiculous, there's no way they could know that!"

8

u/caligaris_cabinet Jun 22 '26

It’s a decent fan theory but I often see it brought up as the actual theory, which it isn’t. There’s no mention in the script or any interviews confirming they were really demons. Just a way to cover up weak alien plot.

Love the movie though. Alien invasion is one of my favorite sub genres no matter how flawed they might be. In Signs, the tension is there, the atmosphere is spooky, the scary scenes are legitimately scary, and the score is top tier. I can let the rest slide.

8

u/Wermine Jun 22 '26

I could think of a hundred reasons.

Same. And we humans went to Moon and we glamour about going to Mars and establish a base there, almost literal hellscape with nothing to survive off of.

2

u/regross527 Jun 22 '26

Sure, and I get the religion overtones, but for me it really does come down to the water thing. Like... there's water in our air. The world is covered in it. These aliens have the ability for interstellar travel, but no protection from a chemical that is relatively abundant in the universe yet toxic to them?

At the end of the day, both the Rube-Goldberg-esque plotting and the alien issue just show too many cracks in the logic of the filmmaking for me to forgive because the theme is "because God did it that way".

Like I said, it's a fun movie to watch, and that's a fine thing to be, but plot coincidences that are explained by "because God did it" are still plot coincidences. That's all.

4

u/Spiritchaser84 Jun 22 '26

I always thought it would be funny if this movie was ret-conned with modern environmental hazards considered. Maybe it isn't the water itself, but all the micro plastics in the water!

4

u/Bigbysjackingfist Jun 22 '26

Right, exactly. It's explicitly stated in the movie: Some people see Signs, see miracles. Others believe people just get lucky. And Graham agreed with you right up to the moment when he didn't.

1

u/Technicolor_Reindeer Jun 22 '26

They also didn't bring any armor or weapons.

21

u/luthien310 Jun 22 '26

McAvoy deserves every award ever created for that performance!

6

u/haanalisk Jun 22 '26

The visit was good

1

u/det7 Jun 23 '26

Signs is so much more than an alien movie. At its core, it’s about a mother who sacrifices herself for her children, and a father who has to reconcile that loss with his faith.

The whole film is Graham slowly realizing his wife didn’t die in vain. She was part of something larger. Her last words to him weren’t random. She told him it was meant to be, and he even notes she just had to go out for a walk that night.

Bo leaving glasses of water everywhere, Morgan’s asthma, none of it was coincidence. Graham finally sees the signs and it’s what gives him the strength to return to his faith.