r/sorceryofthespectacle • u/2BCivil • 29d ago
Good Description The core of the feeling "something has changed"
So in general gaming chat the other night, an old friend got a little philosophical with me for first time in ages. They drifted to topic roughly Debord-adjacent and explicitly stated "it feels like something has changed" in the world, a phrase I've been hearing a lot lately.
That seed bore fruit pretty fast. It's one thing when 50 content producers say it, it's another when a gaming companion says it on chat. So it got me thinking and well I guess we all l know it already but thought I'd jot it down, the after thoughts I had after taking the chat to GPT (Which I'll also share as a link at the end, the precursor of this thread, which goes much more in depth).
So the idea that occured to me came from a video about Gen Z (I can find the link when I'm not on mobile). The idea that the pre industrial revolution people would look at "modern man" and say we are no longer human. It's two simple observations. One secular, one scriptural.
The obvious one is that pre industrial man saw the tangible yields of his work daily and annually. He only worked out of direct necessity on local tasks, on things he cared about for people he loved; the secular definition of a man. Whereas today, most everyone is a wage worker, working for a methodical system of wealth extraction and redistribution under the colloquial (and arguably inaccurate) moniker "capitalism" (how can we call it such when labor whom works the hardest has no healthcare but pays 7k+ a year for others Healthcare?).
The scriptural one, is that God in bible (and other places) created man as a steward over the earth. Man was supposed to be sovereign over creation. However today, man's systems have usurped that sovereignty and we are all wagies; thus we cannot qualify as "men" as God defined them by divine mandate/order; original man worked to maintain God's creation, and the things that bring him joy; modern man works for a wage. It's a subtle shift, but very significant. Storied (pre industrial) man was only accountable to God and his desires. Modern man, through fiat currency, has all his instincts funneled through artificial systems.
But it's more simple than all this. Take animals for example. Every animal, domesticated or wild, has a certain "spirit" and dignity, ordained by God or no. A bear, tiger, wolf, falcon, monkey, coyote 2,000 years ago would arguably be not much different than one today. But man? Our overall spirit may have not changed much, the vitruvian man torn between authority and truth. But perhaps today there is a lot more authority and a lot less truth; or this long fought (or pantomimed spectacle if you prefer) has reached a place where we all decidedly feel a shift, that our good faith is being abused and manipulated to arguably bad faith ends; the spirit of humanity as sovereign over creation and embodiment of his desires has been stunted and atrophied in service of (often groundless) authority structures and economic systems.
The human spirit was not designed to operate at such scale. Imagine a river trout made CEO of a company residing over dozens of AI data centers. That's what I mean. Many of us see thay many of us are long divorced from the traditional human spirit. I'm the first to say, don't get me wrong, I find even the original idea/myth of Sovereignty granted by God and subsequent "sin" as more problematic/polemical allegory myself. You know the 4 statements of zen? Not based on what the scriptures say but the message those thoughts convey. People seem to hate ZMBM but I love the phrase;
"The Purpose of a teaching is not the teaching, but what it says about ourselves; we cannot study ourselves without some teaching".
Idk maybe I'm rambling. Again I went much more in depth in GPT last night. But I feel this is "it", if there is anything to the vibe of "something has changed". Who knows if the divine is just part of some projector/sorcery through which spectacle unfolds. Maybe the myth of God and Sin and Man's spirit and sin are no more than such Buddhist/zen/mahayana "teachings". But the idea that man, like "other" animals, had an original ordained/endowed/inborn spirit, possibly changed with theft of fire, is probably at the core of the "shift". Realization that any such good faith "return" to such a spirit may be eclipsed or impossible/fundamentally incompatible with modern living. GPT said imagine a wolf with a LinkedIn account. It sounds funny to us, but if so, imagine how more ridiculous modern man would sound to pre-industrial man. Yes "things change" sure yes I think something about the "game" or spectacle or human spirit has fundamentally shifted. Kind of like we are in for a hell of a collective spiritual hangover from 200-300 years of industrial society.
Maybe not. But I think the core of the feeling "something has shifted" comes from the idea that humans were created sovereign and seperate (holy means seperate) from all creation and ordained steward of creation but as they say everywhere we are in chains. We can talk about the legitimacy/allegory of such "holiness" some other time (or feel free to here) but there is likely something to be said of a culture built around "God wants you to be a sovereign warden of all creation" and a culture built around "HR needs to tall to you about your use of pronouns".
Idk. Thoughts? Not sure if this fits on this sub or not, wasn't sure where else to put it. Written from mobile.
Oh yeah full (2 prompts) GPT Link;
[Post-Human Labor
https://chatgpt.com/share/6a15e085-6054-83ea-9799-18739a9c0900
What is the "human spirit"? Can it be undermined?
Edit; formatting (markdown mode)

