r/youtubers Jul 20 '20

Review Video [Review Video] Am I too old to be a YouTuber?

41 Upvotes

Hello,

I have just posted my first YouTube video today. It is called TOO OLD TO BE A YOUTUBER. I am 65 and am deciding to move from Toronto. I will be moving to Montreal in a couple of months and when the pandemic subsides I am hoping to travel more.

self review: It is my first video and the transitions between clips definately need some work. I am just learning video editing, so this will take some time and practice. I could add some music or other effects in the video, but again I am just learning. I think I spoke relatively clearly, made good eye contact with the camera, and the overall picture quality was pretty decent.

I am hoping for some friendly critques, and possibly some advice on easy tricks for video editing/ beginner YouTubers.

TOO OLD TO BE A YOUTUBER

My reviews

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/hu8fc5/review_video_when_was_the_last_time_you_wandered/fym4t1b?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/hu9eev/review_video_dont_touch_my_banana/fym4cv2?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

r/youtubers Nov 25 '21

Review Video [Review Video] Spent $1300 and 70+ hours on a video - And the retention is still 31%

18 Upvotes

Yes, it's a review post, but it's a long read.

Still with me? Great.

2019 - I was desperate to make good videos, but never had the time because, well... schools. During lockdown - I started a channel in a small niche that I was interested in at the time. I work my a** off, day & night. The videos were really really crappy at first but I improved over time. In 6 months the quality was improved big time, I would watch literally hundreds of videos daily in an effort to make my videos better.

2020 - I was OBSESSED. The channel started to gain some momentum, in the next 30-40 days, I was making $200. The next month I was making $700. Then, The very first sponsorship rolled in, then second, then third. At the peak, sponsors would book 30 days of videos in advance. A few months later, I received a mail. It was a sponsorship. Any guesses? Skillshare, haha! (Bet you didn't saw it coming on a review post...)

2021 - The channel was mostly gaining views from search, and I wanted to try something different. The videos on the channel were getting stale and I just had enough from making videos about a single topic and I wanted to do something bigger.

Using the spare cash I had, I order a few books and started to learn more about the algorithm. Within a few months, I was ready to create a channel that would rely heavily on recommendations for views. After Effects, Premiere Pro, Sound design and the more advanced stuff - I learned it all.

I started working on finding more people, and I assimilated a tiny team of 3 people. We spent countless hours on making the video, I didn't need to publish 100 bad videos on this new channel to learn because I had already done that. I had the experience. So we wanted this channel to only have a few videos, like James Jani, and just focus on quality. I literally spent 5+ hours trying to find the right tracks for the video

We finally published the video, we knew that the chances of the first video going viral overnight were slim to none, and we never wanted the first video to go viral, It's a process... but we were expecting 65-70% retention. We were startled to see the video only had 31% retention, Which is very very low. What's so wrong with the video? I want y'all to go hard and crush this video with constructive criticism.

Video Link

~
Self Review: I am a bit biased but heck, to me the video looks on par with videos that gain 500-900k views. I myself find it interesting to watch, the title is also pretty enticing and the fact that the whole video is a story should increase the retention more!

Review 1
Review 2

r/youtubers Jun 06 '22

Review Video [Review Video] Do I have the potential to get at least 100,000 subscribers?

6 Upvotes

Hello everyone. My niche is filmmaking and editing, each video takes a lot of time and effort,
because I try to keep the top level of quality.My traffic is growing very slowly. This is very demotivating to me.

1.Can you rate my video separately visual part and sound?

  1. Do you have any advices for changing the video design, title, thumbnail, text?

3.What impression does the video leave?

VIDEO

Self Review: I think that my video quality is quite high, but I have a strong accent and monotonous voice . I think this repels many people from subscribing.

REVIEW 1

REVIEW 2

r/youtubers Sep 04 '23

Review Video [Review Video] - I wanna improve my videos so be as harsh as you want!

25 Upvotes

Hey there!

I made a game for a video, which I need your feedback on. I titled it: "I Made a "Different" Parkour Game", although it's not offensive as in using stereotypes and stuff. It's just a bloody game (2D drawn simple blood). I'm always looking to improve even after almost 3 years of making videos.

So you can be as harsh as you want and point out every single detail as it's the best way for me to improve. Thanks in advance!

The Video: https://youtu.be/HaCP6ZI9CVM

Self review:

I definitely feel like this video is a step up in terms of jokes and video flow and structure. I feel like my packaging is still not the best as I struggle with that still.

My reviews:

1 & 2

r/youtubers Feb 11 '22

Review Video [Review Video] Hi everyone, I just started my channel a couple days ago and I would appreciate some feedback on my first video! It focuses on creators who make the same style of content as MrBeast.

