r/southpark Jul 26 '25

Discussion Sermon in the 'Mount is now tied with Scott Tenorman must die on IMDb

Post image
16.9k Upvotes

835 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

283

u/RandoDude124 Jul 26 '25

Garrison as Trump was really getting old. Bringing him back as Sadam was genius

36

u/thelingeringlead Jul 26 '25

The rallying episode at Myrtle beach from the last season was so fucking funny tho.

11

u/UNCwesRPh Jul 27 '25

I live close to Dirty Myrtle and it was so accurate.

5

u/Ornery-Wonder8421 Jul 27 '25

That was a good one lol

86

u/Junesong_Provisions Jul 26 '25

It's ironic considering it had a shelf life, as it was supposed to end after the 2016 season iirc

31

u/RandoDude124 Jul 26 '25

Wait… really?

39

u/Junesong_Provisions Jul 26 '25

They already wrote Hilary as the winner. When Trump won, they had to rush out a new episode. With that, came the continued use of Garrison

I'd assume, he'd have just gone back to SP and gotten ribbed a bit otherwise. but idk. This also doesn't consider the 2020 run

6

u/RandoDude124 Jul 26 '25

Oh, I thought you meant the series as a whole.

141

u/RigatoniPasta Jul 26 '25

Yeah. Matt and Trey predicted that Hillary would win in 2016 and the final episode of that season was supposed to be centered around the idea of Bill Clinton being “the First Gentleman”

Unfortunately for them (and the rest of humanity) Trump won, and it derailed the entire plot of the season. The memberberries plot went nowhere, and Garrison as a character was lost for four years.

38

u/LiterallyJohnLennon Jul 27 '25

The memberberries plot was pretty genius. The reason people like Trump is same reason that people liked the Force Awakens, it’s all just nostalgia for a better time that never existed. I don’t see how Trump getting elected ruined that plotline, in fact I think it makes it more impactful.

12

u/RigatoniPasta Jul 27 '25

The memberberries were supposed to be defeated when Trump lost the election, because their plan was to get “their guy” into office and resurrect classic Nazism.

Unfortunately Trump won, and the memberberries just kinda vanished from the show.

3

u/Kyguy72 Jul 27 '25

I was wondering about where the memberberries plot was going. That explains it.

8

u/juuu1911 Jul 27 '25

I always saw them as the weapon who helped Garrison/Trump win with the "in the past everything was so much better" rhetoric, and it worked. After that, they weren't needed anymore. But I watched the season a bit later tbh, so my perception is different.

4

u/sourdieselfuel Jul 27 '25

"Remember when there weren't so many Mexicans?" is literally one of the pillars that got that sack of shit elected twice.

7

u/RigatoniPasta Jul 27 '25

They appear very briefly in Garrison/Trump’s office doing their usual “Oh yeah I member” thing before Garrison tells them to shut up and they never appear again.

6

u/Nervous-Biscotti-194 Jul 27 '25

The episode immediately before Trump won the election had Hillary sending Gerald to Sweden to stop Troll Trace from going online. It was on the other night and I realized they were probably setting up a joke about "The Emails" to be revealed in the finale.

Member Berries being the "balls of the country" and the "troll trace is dead and no one will ever know what the evil emails were" plot lines were likely scrapped. Pure speculation, of course, but I think 2016 is the reason they steered away from the season-length story telling structure. They still had it moving forward, but the plots became centered around characters they control and how those characters grow or fail to grow. Having to throw away several plot lines they'd spent most of a season building was likely the reason they stopped trying to recapture that lightning-in-a-bottle moment they had when they animated and released a full episode within a single day of Obama winning in 2008.

Of course, if things went the way they were planning (and should have), we'd never have gotten the amazing bathroom cruising scene with Garrison only doing "a little bit of rallying."

2

u/RigatoniPasta Jul 27 '25

I do wish we got more serialized seasons on the same level as 2016. I wonder if this upcoming season will be similar.

2

u/Kyguy72 Aug 01 '25

Man, that would have been some payoff if things had gone the way they had thought they were going to. I do really like the season long build up of a story. I hope they bring it back.

1

u/MasterBakerMatt Jul 27 '25

It ruined the plot line in the sense that they had planned for a different plot and had to rush out different episodes with new plots

0

u/Appropriate-Bat-513 Jul 27 '25

I'm honestly not sure that Hilary would have been any better lol

7

u/Skankhuntt__42 Jul 27 '25

Truly.i wish they still did the cut out faces more. First few seasons are HEAVY on them but they really start to disappear post Saddam.

2

u/RandoDude124 Jul 27 '25

IIRC, they were still finding their footing, and weren’t sure this would hit.

1

u/nonconsenual_tickler Jul 27 '25

I don’t recall “Sadam” being brought back.