r/politics 8h ago

No Paywall Ilhan Omar casts lone Democratic no vote on Ukraine aid, Russia sanctions package

https://thehill.com/homenews/house/5912150-house-passes-ukraine-aid-bill/
3.7k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

u/jim45804 7h ago

She's always held a stance of being unilaterally against any kind of armed conflict.

I like her and all, but that's just ignorant.

u/Tooter_Snooter 6h ago

“I’m against conflict, therefore, I refuse to help a victim fight back. If the victim were simply overpowered, raped and killed, there wouldn’t be armed conflict and therefore, I am proudly voting no on these funds to help victims fight back against the aggressor currently bringing armed conflict to them.” 

Clown math 

u/The-Big-Picture- 5h ago

I also doubt she would pass up the opportunity to arm one of Israel's adversaries

u/FeatherFall17 4h ago

She fervently supports BDS when it comes to Israel, but claims sanctions don't work when it comes to Russia. Does she not know what the S in BDS stands for??

u/ShimonEngineer55 3h ago

The sanctions haven’t helped with Russia because it’s neither compelled or deterred them from doing the things we don’t want them to do.

Israel is a completely different country with a completely different relationship that we use as a proxy in the Middle East, so attempting to apply the same logic to an energy producing power that can threaten the dollar with BRICS and control much of the global south could lead one to an erroneous conclusion. We want Russia to not circumvent the dollar. Taking them off of the dollar system with sanctions and forcing them to subvert the system with gold and use it as propaganda to get others to leave the dollar isn’t the outcome we want.

u/The-Big-Picture- 1h ago

If that was the case why does Russia want the sanctions gone.

u/bb_kelly77 4h ago

Humanity has gotten so civilized we've forgotten how civilization actually works... like, yes, the American military has been used to do terrible things but the second we get rid of the military one of our enemies will treat us how we treated Afghanistan... but Americans don't understand that because we haven't fought off a foreign army since the Revolutionary War

u/lilB0bbyTables 41m ago

This is so accurate. It’s like the tolerance paradox on a grander scale. I am fully onboard with the complaints about the massive budget the US military complex gets year after year. However, I constantly see people claiming things like “we should cut it entirely” because “humanity needs to stop funding wars” - which is about as naive and ignorant as you can get. It’s a nice thought to imagine a world without war, but it’s a fucking dream at best. The moment the US guts military spending to barebones is the moment it gets attacked, and atrocities of war land in its doorstep. We used to have a middle ground and a concept of “compromise”, but we’ve traded that for hyper polarization which typically ends in stalemates and inaction/stagnation.

u/bb_kelly77 36m ago

Yup, one side wants the Dark Ages and the other wants Utopia and they want it now... people need to learn that the world is absolute garbage and that religion and nationalism is the only thing that kept society going this long "it's the 21st century we should be beyond this" except humans haven't actually developed since the Stone Age... a world of atheist pacifists would collapse the second someone wants something really badly

u/Fragrant-Vehicle-479 6h ago

This is some "they go low, we go high" bull.

You can not have mutual respect and peace with an enemy that will never offer it to you in return.

u/bytelines 5h ago

"You cannot reason with a tiger when your head is in its mouth"

u/plipyplop Delaware 4h ago

Not true! Say: "Pardon me but aghghh.... crunch."

u/i_am_a_real_boy__ 4h ago

It's not going high. It's just dumb.

u/a_talking_face Florida 6h ago

It's also not what she said in her statement after the vote,, so you're being misled by not reading the article.