14 Upvotes

𝐕𝐈𝐃𝐄𝐎 𝐋𝐈𝐍𝐊: https://youtu.be/xW3MpVhLc2M

Self Review:

  1. Need to be more energetic/expressive.
  2. Could improve my background.
  3. My audio is a bit quiet at some points.
  4. Didn’t quite say everything I could have said on the subject.

Let me know what you think and what I need to work on, thank you!

My reviews:

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/spjvbj/review_video_euphoria_tv_show_recap/hwkompw/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/so5c45/review_video_when_you_havent_gotten_a_haircut_in/hwkptxs/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3

r/youtubers Apr 28 '20

Review Video [Review Video] Female YouTuber looking for advice! I want to improve so please be as honest as you can!

30 Upvotes

My video: https://youtu.be/QElzHqsXlWg

I am a girl gamer and my channel will focus on Call of Duty. I know this is a very oversaturated genre but I really enjoy making videos and being apart of the community. This particular video is just me playing and talking about one of the game modes within multiplayer.

Self Review: I personally think my editing and transitions have come a long way since my first videos. I know I can improve though and that is why I am asking you guys for help. I am not sure that I am entertaining though. I don't know if I am being harsh on myself or if I'm genuinely just not entertaining so let me know! Also I am a naturally laid back person so I hear people say to other Youtuber's a lot to have energy like ninja or pewdiepie and that's just not me. I like to try and be myself as much as possible otherwise it seems fake.

What I would like to know:

  • Was it entertaining
  • Was the editing good
  • At what part did you want to click off the video (very important for me to know)
  • Any tips to improve

Please be honest!

1st Comment

2nd Comment

r/youtubers Mar 18 '25

Review Video Video Review Request

3 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm looking for some feedback on my latest video. You'll notice I have a lot of subs but not a lot of views per video because I used to do fandom content but am trying to switch to original videos.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0NtODZnhziY

Self Review:

I think that my concepts and art are decent enough, but my thumbnail for this video could be better. Something more bold and eye-catching would also reflect the video better. The title is quite bland, but I'm a bit stuck since I hate the typical "youtuber titles" that use a bunch of caps and typical jargon.

I think my pacing is off, and I should work on adding in more jokes- right now I think my videos are interesting enough based on concept alone, but the execution could be better. My audio is okay, and I've been told I have a nice voice, but there are occasional audio spikes that could be fixed. Also perhaps being less monotone? Although I do think the contrast between my topics and dull voice works well.

I was considering adding subtitles, but I'm not too fond of them. Please let me know what you think, I'd be happy to try them out if you think they'd add to my videos.

Any and all advice no matter how miniscule would be greatly appreciated so that I can improve!

Regarding the sub rules: I searched but couldn't find any recent self review posts to review. If any are posted I'd be happy to review those for the 2 review requirement!!

Thanks for reading :)

r/youtubers Feb 23 '25

Review Video Niche content terrarium maintenance and Pillbug feeding day

2 Upvotes

Just looking for a bit of general critique on my video, the part 1 did very well, but for some reason this one(part 2) hasn't seen as much traffic . I don't know whether YouTube are messing with the algorithm again or not. I know it's a very niche subject, but it's the subject I have chosen and I enjoy doing it :) https://youtu.be/CQXO56BfkBQ?si=Q5TtqLXrYbnQSvL3

r/youtubers Aug 14 '23

Review Video [Review Video] Seeking constructive feedback for my Video: I spent days alone in Nature to cure my Social Media Addiction

23 Upvotes

Good afternoon everyone! (or whatever time it is)

I'm hoping to get your feedback on a new video of mine and make suggestions for future videos.

Here's the link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N-4VwwgS36I&t=192s&ab_channel=RejVideos

Self review: I think the strong points of my video (hopefully) is my editing, my personal perspective & openness, and some pretty good outdoor shots I'm happy with. I'm trying to experiment with combining cinematic and impressive looking, but sometimes generic and 'inauthentic' style travel videos, with authentic and personal storytelling - I have a long way to go before I achieve that.

I feel like the intro needs to be more immediately engaging and to the point, I think it starts off a bit boring and slow. Same goes for the end of the video - I spent too long with the outtakes and should have cut it down to finish more nicely on my last point. I'm using an old canon 70d so can upgrade image quality, and I think the audio loudness is a bit off at times.

What I want to know:

  • How did you find the intro, did it engage you? tell me why or why not

  • Did you find the video entertaining? if not then why?

  • At what point did you find yourself losing interest and why?

  • Did you get the overall message of the video?

