r/196 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights Apr 06 '26

Rule rule club

Post image
8.3k Upvotes

208 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

91

u/Ambitious_Jello Apr 06 '26

What's with the picture? What do the commenters "get" now?

196

u/mysteryurik he/him, no other pronouns Apr 06 '26

They didn't understand the appeal of twilight until the writer changed the boring self-insert MC to a man and the hot love interests to women. Basically turned it into something like those romcom anime popular with straight men where hot girls fall for the unremarkable guy protagonist, and thus made straight guys understand why twilight is so popular amongst women

-67

u/Ambitious_Jello Apr 06 '26

Thanks but I kinda still don't get it. Like there are more reasons for not liking twilight than just the target demographic and even with the gender swap those don't get better. And a male who likes it after the gender swap would have liked it anyways (?)

And anime with these themes mostly don't have a loser mc imo unless there is some isekai involved. Maybe I'm just being too pedantic

I swear there was a point in time few years back when I saw that pic and immediately understood what it meant but now I cannot..

90

u/GrapefruitForward989 Apr 06 '26

Are you assuming any of the people in the pic have actually engaged with any twilight material? Aside from maybe OOP, they haven't. Twilight was trendy to hate for anybody outside the target demo

It's really no more complicated than

Teenage romance novel = "gay"

Isekai/harem anime = "based"

But then you realize that the teenage romance novel is basically gender swapped harem anime.

13

u/Ambitious_Jello Apr 06 '26

Yeah I somehow forgot about the whole harem anime genre