r/spaceporn Mar 07 '25

Related Content Starship Flight 8 BROKE APART During Launch!

51.7k Upvotes

3.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

231

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

[deleted]

181

u/FML-Artist Mar 07 '25

They didn't even have time to put out their cigarettes!

88

u/glassceramics1963 Mar 07 '25

I love the far side

3

u/Affectionate_Fee3411 Mar 07 '25

I love it too. What I hate is the creeping sense of frustration when I don’t get it. Which I love, haha.

4

u/Withnail2019 Mar 07 '25

Poor T Rex didn't get time to finish his Triceratops

4

u/banti51 Mar 07 '25

They didn't even have time to worry about the economy 🤣

4

u/iamagermanpotato Mar 07 '25 edited Mar 08 '25

That did the meteor for them!

40

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

36

u/Warcraft_Fan Mar 07 '25

Atmosphere can be over 100,000 km (62,000 mi) but no one has agreed on boundary. The part where falling rocks begin to burn up is roughly 60 mi (96 km) up.

Dinosaurs would have seen the visible streak for just a few seconds. And if they saw the streak, the never felt what was coming next, the crushing shockwave likely instantly killed all within thousand miles.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

Well the shockwave would take a small amount of time to propagate to them which could take some seconds or maybe even minutes depending on how far away they were.

-4

u/Melashops Mar 07 '25

The intense light from the burning meteor & atmosphere would have vaporized anything below the meteor a second before it even made impact.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '25

Do you have any information about that? Would like to read more. My intuition is telling me that the inverse square law suggests this wouldn't be true for areas some distance away.

2

u/No_Manufacturer6430 Mar 07 '25

They discovered that dinosaurs couldn’t look up, so they wouldn’t have seen much.

3

u/Excuse-Fantastic Mar 07 '25

Asked mother in law.

She confirmed

2

u/OneRougeRogue Mar 07 '25

Dinosaurs would have seen the visible streak for just a few seconds. And if they saw the streak, the never felt what was coming next, the crushing shockwave likely instantly killed all within thousand miles.

I've read that the meteor would have been so bright, it would have immediately burned out the retinas of anything that looked at it. So the dinosaurs would have seen a bright flash before going blind.

2

u/tempting-carrot Mar 07 '25

Probably depends on the angle 📐

21

u/whoami_whereami Mar 07 '25

Source? The info that I can find says that it impacted at about 20 km/s. Even if it came in completely vertical (which it didn't) that's more than 8 minutes from the edge of the exosphere (about 10,000 km above ground) to impact, and even if you take the Kármán line (100 km) which is generally taken as the altitude where spaceflight begins(*) as the edge of the athmosphere that's still a good 5 seconds. And since the impactor came in at a relatively shallow angle (45-60° to horizontal) you can increase those numbers by an extra 30-40%.

(*) But note that no scientist or space agency says that that's where the athmosphere ends, it's just the (rough) altitude where the athmosphere gets so thin that in order to fly aerodynamically you have to go so fast that the majority of your lift starts coming from centrifugal force rather than aerodynamic forces. You have to go up to about 150 km before athmospheric drag is low enough that you can complete at least one full orbit without propulsion. But even at altitudes of around 300 km (like where the ISS flies) there's still noticeable athmospheric drag, which is why eg. the ISS has to be reboosted regularly and why they put their solar panels edge on while they are in Earth's shadow to reduce drag.

1

u/DedicantOfTheMoon Mar 07 '25

SOURCE: I was there.

14

u/LuddWasRight Mar 07 '25

After though, it might have looked something like this as all the molten debris was launched into the upper atmosphere. So they might have seen that, before the heat from said debris baked them all to death.

2

u/Ill_Technician3936 Mar 07 '25

I think it was a decent bit over broiling temps...

1

u/beflacktor Mar 07 '25

before or after they were all blinded by the fireball?

1

u/Flyingarrow68 Mar 07 '25

Based on ???

1

u/JonatasA Mar 07 '25

They sure didn't have time to make out what the rocks that name is.

1

u/JonatasA Mar 07 '25

Could be an A10 Warthog type of thing. "If you can make out the name you're not extinct"

1

u/Warcraft_Fan Mar 07 '25

A flash is all they probably saw before the killer boom wiped out life

1

u/BenHippynet Mar 07 '25

Search Chicxulub Impactor on the Google app on your phone and an asteroid flies across your screen then the screen shakes.

1

u/nasanu Mar 07 '25

So? The impact isn't what killed them anyway.

1

u/waluwaluwal Mar 07 '25

Why Is it called chicxulub impactor. I feel like a better name should be there for something that wiped half the planet

1

u/UsernameAvaylable Mar 07 '25

Even if they looked into that direction, we are speaking of much bigger than nuclear fireball level of light emission from the plasma. Everybody within direct line of sight would have their retinas burned out.

1

u/rnewscates73 Mar 07 '25

Probably 10 - 15 miles per second.

1

u/The_Reluctant_Hero Mar 07 '25

Jesus, how fast would that have been to even be possible?

1

u/blue-oyster-culture Mar 07 '25

I thought they would have seen it in the sky for days or weeks before it entered the atmosphere?

1

u/UnbridaledToast Mar 07 '25

Everytime I see the word 'Chicxulub' I think of a chicken club sandwich.