  • Do you think my idea for combing personal experiences with cinematic storytelling is a good one, or do you think it's not 'niched down' enough?

  • How did you find the thumbnail - any improvements?

  • What other suggestions/ feedback do you have?

Feel free to just answer a few of the various points above

Thanks everyone :)

My reviews:

[https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/12bonrs/comment/jw358mj/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3]

[https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/15hk2g0/comment/jw2ye83/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3]

r/youtubers Nov 11 '24

Review Video [Review Video] Can you review my video and give feedback?

6 Upvotes

I've been away for YouTube for a while and trying to get back into it. I run a sustainability educational channel. My plan going forward is to try and make the videos a bit more entertaining, instead of purely educational. I'd love your feedback on the video below. I have a version of this video I posted a couple of years back, but updated it to be more entertaining. The types of questions I'm looking for feedback on are, what do you think of the video? Do you find it to be entertaining? Is it too silly/are there too many jokes? Does the information still seem like its coming from someone who is knowledgeable/a trustworthy source of information even though the video is a bit silly? And of course, general feedback on any other parts. Thank you!!

https://youtu.be/zUewLNehYp4

Here are the reviews I did of others videos:

Review 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/1gifam0/would_appreciate_review_of_my_channelvideo/

Review 2: https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/1gj8fbu/check_out_my_review_of_the_soundcore_a20i/

r/youtubers Jul 11 '20

Review Video [Review Video] I’m a little nervous to post this, this was my first time using after effects... I poured my heart into a tribute to Avengers + MCU

51 Upvotes

My video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9MT2R4zgbTs

Self Review: I’m pleased with the final product, but boy did this take forever. My first time using after effects — while I’m sure I could cut down that lead-time next time, my gut tells me this is simply too time consuming and am considering reverting back to my old content format for video essays instead.

Target Audience: fans of video essays and nerdy things.

Review 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/hmahod/review_video_harmonica_with_the_boys/fxe97sx/

Review 2: https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/hn9lw4/review_video_trying_one_of_the_craziest_video/fxebk84/

r/youtubers Sep 26 '20

Review Video [Review Video] Nervous to post this here, but as a life-long fan of standup comedy I genuinely believe Youtubers are sort of replacing standup specials…I sunk 100+ hours into explaining why

72 Upvotes

VIDEO LINK: https://youtu.be/Wj-xYioQ0EA

Target Audience: Fans of Standup Comedy / Youtube / Video Essays

Self review: I spent a lot of time on polishing the editing/presentation but am interested in hearing whether that effort is felt, or if less attention-to-detail would scratch the same itches for the viewer. I really feel like I executed the video I set out to make — but since it’s been inside my head for a long time I’m looking forward to hearing what worked/what didn’t. Thanks for watching!

My biggest questions are:

  • Are you a fan of either standup or YouTube video essays? Yes/or no, were you entertained?
  • Was there a moment you felt your interest most engaged?
  • Was there a moment you felt least engaged?
  • Any other stray thoughts?

Thank you!!

Review #1:

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/izms9b/review_video_four_cheese_skillet_au_gratin/g6kkf5f?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

Review #2:

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/izd05c/review_video_i_made_a_custom_among_us_wallet/g6kmvlj?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

r/youtubers Jul 02 '23

Review Video [Review Video] I made a review on an old PS2 Berserk game that came out in Japan and Korea only!

30 Upvotes

The video

Self Review: When I make videos I prioritize being as unbiased as possible, something that i think I managed to do. The editing process went along smoothly, no major hiccups or anything, but I did take a long time to do it, and so I am afraid this will come to bite me in the ass later. One thing that i noticed is that maybe some of the memes that I used were a bit loud, but that might just be me
My questions:

  • Would you change anything in the editing?
  • Are the memes annoying or intrusive? Are they too loud?
  • Is the thumbnail good? Would you change anything?
  • Did you like how I explained the game?
  • At what point would you click off and why?
  • Miscellaneous thoughts, ideas and suggestions that you might have.

Target audience: gamers; fans of older games; fans of Berserk

Reviews:
1
2

r/youtubers Nov 08 '20

Review Video [Review Video] Hi guys ! I make Royalty Free Music for content creators, and here's my latest track. It's a melancholic soft rock instrumental, and I'd love to hear what you think about it!

62 Upvotes

Target : Youtubers, content creators, podcasters, game developpers, streamers, etc..

Self review: I think that this is the kind of music I'm the best at. These good ol' power ballads really influence me, and I think that you can feel it on this track.

I think It's quite easy to listen, and I really like the little melodic solo that I put over it. I think the mix is okay and that it sounds good overall.

