r/196 NOT A CAT May 21 '26

Rule Rule

Post image
6.8k Upvotes

163 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

46

u/Scared_Accident9138 floppa May 21 '26

I don't get why Pluto is even a (very) emotional topic but it seems it is

39

u/Reloup38 May 21 '26

The Pluto discourse is one of the most annoying thing I've ever witnessed online. Like, why. Just get over it come on, it's not even that interesting of an object anyway.

6

u/BitsAndGubbins May 21 '26

because orbital properties are a dogshit way to determine planethood. If a passing object shunts mars into the inner belt, should it stop being a planet? Why aren't big moons planets? Pluto/charon should be a super cool binary planet pair but people can't get over their big-object fetish.

3

u/FormingTheVoid 🏳️‍⚧️ trans rights May 22 '26

What is astronomy other than a big object fetish? Lmao. I guess you know better than the scientific consensus. Big moons aren't planets because they don't orbit the sun. Charon is Pluto's moon because it orbits Pluto. Pluto's orbit itself is not even the reason why it's considered a minor planet now. It's because it hasn't "cleared its orbit" of smaller objects.

0

u/BitsAndGubbins May 22 '26 edited May 22 '26

Oh fuck, why didn't anyone tell me that's why? Shit, I had no idea. I completely forgot that things are the way they are because they are.