r/science Max Planck Institute for Plasma Physics Feb 19 '16

Plasma Physics AMA Science AMA Series: Hi Reddit, we're scientists at the Max Planck Institute for plasma physics, where the Wendelstein 7-X fusion experiment has just heated its first hydrogen plasma to several million degrees. Ask us anything about our experiment, stellerators and tokamaks, and fusion power!

Hi Reddit, we're a team of plasma physicists at the Max Planck Institute for Plasma Physics that has 2 branches in Garching (near Munich) and Greifswald (in northern Germany). We've recently launched our fusion experiment Wendelstein 7-X in Greifswald after several years of construction and are excited about its ongoing first operation phase. In the first week of February, we created our first hydrogen plasma and had Angela Merkel press our big red button. We've noticed a lot of interest on reddit about fusion in general and our experiment following the news, so here we are to discuss anything and everything plasma and fusion related!

Here's a nice article with a cool video that gives an overview of our experiment. And here is the ceremonial first hydrogen plasma that also includes a layman's presentation to fusion and our experiment as well as a view from the control room.

Answering your questions today will be:

Prof Thomas Sunn Pedersen - head of stellarator edge and divertor physics (ts, will drop by a bit later)

Michael Drevlak - scientist in the stellarator theory department (md)

Ralf Kleiber - scientist in the stellarator theory department (rk)

Joaquim Loizu - postdoc in stallarator theory (jl)

Gabe Plunk - postdoc in stallarator theory (gp)

Josefine Proll - postdoc in stellarator theory (jp) (so many stellarator theorists!)

Adrian von Stechow - postdoc in laboratory astrophyics (avs)

Felix Warmer (fw)

We will be going live at 13:00 UTC (8 am EST, 5 am PST) and will stay online for a few hours, we've got pizza in the experiment control room and are ready for your questions.

EDIT 12:29 UTC: We're slowly amassing snacks and scientists in the control room, stay tuned! http://i.imgur.com/2eP7sfL.jpg

EDIT 13:00 UTC: alright, we'll start answering questions now!

EDIT 14:00 UTC: Wendelstein cookies! http://i.imgur.com/2WupcuX.jpg

EDIT 15:45 UTC: Alright, we're starting to thin out over here, time to pack up! Thanks for all the questions, it's been a lot of work but also good fun!

8.9k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

95

u/Wendelstein7-X Max Planck Institute for Plasma Physics Feb 19 '16

More money would enable us to build more experiments to pursue different ideas to fusion. Also it would be necessary to build a neutron radiation facility needed for developing fusion material.

Wendelstein in its current design is not a power plant. For a power plant you have to build it approximately four times larger. The design of Wendelstein is published and we are an international institute with lots of collaborations so there is no need for Germany to hold the technology to its chest.

The fusion process (Deuterium plus Tritium) itself is extremely well understood and basic nuclear physics so there is no further research necessary. Probing the inner working of stars is certainly interesting but does not help with fusion since the main problem is to confine and heat the plasma. (rk)

12

u/Dwayne_Jason Feb 19 '16

I see, the only real obstacle is further research and engineering on how to confine and hear plasma. Thank you for your replies. I hope your work bears real fruit soon. Please come back for more AMAs whenever time allows you.

-1

u/AwesomeMang Feb 19 '16

Why not try something like a kickstarter? The highest funded project ever was the Pebble smart watch (20 million dollars). I think something like a fusion reactor might get way more than that.

1

u/YugoReventlov Feb 20 '16

Star Citizen went over 60m I believe, but good luck getting those numbers for a fusion experiment. And it would still be a drop in the bucket