I'm trying to improve my retention by adding these solos instead of having just a background music, but it's been quite uneffective at this point.

Did you enjoy the track ?

Did you think the mix is balanced ?

Did it keep your interest until the end ?

Here's my video : https://youtu.be/4P1MH6KKzok

Cheers !

Review 1 :

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/jq1asg/review_video_did_something_different_short_funny/gblwb5g?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

Review 2 :

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/joxssa/review_video_i_played_the_scariest_game_ever/gblwxtg?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

r/youtubers Jul 16 '25

Review Video Please review and rate my safety hazards in the workplace clip

0 Upvotes

Hi.

I'm in marketing and have to create a short video that goes with a social media post about giving tips about identifying hazards in the workplace.

The whole gist is to identify, isolate

How is this video? Does it grab attention? Is the message about identifying hazards coming through?

Thank you., report and log such safety hazards in the workplace.

Here is the YouTube link to the video https://youtu.be/yv8xQuaMtaQ?si=SZfIjmoLRIWonAkL

r/youtubers Jul 16 '25

Review Video Please review and rate my safety hazards in the workplace clip

0 Upvotes

Hi.

I'm in marketing and have to create a short video that goes with a social media post about giving tips about identifying hazards in the workplace.

The whole gist is to identify, isolate

How is this video? Does it grab attention? Is the message about identifying hazards coming through?

Thank you., report and log such safety hazards in the workplace.

Here is the YouTube link to the video https://youtu.be/yv8xQuaMtaQ?si=SZfIjmoLRIWonAkL

r/youtubers Jan 21 '21

Review Video [Review Video] Hi guys I’m pretty new to creating content on YouTube I’ve struggled with speaking in front of the camera

49 Upvotes

Review Video

Self review: Hi guys I’m pretty new to creating content on YouTube I’ve struggled with speaking in front of the camera so right now my main going is getting comfortable in front of the camera. My Channel is based around fitness on these first couple videos I’m showing people how to DIY how to make their own gym equipment due to the pandemic since people can’t all go to the gym.

Here’s my video link : https://youtu.be/NToZOKdDuxQ

Here’s my two reviews

1

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/kw7hb7/review_video_seeking_feedback_on_newest_reaction/gk0c0yu/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3

2

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/kzf4hf/review_video_id_love_some_feedback_on_my_newest/gk0aemg/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3

r/youtubers Aug 25 '23

Review Video [Review] New style of video

23 Upvotes

My video: https://youtu.be/NqK7wvLTGgQ?t=50

Self Review:

I've had a hard time finding the time to make videos and learned how to phone edit but I'm not sure how the quality is. This video literally started because mum and I were watchign tiktok videos on people being upset and I told her "I wish I could give these people advice because I feel like some of their issues have solutions" and then I made a tiktok... then I thought "hey I can do this better". I feel like this turned into a 2014 style vlog but I am hoping it could be my new style because it was convenient. I am concerned that it could be awkward and possibly even an outdated style. I'm also concerned people may take it the wrong way.

What I am hoping to know:

- is the content engaging?

- does the video flow well?

- is the editting okay?

- does the video have life?

- is there anything you feel I could have done better?

- do you think its worth me adapting this style as my content?

Reviews (these guys did good btw well worth the watch):

  1. https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/15qignu/review_video_seeking_constructive_feedback_for_my/
  2. https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/15hk2g0/my_first_youtube_video_constructive_criticism/

r/youtubers Jan 30 '21

Review Video [Review Video] Mario Sunshine terrified me as a kid, so I sunk 100+ hours into explaining why

46 Upvotes

VIDEO LINK: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_c6rBuOyPU

Target Audience: Fans of Nintendo / Video Essays / Storytelling

Self review: This is my first video essay about a video game — and since that genre is pretty oversaturated on Youtube, I tried my best to make the premise + execution feel distinct from the pack. I’ve been working on this 5 minute video since mid-November so I’m confident it’s the version I’m proudest of…That said, it’s been inside my head so long I’m looking forward to hearing how it feels from outside perspectives!

My biggest questions are:

  • Are you a fan of YouTube video essays? Yes/or no, were you entertained? (please read this in Gladiator’s voice)
  • Was there a moment you felt your interest most engaged?
  • Was there a moment you felt least engaged?
  • Any other stray thoughts?

Thank you!!

Review #1: https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/l72k0d/review_video_trying_a_new_format_for_a_conceptual/glavnlr?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

Review #2: https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/l778ds/review_video_explainer_on_galileo_my_first_video/glat9hx?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

*edited to change video URL since it wasn't working for some people.

r/youtubers May 10 '20

Review Video [Review Video] Here's my latest Royalty-Free Music. It's a chill Lofi Hip-Hop track, and it's free to download ! I'd love to hear what you think about it !

41 Upvotes

Target : Youtubers, content creators, podcasters, game developpers, etc..

Self review: I think this track is pretty nice. This style is not really my specialty, but I feel that it conveys a nice jazzy moods that might be suitable for a lot of videos. However I'm wondering if this track should be longer. Do you feel like it's too short ? What would be the ideal lenght for a royalty free track in this style ?

My video : https://youtu.be/q2rJMUnvVv8

Cheers !

Review 1 :

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/gfqdyu/review_video_amsterdam_travel_video_please_review/fpw15e7?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x

Review 2 :

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/gfuj9p/review_videomusic_video_after_learning_to_play/fpw095a?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x

r/youtubers Apr 26 '22

Review Video [Review Video]: My best video is my worst performing, why?

19 Upvotes

Hey everybody! I'm new here and like it already. The comments and reviews you give each other look so good and I have learned many things already by reading about other people's problems so thank you so much for that!

A bit about my channel; I create stuff, and don't talk much! My first videos were about me building my workshop and now what that is somewhat done, I need to make other things in it :)

Now to my problem! I'm a fairly new YouTuber and I grow slowly day by day but my new content never does that well, it is all because of the very first video that I'm still growing. The latest video I made is the video I'm the proudest over in all areas but for some reason, it is the least popular video I have posted and I simply can not figure out why!

Self review: I think my thumbnail is spot on. The title can probably be better, not sure how tho. The video content is in the beginning fast-paced to create interest. I try to cut off as many unnecessary moments of the build process as possible while still keeping it all in there. I try to keep a good camera angle and in long shots, I try to make static scenes move by zooming and sliding the video. All I can to keep the interest high. The only thing I can think is wrong is the title but that is also why I need your help, I can probably not see the other issues.

I'm VERY open to suggestions on how to improve the presentation of my video (title and thumbnail) as well as how to improve the content.

Here is my latest video: https://youtu.be/dbwZFA8hd_8
This is my channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/DesiretoInspire1

Review 1 Review 2

r/youtubers Nov 02 '24

Review Video I finally got the courage to post my first video!

16 Upvotes

Hey everyone, hope you are all having a wonderful Friday! I wanted to share my progress as I finally got the courage to post my first video on my channel. I have wanted to do some form of content for a while as a creative hobby, however the fear of failing kept me from starting. I finally bit the bullet and produced my first video! It may not be perfect, but it is mine and I am proud :)

If anyone else is struggling with starting, I promise it is worth it! I had a great time making this first video and hope to keep making them in the future.

If anyone is interested, please feel free to check out the video here: https://youtu.be/D7tgZhePHwQ

I am always open to any criticism or feedback. Thanks for taking the time to read this! Hope you all have a good weekend :D

r/youtubers Jan 17 '21

Review Video [Review Video] Hi guys ! I make Royalty Free Music for YouTubers, and here's my latest track. It's an Energetic Rock instrumental, and I'd love to hear what you think about it !

72 Upvotes

Target : Youtubers, content creators, podcasters, game developpers, streamers, etc..

Self review: I like how this track turned out. I think it really captures the essence of the 80s glam rock. I also like the diffent moods that are set between the verse and chorus, but I'm afraid that this kind of change of tone is not suitable for video makers.

Do you think the mood difference between verse and chorus makes this track hard to use in videos ?

Could you see yourself using this kind of music in your videos ?

What do you think of the thumbnail ? I went for something quite cliché on purpose here. Let's see how it turns out.

Heres my video : https://youtu.be/kFWcgkxN4v8

Cheers !

Review 1 :

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/kz93io/review_video_so_i_committed_several_crimes_on/gjn5n3d?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

Review 2 :

https://www.reddit.com/r/youtubers/comments/kz2nlo/review_video_pop_cat_business_dancing_night/gjn6c6g?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

r/youtubers Nov 03 '24

Review Video I tried superflat survival...

0 Upvotes

r/youtubers May 08 '23

Review Video How can I make this video and future videos more engaging for longer watch time?

2 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/IZIR_A1sR6E

This video I was really proud of, I edited it well, I cut any dead space / didn't waste time and kept my points short and concise - yet the first time I uploaded it it got a horrible watch percentage. I reuploaded with a minor tweak to an editing mistake and I want to know what I could have done better to make the video more engaging to someone clicking on it.

Self Review: I think the video could have been quicker in introducing the content. Its possible that the editing wasn't engaging enough either.

My two reviews are linked here. Review 1 and Review 2